Urgh, emotionally over-invested fans are just the worst. If a customer tells you they're unhappy, the sensible response for any business is to listen to them, not say "But my cheerleaders love me, so bye."
Three very simple questions for this thread, because I can't even muster the energy any more to log in just to go buy the Type 10 and complete my ship set again these days, let alone bother with the beta...
1.) Are people really so self absorbed you don't understand pulling maybe hundreds of hours of tedious grind off people by resetting engineering would actually kill the wider player retention, and thus the game?
2.) If previous engineering is indeed grand-fathered in... Is Engineering still as hopelessly opaque as previously? Take Frame Shift Drives, you can't even see the effects on actual range on those; are we now comparing a secondary we need an external spreadsheet to work out the benefits of, to a system that doesn't even have secondaries? And then waiting for the hyper-nerds to estimate what the actual new caps are, because Frontier think mystery is better than content? How exactly are we going to know we have a comparative God Roll?
3.) And finally, what is even the point of bothering? There's nothing new to do. The "personalized narrative" is just another engineer grind with the same old materials to... what? Unlock new weapons to shoot the same old stuff? Or maybe, as with engineers, be forced to do another grind because the same old stuff is now buffed at Elite and you need those better weapons? But why would I? What's the point?
And that's before the inevitable round of horrendous bugs that'll sneak in to launch. The reason the forums have exploded with negativity is, in large part, because of the kind of toxic "positivism" that refuses to accept Elite really has very serious problems and which really do need addressing, and fast; We need actual new gameplay right now; but then people get patronized for trying to raise that concern. Excessive fan boostering for bad content isn't helping.
The saddest thing is, no matter how much you dote on Frontier, if the designs are in open beta... it's obviously far too late for any kind of feedback on actual full systems. What you see is what we're largely going to get. When was the last time you saw a game company actually even use public suggestions, by the way? Software types tend to be in the business because they want to implement their ideas; most of the "we're listening" is really just PR, they're never going to say "Wow, your idea was even better than the one I had, let's try what you suggested!"
It's just... urgh again. I'm not even sure why I bothered phrasing my questions. Probably just so those who still think it's worth trying to resist bad content can run with them. Because I suspect I already know the answers myself. How many months has it been since Horizons now?