Seems a feasible strategy. If the UA are long-distance sensors/ distress flares and UPs are short-range high precision sensors/map message in a bottle, then UPs should be nearer to Merope 5C, and possibly significantly closer (like within Merope system, or adjacent systems) .
UAs, Barnacles and other mysteries Thread 8 - The Canonn
- Thread starter Yaffle
- Start date
- Status
Seems a feasible strategy. If the UA are long-distance sensors/ distress flares and UPs are short-range high precision sensors/map message in a bottle, then UPs should be nearer to Merope 5C, and possibly significantly closer (like within Merope system, or adjacent systems) .
Use Audacity (freeware). Open the soundfile, click left on file -> spectogram.
If it all lined up nicely, then everything would be distorted. The ellipse, the grid, the angled lines, all of it. But here we have distinct grid lines, and there's no way to get an ellipse to fit using the center of the grid lines.
Look:
http://imgur.com/a/uIrFQ
Somebody did that AFTER we found a barnacle, and found an X over where a barnacle was already known to be.
Has anyone found any other X on any other planet, much less found any other barnacle with this method?
- - - - - Additional Content Posted / Auto Merge - - - - -
Audacity is a common and free audio program. A spectrogram is a common thing that any audio editing program will have.
Last edited:
Hi I've been trying to join this discussion for some time now.
I'm aware that folks can get 'thought blinkers' on but could somebody please help me try to contribute something to this?
I have been trying to upload an image I thought may be helpful. If somebody could please help I'd really appreciate it.
I have an image saved in the correct format but the forum keeps saying the file is invalid.
If nobody can help I'll leave you guys to it.
From my image (when I can post it) and looking the spectogram I reckon the spectogram is four parts that line up. I reckon that that the image lines up to a group of stars and that once the images are lined up in the correct orientation we'll be pointed to somewhere. I could be entirely wrong of course but I'd like to post my off the cuff musings anyway in case it sets somebody off thinking about things differently.
I'm aware that folks can get 'thought blinkers' on but could somebody please help me try to contribute something to this?
I have been trying to upload an image I thought may be helpful. If somebody could please help I'd really appreciate it.
I have an image saved in the correct format but the forum keeps saying the file is invalid.
If nobody can help I'll leave you guys to it.
From my image (when I can post it) and looking the spectogram I reckon the spectogram is four parts that line up. I reckon that that the image lines up to a group of stars and that once the images are lined up in the correct orientation we'll be pointed to somewhere. I could be entirely wrong of course but I'd like to post my off the cuff musings anyway in case it sets somebody off thinking about things differently.
I totally get that, and take pretty much everything he says with a very large pinch of NaCl! I'm merely following up on a previous post that mentioned his comments regarding crashed alien ships (he re-iterates this claim toward the end of the video) and found this particular comment quite specific, but not true as far as I knew.
Last edited:
Register with Imgur and upload there. attach the photo but as a URL link and it will be on the post.
I've posted this before but I feel the need to post it again. I want to encourage everyone to take the time to read this. It is a very good insight into the thought process of these kind of messages.
http://activeseti.org/papers/evpatoria07.pdf
I can't stress it enough. If we are to solve this (provided there is something to solve) we need to approach it with a defined ruleset supporting our lines of inquiry. Just as LordZoltan said before, without a specific methodology which prevents rampant speculation all we'll manage to do is to fill time until FD throws the source of this in our face with one of the next updates. Reading this and similar documents is a very good starting point in developing this methodology.
Apparently xcyber posted a more extensive explanation for the Evpatoria message before in the thread and I missed it. Here it is once more for visibility http://www.plover.com/misc/Dumas-Dutil/messages.pdf.
http://activeseti.org/papers/evpatoria07.pdf
I can't stress it enough. If we are to solve this (provided there is something to solve) we need to approach it with a defined ruleset supporting our lines of inquiry. Just as LordZoltan said before, without a specific methodology which prevents rampant speculation all we'll manage to do is to fill time until FD throws the source of this in our face with one of the next updates. Reading this and similar documents is a very good starting point in developing this methodology.
Apparently xcyber posted a more extensive explanation for the Evpatoria message before in the thread and I missed it. Here it is once more for visibility http://www.plover.com/misc/Dumas-Dutil/messages.pdf.
Last edited:
Very true, and in thread #7, I mentioned this very anomaly with the misaligned grid and think it may be that we're looking at a depression, possibly even a crater, especially as my main area of research has been around the prominent crater on Merope 5c.
I did post this in a previous comment but it got lost due to the sheer volume of comments, so started a thread over on Reddit:
https://www.reddit.com/r/Canonn/comments/4uazuq/merope_5c_crater_investigation/
Last edited:
Thanks. I was hoping there might be some kind of greeting - response pairing; something specific the probe responds to rather than simply blasting everything that scans it with this message.
Let me say I'm 100% with MadDogMurdock here, and if you check something like 7000 post back, immediately after the first binary interpretation of the symbols, I've immediately raised the same objection. And the difference in spacing is VERY CLEAR.
And it is even easier to note it, because the two pictograms on the left side, the -|- and the | - - are composed by the same "dash'n dots" EXACTLY, that are one | and two -, so their length, the pictograms width, should be exactly the same. That is not. And the left and right margins of the 4 pictos are perfectly aligned, so please, don't tell me there is a distortion.
MOREOVER:
it really is a misfortune, IMHO, that the interpratation of 3.142 is, by misfortune as I said, made of the same four numbers that make the most basic sequence in the universe, I mean: 1,2,3,4.
Really, why is there a need to let us know Pi ?! What use can we do of it?
It's not a real message from Aliens: it's David Braben and Michael Brookes fooling us with a riddle
Those pictograms, being either in a group or four, or two groups of two, mean something else.
Last edited:
I meant to comment on your last post about this. I have a feeling this has got some legs.
Let me say I'm 100% with MadDogMurdock here, and if you check something like 7000 post back, immediately after the first binary interpretation of the symbols, I've immediately raised the same objection. And the difference in spacing is VERY CLEAR.
And it is even easier to note it, because the two pictograms on the left side, the -|- and the | - - are composed by the same "dash'n dots" EXACTLY, that are one | and two -, so their length should be exactly the same. That is not. And the left and right margins of the 4 pictos are perfectly aligned, so please, don't tell me there is a distortion.
MOREOVER:
it really is a misfortune, IMHO, that the interpratation of 3.142 is, by misfortune as I said, made of the same four numbers that make the most basic sequence in the universe, I mean: 1,2,3,4.
Really, why is there a need to let us know Pi ?! What use can we do of it?
It's not a real message from Aliens: it's David Braben and Michael Brookes fooling us with a riddle
Those pictograms, being either in a group or four, or two groups of two, mean something else.
I agree wholeheartedly.
The bottom row being some kind of a (| - - - - |) being a kind of boundary to define the meaningful part of the message is a likelier to me than they are numbers, because of the above-mentioned facts in MadDog's post.
man, I posted more explained version of Evpatoria few pages ago. Please read thread better. So, posted again: http://www.plover.com/misc/Dumas-Dutil/messages.pdf
There are so many posts, I missed yours somehow.
I'll edit mine to include your link so visibility will be better.
Let me say I'm 100% with MadDogMurdock here, and if you check something like 7000 post back, immediately after the first binary interpretation of the symbols, I've immediately raised the same objection. And the difference in spacing is VERY CLEAR.
And it is even easier to note it, because the two pictograms on the left side, the -|- and the | - - are composed by the same "dash'n dots" EXACTLY, that are one | and two -, so their length, the pictograms width, should be exactly the same. That is not. And the left and right margins of the 4 pictos are perfectly aligned, so please, don't tell me there is a distortion.
MOREOVER:
it really is a misfortune, IMHO, that the interpratation of 3.142 is, by misfortune as I said, made of the same four numbers that make the most basic sequence in the universe, I mean: 1,2,3,4.
Really, why is there a need to let us know Pi ?! What use can we do of it?
It's not a real message from Aliens: it's David Braben and Michael Brookes fooling us with a riddle
Those pictograms, being either in a group or four, or two groups of two, mean something else.
I'm going to disagree on the sizing of the pictograms argument mainly because the image is being warped along a logarithmic scale there are bound to be discrepancies in the sizing. The shape of the circle ... etc...
Didn't find anything unusual there but it was still the first crater of that kind I ever saw...
http://imgur.com/a/KFxrZ
Whatever imgur changed - can't link the picture directly -_-
http://imgur.com/a/KFxrZ
Whatever imgur changed - can't link the picture directly -_-
I don't think they are.
On page 3 of this monster thread I posted a solution, with coords, that works off the theory that the upper hemisphere tells you how to read the circular template and also orient yourself on merope 5c.
The lower hemisphere gives the coordinates.
The "1" and "2" of the top quadrants are exactly that and to be read in order. The bottom quadrants indicate they are two halves of a pair...of coordinate's and how to lay them out to read them.
Although I didn't go into that much detail on page 3, that's how I pulled the coordinates.
It covers a very big area though!
on this forum thread, a few pages ago is like a nanosecond that is a few million miles away.
don't stress
- Status