Elite federation VS Star wars Empire. Who would win ?

[Remus]

So I just ended up watching Rogue one, fantastic flick I must add, on of the best right up there with the 3 first movies.

At the end I keep on wandering, what if at the end battle, a Farragut suddenly spawned from nowhere and sided with the rebellion ?

Would a Farragut battlecruiser completely obliterate an imperial destroyer ? Or the other way around ?

I can almost imagine the scene, where in the middle of the battle the following message was suddenly displayed on the comms. " Warning, capital class signature detected." Everybody would be like... ? :O

And BOOOM, here enters the Farragut in all its majestic glory, horns and everything, and begins giving the imperials a shower of fiery hell.

oh, and I added a poll, just because.

Vs

Who will win ?

You decide !

 

[StiTch]

Feds can't even handle ED Empire.

How is hull tanking gonna stand up to a death star? *chuckles*

 

[Remus]

Feds can't even handle ED Empire.

How is hull tanking gonna stand up to a death star? *chuckles*

Death Star proved to be a glass cannon, tree times they build it, tree times it blowed up, and by a small group of rebels no less.

 

[Vorxian]

Death Star proved to be a glass cannon, tree times they build it, tree times it blowed up, and by a small group of rebels no less.

I'd have made it out of something other than trees!

I voted Federation.

Imagine all them death star station campers in corvettes. The SW imperials would stand no chance.

Plus, in the SW the ships seem quite balanced. Just wait until one of them silly star destroyers meets an engineered FDL.

no chance.

 

[StiTch]

Death Star proved to be a glass cannon, tree times they build it, tree times it blowed up, and by a small group of rebels no less.

Less glass cannon, more "thick engineers and their exhaust ports"

Still, can also solo a Farragut with the right know-how (even before 2.1).

 

[Weps]

 

[Jason S]

Starwars is cool but I am bias to elite so no logic there just pure simple prejudice.

 

[MottiKhan]

Federation of course. Sure, Star Wars has superior technology, but have you ever seen a stormtrooper hit anything with a weapon?

 

[GunnerBill]

Federation of course. Sure, Star Wars has superior technology, but have you ever seen a stormtrooper hit anything with a weapon?

Also the universe's worst armour. You'd think it was just made of plastic...

 

[Remus]

Federation of course. Sure, Star Wars has superior technology, but have you ever seen a stormtrooper hit anything with a weapon?

Whereas elite NPC's are Deadly precise !

 

[zimms]

Given the Empire's track record, it's not even a competition. Hudson would wipe the floor with those amateurs.

 

[Marcusfalden]

Not even close a single Imp MK1 star destroyer would mop up any and Elite Ships.

 

[[VR] Deggial]

Star wars Empire, of course.

The ED Federation isn't able to land on or even attack installations on planets with atmosphere. How could they win a war without taking the enemy's bases?

 

[Azra'il]

Sorry guys, I'd be defecting to Revan's side. --- now if we're talking the era of Vader.. maybe not so much.

 

[Terry Bruge-Hiplo]

Star wars Empire, of course.

The ED Federation isn't able to land on or even attack installations on planets with atmosphere. How could they win a war without taking the enemy's bases?

They could always land on that small, non-atmospheric moon over there...

 

[kdjac]

ED

The SW ships wouldntr even get out of the ships for all the SLF ramming them.

 

[babelfisch]

The Empire has the better equipment and they are more awesome, but they are absolutely incompetent. The real question is: Who would kill themselves first?

 

[CMDR Corlas]

Star Wars Empire would win hands-down for the simple fact that Elite is sci-fi and tries to stick somewhat to reality, while Star Wars is fantasy, and doesn't give a crap about reality.

Rogue One was an excellent film though.

 

[[VR] Deggial]

So I just ended up watching Rogue one, fantastic flick I must add, on of the best right up there with the 3 first movies.

My partner and I enjoyed it, too. And I really liked, how they explained this silly flaw in the design of the death star.

Federation of course. Sure, Star Wars has superior technology, but have you ever seen a stormtrooper hit anything with a weapon?

Which made my girlfriend wonder, if they'll expain this in the next Star Wars movie as well: The clones for the clone army were deliberately designed with a flaw in their DNA, causing squinty eyes or terrible eye-to-hand coordination.

--

Star Wars Empire would win hands-down for the simple fact that Elite is sci-fi and tries to stick somewhat to reality, while Star Wars is fantasy, and doesn't give a crap about reality.

Yes, yes, yes, but the Federation will be able to rely on the help of many Pilot's Federation commanders - which are immortal, as we all know ...

 

[Ian Phillips]

This is not the comparisson you were looking for. (waves hand)

Edit:
SW has the force - of course it wins.