ATR needs, IMHO, some serious reworking.
First, they need to NOT be using ships available to players. They are the top end elite system security personnel. They need full on military grade ships. Yes, stuff players (pirates every one of em!) can't get.
Second, they need THE TOP END engineering, plus a smidgen.
Third, they need to deploy as wings and work together, not as a group of independent pilots. They need wings that are designed to work together to take out the best and the baddest criminals can throw at them.
And last, but not least, they need persistence. If the criminal low wakes, the existing wing should follow them, as well as call in reinforcements, following the criminal and interdicting them non stop until they high wake out. And following even then if to another med or high sec system.