I collected a few illegal rares and visited Paul-Friedrichs Star & Thornycroft Penal Colony...
As expected, almost everything was illegal in PFS, but unfortunately it's an Anarchy, so no "illicit cargo" status, and I'm not sure if you would get scanned and fined in an Anarchy?
I decided to try a different approach on selecting suitable Stations - I have searched for similar criteria as before (Blackmarket, no permit etc.) but this time I have explicitly searched for Stations that claim to prohibit Liquor and Narcotics - I think this list might have better candidates
Tshang Hub in 23 Andromedae system looks very promising, they appear to prohibit the following...
{Beer, Liquor, Narcotics, Tobacco, Wine, Combat Stabilisers, Performance Enhancers, Progenitor Cells, Imperial Slaves, Slaves, Personal Weapons, Battle Weapons, Toxic Waste, Lucan Onion Head, Wuthielo Ku Froth, Trinkets Of Hidden Fortune}
"name","system","needs_permit","max_landing_pad_size","distance_to_star","sc_est_mins","faction","government","allegiance","state","type","has_blackmarket","has_commodities","has_refuel","has_repair","has_rearm","has_outfitting","has_shipyard","prohibited_commodities","economies"
"Brust Vision","HIP 54692",0,"L",615,2,"Angelic Order of HIP 54692","Theocracy","Alliance","None","Coriolis Starport",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,"{Consumer Technology, Liquor, Narcotics, Tobacco, Combat Stabilisers, Imperial Slaves, Slaves, Personal Weapons, Battle Weapons, Toxic Waste, Trinkets Of Hidden Fortune}","{Agriculture}"
"Goran Gmitrovic","Ross 788",0,"L",102,2,"Independent Ross 788 Progressive Party","Democracy","Independent","None","Coriolis Starport",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,"{Beer, Liquor, Narcotics, Tobacco, Wine, Combat Stabilisers, Performance Enhancers, Progenitor Cells, Imperial Slaves, Slaves, Personal Weapons, Battle Weapons, Toxic Waste, Trinkets Of Hidden Fortune}","{Industrial}"
"Brookes Abyss","Ross 788",0,"L",101,2,"Independent Ross 788 Progressive Party","Democracy","Independent","None","Unknown Starport",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,"{Beer, Liquor, Narcotics, Tobacco, Wine, Combat Stabilisers, Performance Enhancers, Progenitor Cells, Imperial Slaves, Slaves, Personal Weapons, Battle Weapons, Toxic Waste, Trinkets Of Hidden Fortune}","{Industrial}"
"Shalatula Ring","Holvandalla",0,"L",85,2,"People's Holvandalla Liberals","Democracy","Independent","None","Coriolis Starport",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,"{Beer, Liquor, Narcotics, Tobacco, Wine, Combat Stabilisers, Performance Enhancers, Progenitor Cells, Imperial Slaves, Slaves, Personal Weapons, Battle Weapons, Toxic Waste}","{Industrial}"
"Buffett Port","AR Lacertae",0,"L",351,2,"AR Lacertae Democrats","Democracy","Federation","None","Coriolis Starport",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,"{Beer, Liquor, Narcotics, Tobacco, Wine, Combat Stabilisers, Performance Enhancers, Progenitor Cells, Imperial Slaves, Slaves, Personal Weapons, Battle Weapons, Toxic Waste, Lucan Onion Head}","{Industrial, Refinery}"
"Savery Port","Idinda",0,"L",425,2,"Liberals of Idinda","Corporate","Independent","None","Ocellus Starport",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,"{Beer, Liquor, Narcotics, Tobacco, Wine, Combat Stabilisers, Performance Enhancers, Progenitor Cells, Imperial Slaves, Slaves, Battle Weapons, Toxic Waste, Trinkets Of Hidden Fortune}","{Industrial}"
"Bernard Gateway","Idinda",0,"L",100,2,"Liberals of Idinda","Democracy","Federation","None","Orbis Starport",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,"{Beer, Liquor, Narcotics, Tobacco, Wine, Combat Stabilisers, Performance Enhancers, Progenitor Cells, Imperial Slaves, Slaves, Personal Weapons, Battle Weapons, Toxic Waste, Onion Head, Trinkets Of Hidden Fortune}","{Industrial}"
"Poindexter Hub","Idinda",0,"L",99,2,"Liberals of Idinda","Democracy","Federation","None","Orbis Starport",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,"{Beer, Liquor, Narcotics, Tobacco, Wine, Combat Stabilisers, Performance Enhancers, Progenitor Cells, Imperial Slaves, Slaves, Personal Weapons, Battle Weapons, Toxic Waste, Onion Head, Trinkets Of Hidden Fortune}","{Agriculture}"
"Tshang Hub","23 Andromedae",0,"L",345,2,"New 23 Andromedae Independents","Corporate","Federation","None","Unknown Starport",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,"{Beer, Liquor, Narcotics, Tobacco, Wine, Combat Stabilisers, Performance Enhancers, Progenitor Cells, Imperial Slaves, Slaves, Personal Weapons, Battle Weapons, Toxic Waste, Lucan Onion Head, Wuthielo Ku Froth, Trinkets Of Hidden Fortune}","{Refinery}"
"Smith Port","Pathan",0,"L",204,2,"Pathan bridge systems","Corporate","Independent","None","Unknown Starport",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,"{Beer, Liquor, Narcotics, Tobacco, Wine, Combat Stabilisers, Performance Enhancers, Progenitor Cells, Imperial Slaves, Slaves, Battle Weapons, Toxic Waste}","{Agriculture}"
I've joined the Xelabara CG for now so had to sell my dodgy rares - I may do a bit more testing once the CG is complete