ELW bucket list

The question of "how rare is this" and a bucket list of ELWs to find has come up from time to time, so I thought I'd write one up now. I'll include some categories based on rarity, and at times, they'll be approximate.
For reference: the main star of a system is the one that's shown on the galaxy map, the first star.
Also, usually when I list a series of various things (usually stars or parents), then the first one is the most common, and the last one the least.


Let's see them then!

Common (>15%):
  • system main star type: F, A, G, K

Uncommon (5-15%):
  • main star type: Neutron Star
  • ELW has one moon

Rare (1-5%):
  • system main star type: M
  • binary ELW pair
  • system contains two ELWs
  • ELW co-orbits two or three stars
  • ringed ELW
  • ELM (Earth-like Moon) with HMCP (High Metal Content Planet) parent
  • ELW's moon is a candidate for terraforming

Very rare (0.025-1%):
  • system main star type: B, Black Hole, Carbon star, Herbig Ae/Be, TTS (T-Tauri Star), WD (White Dwarf)
  • ELW co-orbits four stars
  • system contains three ELWs
  • ELW has 2 moons
  • ELW has thin atmospheric landable moon
  • ELM with GG (Gas Giant), WW (Water World), K star, M star parent
  • ELM's parent is a candidate for terraforming
  • ELM has moon
  • ELW has landable moon with active volcanism
  • uncertain, but probably belongs here: no planets other than the ELW(s)

Good F***ing Luck with These, because at best only a handful have been found (<0.025%):
  • system main star type: L, T, WR (Wolf-Rayet), O
  • trinary ELW set
  • binary ELM pair
  • system contains four ELWs
  • ELW co-orbits five or six stars
  • ELW has 3-7 moons
  • ELM with parent other than the ones above
  • trojan ELW
  • shepherd ELM (orbits ringed parent body on the inside of its rings, not outside)
  • ELW has thin atmospheric landable moon with composition other than carbon dioxide or sulphur dioxide
  • ELW has thin atmospheric landable moon which has surface volcanism

If you found something that ticks more than one categories, then as a rough rule of the thumb, that pushes it lower one category at least.

As a note, Earth-like Moons (ELMs) can easily be identified by their name ending with a letter. For example, see the bolded part: "Preia Hypai SO-Q d5-4 1 f".

If you have any that I've forgotten, post them here please!


There's also a list of things not actually found yet, but maybe (maybe) possible. Even if they are, the odds would be astronomically low. Click the spoiler at your own risk, in case you'll want to find any of these.
  • ELW + ELM pair
  • quaternary ELW set
  • trinary ELM set
  • system with five ELWs
  • ELW co-orbits seven (or more) stars
  • Y system main star (most likely impossible, habitable zone would be too close to the star)
  • ELW directly orbits O star (most likely impossible, habitable zone would be too far from the star)
 
Last edited:
Trojan ELW: see the Wikipedia article.
Co-orbits: it orbits the shared barycenter of them. For example, an ELW designated [system] ABC 1 would orbit the center of mass of those three stars.
ELM with x parent: Earth-like moon, orbiting a parent body of x type.
 
Common, check. Uncommon both check. Rare all but ELM. Very rare just the last two. I am yet to experience good f***ing luck, unless I missed a trojan.
 
I think I've found everything in Common, Uncommon, and Rare (except maybe "ELW co-orbits two or three stars", which I'll have to verify), but very little beyond that. For some of the Very Rare, I may have to dig through my journals and look them up in detail.
 
I'm not nearly enough traveling enough … But I wonder into which category the ringed ELW around a Neutron Main star belongs. I guess into the very rare section.
 
I'm not nearly enough traveling enough … But I wonder into which category the ringed ELW around a Neutron Main star belongs. I guess into the very rare section.
Yep. And if you calculate it yourself, ringed ELW is around 1.9%, neutron star main is around 5.1% (there are some duplicates, but the difference is not significant), so the two multiplied is 0.097%.
Hm, actually that would push it into the upper border of GFLwT territory. But there are still 181 such ringed NS main ELWs, while the rest there don't really reach more than a few dozen... Looks like I'll need to adjust the percentage ranges then, I made a mistake there. I did write "at best only a handful", but 0.1% would still be around 200.


Oh, and if we're sharing track records: I found all in the Rare category and up, while for Very Rares, there's B star, co-orbiting four stars, ELM around GG, and ELW being the sole planet in the system. None of the rest.
 
Last edited:
Is this one rare-ish? It is a ringed ELW orbiting a brown dwarf with the primary star being a Neutron.

elw_ringed.jpg
 
Going back what I wrote above, definitely. NS main, ringed, ELM around brown dwarf star: rarities rack up there.
 
Which category would be an ELW in mass codes A or G?
In the very rare section I miss an ELW around a TTS and I am not sure about ELMs around F,G or K. Good f***ing luck I had with WD, Herbig, a pair of ELMs (not binary), ELW with three moons and ELM around a Y-Star.
 
Fantastic thread. It also inspires me to play more. And with the introduction of the FSS, I'd already changed my exploration style to ELW cherry picking anyway.

I already tick the commons and uncommons... now I have to check all my past ELWs to see what else I have ticked. :)

Thank you marx!
 
Searched my archives to see what boxes i could tick.

  • ELW orbiting M star
  • ELW orbiting B star
  • ELW orbiting L star
  • Ringed ELW in system with NS as primary:
gXb9Z4r.png

And my favorite trio. Not sure in which category these go, except for the last one.
- An ELM orbiting a lava planet in system with NS as primary, which is the central star of a planetary nebula
MOTri8l.jpg

- ELM with a moon orbiting a secondary M star which is orbiting a Black Hole
qpYpxxL.png

- ELW orbiting a Herbig in a system where the primary star is O. By the time i reported it, it was the only reported ELW in system with O as main star.
l3UUYx0.png
 
Back
Top Bottom