Never really put too much thought into fuel scoops, so it's really interesting to read this thread. My only strategy has been to fit the biggest possible on explorers and anything else gets something that'll fill the tank in 1 min 30s - 2 min. I always fit a-rated, since they get chucked into the bottom of the power priority list anyway.
Lots of feelings in this thread - please allow me to inject some facts:
Unless something major has changed, once you load into the system, you have the FSD Cooldown timer, and then the FSD Charge-Up time where you are going
exactly nowhere. If maximum travel time efficiency is what is desired, then your Fuel Scoop need only fit into this amount of time. Anything faster is not, in fact, saving you any time at all, though it does allow you to scoop at a higher rate from farther away. I find that benefit to be minimal at best, to be honest. If someone is the type that runs the tank pretty dry before scooping, then a faster scoop will (obviously) refill it faster per time, but most people don't do it that way the majority of the time. All your scoop needs to do, in most cases, is refill one maximum jump's worth of fuel during the FSD Cooldown/Spool Up time period.
Running a 7A or 8A scoop is an egregious waste of both credits and power. It's nothing to me if people decide to use those, but that doesn't change the truth of what I just said. 8D/7C are what they should be using, especially if they are also running thin on power.
And yikes, what the hell happened to my pic? It looks terrible in this new forum.
Riôt