I'm not sure anyone's been saying that they aren't? We just have different opinions about what they're up to and why. (And probably, I think, different opinions on whether they're supporting or opposing the Council)Reasons to believe the club are active in Colonia -
There was a Black Flight diamondback poking around the Comms Installation in Metztli, too, about a year ago. No idea what they were up to, but it didn't look authorised. I led them on a wild goose chase away from it and haven't seen them there since.1) Commander Hyford was murdered in Colonia itself by (presumed) agents of the Black Flight, an almost certain club front organisation active in the Pleiades
A different front organisation, at least, in this case. The attackers of the Luchtaine ship were shouting various anti-authority slogans and indicated their goal was straightforward terrorism. Not necessarily to be taken at face value, of course.2) Human prisoners have been seized (rather than cargo) from at least one bulk hauler megaship in the Colonia region, this fits with what we have also seen from pirates operating under the flag of the Turner Research Group
More subtly, you might also want to check out the BFS-396. There's nothing obviously troublesome about it, but it may be worth more detailed checks.