Gonna play a bit first, I'm bored, these are not just floating, they're way out of position.
Stop posting this ridiculous misinformation. None of new two ruins show up on ship scanner. I just checked 3rd ruins.
One thought.. on a tidally locked body it might "make sense" (to the guardians) to place their equivalent of the 0 longitude line at the point which is always facing the parent body. So.. would it be worth measuring the human longitude value for this point, and taking the difference between this and the site longitude. If we do this for each site, and they come out to the same value that would be pretty sweet.
Actually that is something we do today. The Moon's prime meridian points directly at Earth, Titan's at Saturn, and Pluto and Charon at each other. However, one tidally locked body I travelled to in order to check this out in game didn't follow suit, so I think FDev dropped a bit of a scientific clanger there
More than likely a bug. I've come across outcrops marked by tiny blue dots on the radar. Maybe one accidentally spawned within the ruins. I've been at the new ruins all afternoon and saw no such blue POI dot. Even left to visit the Brain Trees and came back and still no blue dot over the ruins.For 3rd site I can Validate that I can see a light blue dot up to 9-10 km in solo at least. It shows up near the V shaped obelisk group.
Appears much like a barnacle dot.
More than likely a bug. I've come across outcrops marked by tiny blue dots on the radar. Maybe one accidentally spawned within the ruins. I've been at the new ruins all afternoon and saw no such blue POI dot. Even left to visit the Brain Trees and came back and still no blue dot over the ruins.
For 3rd site I can Validate that I can see a light blue dot up to 9-10 km in solo at least. It shows up near the V shaped obelisk group.
Appears much like a barnacle dot.
Apologies if this sounds a crazy theory - and if someone else has already said it - but I believe I may understand what is going on with the duplicates etc. and possibly help us work out how many sites there are. And perhaps even understand the bugs a bit.
Beta site (the original) is meant to contain 13 data packages, but we can get 36. What if the copy is meant to have the next 13 of middle band... and therefore a 3rd copy hold the last 13? If that is true, then might there be 2 or 3 copies of Apha site (11 in solo and 32 in total I think). That means that there is a third 'type' of site to find (Gamma) with the final band of data packages (I am assuming 2 or 3 of those too).
I thought about Guardians and why these moons are around ruins. Maybe they wanted to shield themselves from unwanted sun rays/radiation this way. Whats the other reason for placing ruins so in similar way, Frontier [cool].
Thats solid idea. Yet still we just guessing coordinates.
I agree. This is why any theory based on measuring some number of degrees from the image/map of the site and turning those into lat/long values is almost certainly wrong, IMO. However.. Humans measure latitude from the equator (which is a physical place on a rotating body) and we draw latitude lines around the planet from 0 to -90 and from 0 to +90. The actual values don't matter as much as the fact that -30 and +30 are 1/3rd the distance, -60/+60 are 2/3rds, and so on. Given the guardians predilection for triangles these divisions seem relevant. So, theories based on latitude are, IMO, far more likely to be valid.
The same cannot be said for longitude, the position of the 0 line is arbitrary. Which is why my favourite theory based on lat/long is AdmlAdama's and it involves the position of the moon. With the first 2 sites, if you view the horizon from the end of the central ridge, you will see the moon rise from the horizon beyond the smaller circular structure. The moon then sets on the horizon beyond the larger circular structure. It therefore follows a path which does not go directly over the ruins, but passes to the "left" (using the typical ruins orientation). And, as such, AdmlAdama's effort so far has been in calculating the moons path and adding an offset to this path based .. well, this bit I don't understand.
The point is, however, that the numbers AdmlAdama is coming up with do seem to match the ruin sites. So, were I a betting man I would place my bet on this method producing results. If I had more game time I would be picking lat/long values off the "Parallel orbit coordinates" list posted by Suteksio here:
https://forums.frontier.co.uk/showt...9-The-Canonn?p=5087002&viewfull=1#post5087002
I would start with -31.763541854905036,109.5244473160258 personally, as I think anything near -/+30 or 60 is more likely.
Based on this:
I took measurements to calculate possible coordinates in one of the candidates. This are for Synuefe XO-P c22-17 AB 3
Lunar orbit coordinates
----------------
0.0432,107.3961
-0.5526034953194522,115.33162594630078
-1.1378221376809388,123.26872473191094
-1.701237712093077,131.20897445667362
-2.232033101483398,139.15371501335233
-2.719994828618564,147.1039458365779
-3.1557081467584767,155.0602486046068
-3.5307412164051115,163.02274101775595
-3.8378143583569853,170.99106568144148
-4.070949970463688,178.96441557461497
-4.225598564938569,-173.05840526453082
-4.298736620160258,-165.07889012579497
-4.288932587484494,-157.0987140833345
-4.19637842552382,-149.11960369809788
-4.02288536096626,-141.14320252460521
-3.7718440525411685,-133.17094337823514
-3.448150791602696,-125.20393767916707
-3.0581026412290995,-117.24289059847202
-2.6092653625961924,-109.28804840024566
-2.1103185269925655,-101.33918158875872
-1.5708823561592464,-93.39560454044154
-1.0013306286904013,-85.45622950499066
-0.412593541119921,-77.51965040872801
0.184046148788291,-69.58424991709758
0.7771609068287029,-61.64832177080648
1.3553877432943842,-53.71019951209916
1.9076368546891933,-45.7683823537449
2.4232972911631045,-37.821649105169335
2.8924370344435033,-29.869151761800232
-0.0432,-72.6039
0.5526034953194522,-64.66837405369922
1.1378221376809388,-56.731275268089064
1.701237712093077,-48.791025543326384
2.232033101483398,-40.846284986647674
2.719994828618564,-32.89605416342209
3.1557081467584767,-24.939751395393188
3.5307412164051115,-16.977258982244052
3.8378143583569853,-9.008934318558516
4.070949970463688,-1.035584425385025
4.225598564938569,6.941594735469181
4.298736620160258,14.92110987420503
4.288932587484494,22.9012859166655
4.19637842552382,30.880396301902124
4.02288536096626,38.856797475394785
3.7718440525411685,46.82905662176486
3.448150791602696,54.79606232083293
3.0581026412290995,62.757109401527984
2.6092653625961924,70.71195159975434
2.1103185269925655,78.66081841124128
1.5708823561592464,86.60439545955846
1.0013306286904013,94.54377049500934
0.412593541119921,102.48034959127199
-0.184046148788291,110.41575008290242
-0.7771609068287029,118.35167822919351
-1.3553877432943842,126.28980048790083
-1.9076368546891933,134.2316176462551
-2.4232972911631045,142.17835089483066
-2.8924370344435033,150.13084823819977
Parallel orbit coordinates
----------------
0.039085271179236124,82.18595073810964
-25.687582673005274,113.31520716018983
-26.276526408371684,121.29776522773933
-26.84625249266012,129.32206326875692
-27.38547550228442,137.38845870887022
-27.8833415427846,145.49617379293787
-28.32966981703617,153.64318671598784
-28.715195314000137,161.8261782620126
-29.031804409954397,170.04054703373268
-29.272753572796546,178.280501721554
-29.43286045260635,-173.4607677681794
-29.50865674454863,-165.19084647870176
-29.498493508700758,-156.91779224255237
-29.402592108789875,-148.64979670500472
-29.223037341094873,-140.39483576161555
-28.96371322060958,-132.1603370277651
-28.6301857203929,-123.95288973221358
-28.229539983355824,-115.77801703479359
-27.770181738817918,-107.6400232548957
-27.26161366578589,-99.541920213525
-26.7141972865481,-91.48542915209582
-26.1389098714993,-83.47104849288627
-25.547104123781054,-75.4981735832421
-24.950276450279585,-67.56525259128159
-24.35984772829141,-59.669962617934495
-23.786958870961122,-51.809391389234854
-23.242282303373923,-43.98021208107565
-22.73584971508503,-36.17884145582794
-22.27689611157789,-28.401574221592785
-0.039085271179245096,-97.81404926189035
-24.583053836850784,-66.66662885958594
-24.002203228341372,-58.66584082839949
-23.445570236288436,-50.626054693810985
-22.923449634881642,-42.54809358453125
-22.445396939392612,-34.43363158590324
-22.02008254288249,-26.285231104752025
-21.655162219299896,-18.10634786551586
-21.357164317991007,-9.901296176479677
-21.131394241067536,-1.675170215105804
-20.981857000499357,6.566278937773333
-20.911198738160227,14.816806386198614
-20.92066803305572,23.069868246413286
-21.010097620777156,31.318836312206297
-21.17790684344938,39.55721839702153
-21.421124786648615,47.77886953659658
-21.735433705504843,55.97818028864223
-22.11523205666173,64.15023096212055
-22.55371628463069,72.29090435158159
-23.042980487028185,80.39695389456891
-23.574133201204152,88.46602851807476
-24.13743078094526,96.49665925092545
-24.7224271011052,104.48821553422715
-25.31813954837155,112.44084080357281
-25.913231318272622,120.3553772519001
-26.496209827847952,128.23328876892361
-27.055640469936304,136.07658908109556
-27.580373915491617,143.88777938813996
-28.05978371413768,151.66979670976505
More than likely a bug. I've come across outcrops marked by tiny blue dots on the radar. Maybe one accidentally spawned within the ruins. I've been at the new ruins all afternoon and saw no such blue POI dot. Even left to visit the Brain Trees and came back and still no blue dot over the ruins.
How about this theory on Site Deja Vu:
FDev needed a way to debug all of the issues with the original site, both the networking issues in multi-player (CTDs, adjudication server errors), and the obelisk reset issues. And suppose these errors did not show up in Beta.
So, create an exact duplicate somewhere else in the live game to serve as a debug tool. Allow FDev players to go in a PG to experience the issues, possibly add debug code or try out fixes in live, but not at the real original site.
Maybe we weren't intended or expected to find it.
Of course, against this theory is: why put it in a system we are told to look in?
It just seems so pointless to have an exact copy with the same decoded data that there must be some other reason for it, other than reasons that otherwise come to mind...
guys the ruins are reflections of Nebulas in the sky that schould help a lot limiting the space to search.
also it seems the planet must have a moon.
Take a look straight up when you are at a ruin![]()
guys the ruins are reflections of Nebulas in the sky that schould help a lot limiting the space to search.