Here we go again...
Given a planets's criteria for Barnacle's (non-icy, landable, certain temperature) does the wailing only occur when it's near a matching planet? That should be testable.
And it has been tested. The UP wails at
ALL planetary bodies. Terraformables, ELWs, Barnacle sites, Gas giants, ice moons, ALL. If there is a planetary body it doesn't wail at, we haven't found it yet. Ask Bungalo (iirc) for his test results.
Or you haven't dropped it closer to another major hub.. and the Pleiades is just the closest place to point?
One of the first things RiZ@L did was take it out to the Col 70 sector. That's actually where the UP replied the first time iirc. It still points to Merope, and the image is the same as all the subsequent ones. If it behaves differently somewhere we haven't found that location yet, but distance does not seem to matter at all. Exact location may.
Hello All,
I posted a probable solution for the UP mystery over on Reddit yesterday...
<snip>
Additionally, the "2" arc is the real question. I think it shows us one of two things:
1) Where the UA shell ends, 2x radial distance from Merope (boring)
2) Where a second shell is, where we may find "free floating" UP (less boring)
So the 2x radial distance is likely 2x the radius outside the shell, or 254 LY out from Merope.
Testable aspects of this theory:
1) Search systems 127 LY away from Merope for UA
2) Search systems 254 LY away from Merope for UP (or slightly less than that for UA)
That is some good reverse engineering. I like your numbers, even though they are selected a bit arbitrarily (unconfirmed inner radius of UA shell). The fit very nicely, and the 127 may not have anything to do with the UA shell, but we'll figure that out later.
I would however remove your speculation about what we will find in the sectors mentioned. First off to keep an open mind, do tests, note results. Test again and doublecheck results. Going in looking for something makes any discovery biased towards that thing.
Secondly, it makes no sense for anything to tell us "here are more UAs/UPs". Why would that be interesting to anyone? Like I said earlier, "Hey you found me. Want to find more of me? Go here!". That's just silly as it doesn't lead to anything, only more UPs. It's a circular move,
unless the Free Floating UPs show a different image or hold different information from the "captured" ones. I highly doubt that they do.