List of Earth-like worlds, v3

Edelgard von Rhein · Jan 6, 2017

The moon orbited by Colonia Dream does not orbit an Earth-like World. It is much too close to the host star (I think both planet and moon are landable) but it struck me that it had volcanism as I was thinking about potential sites for fumaroles etc. and the close orbit is evident on making the approach to the station in supercruise. If you still want a screenshot of that moon I can get one next time I'm logged on.

Qohen Leth · Jan 7, 2017

Haha, I'm drawing my list of DWE ELWs for you, and I just noticed I have an ELW orbiting an HMC orbiting a Neutron Star

So I have BOTH the Neutron *and* Herbig ELW, woo!

SpaceMonkeyz · Jan 7, 2017

Qohen Leth said:
Haha, I'm drawing my list of DWE ELWs for you, and I just noticed I have an ELW orbiting an HMC orbiting a Neutron Star So I have BOTH the Neutron *and* Herbig ELW, woo!

OMG!

I have a Herbig ELW and a few Neutron ELW but not both in the same system, that is awesome!

Qohen Leth · Jan 7, 2017

SpaceMonkeyz said:
OMG!

I have a Herbig ELW and a few Neutron ELW but not both in the same system, that is awesome!

Not in the same system! I have both, period x)

SpaceMonkeyz · Jan 7, 2017

Qohen Leth said:
Not in the same system! I have both, period x)

Well, welcome to the club!

osser · Jan 8, 2017

marx said:
Welcome back, Commander! That's quite the haul you have there. An ELW co-orbiting three stars is very rare on its own, but one orbiting a Herbig Ae/Be is one of the rarest kinds. Yours is the second one confirmed so far. Me, I've been to around five hundred such systems, but no luck so far. It's quite interesting to see that your planet's characteristics would be rather close to Earth's, if not for the whole "tidally locked to the star and a year lasts 5.5 days" thing. Oh, and the atmospheric pressure. Anyway, this one's definitely going on the "Earth-likes to visit" list for when we'll finally be able to land on them. Congrats!

Ok I got my gems:
An ELW orbiting 3 stars {class M & 2 T (not T-tauri stars}
But the real shinny is:
An ELW orbiting a Herbig Star (it was a E mass and 0 heat scale.) that would be #3 right Marx?
guess I should add I have a ELW orbiting a T-Tauri (c-mass 6 heat)

I'm loving this

osser · Jan 8, 2017

And here she is:

66ls from the star. that's kinda close

CMDR Tootiny

Qohen Leth · Jan 8, 2017

Here's what I could scavenge from my lost data:

System name

Planet ID

Dist. from Sol (ly)

First discovered by

Contributed by

System star(s) type

First star

ELW is orbiting star(s) type

One primary star?

Ringed EL?

Moons

Screenshot URL

Notes

TRAIKAAE AW-U d3-6

2

QOHEN LETH

F7 VB

Yes

http://imgur.com/QxSknyD

TRAIKAAE NX-L d7-151

B 7

QOHEN LETH

A8 VB, M3 VA

A8 VB

M3 VA

Yes

1

http://imgur.com/IQwjNNc

TRAIKAAE YP-G d10-44

AB 1

QOHEN LETH

A6 VI, K0 VAB, K0 VAB, M5 VA

A6 VI

A6 VI, K0 VAB

No

http://imgur.com/jl3cHAo

TRAIKAAE YP-G d10-132

6

QOHEN LETH

A8 VB

Yes

http://imgur.com/SXH7XVY

Paired with a WW

TRAIKAAE CW-E d11-19

3

QOHEN LETH

A9 VI

Yes

http://imgur.com/QLcSwQQ

DROJU MJ-O d7-32

7

QOHEN LETH

F6 VAB

Yes

1

http://imgur.com/g9xH6gm

TRAIKAAE PY-Z c13-19

A 5

QOHEN LETH

K3 VA, M3 VA

K3 VA

No

http://imgur.com/CCkKsr4

OEPHAIRD IL-F c11-475

3

QOHEN LETH

K5 VA

Yes

http://imgur.com/JINalOz

PRAEA AERB TH-V d2-3

2

QOHEN LETH

F9 VAB

Yes

http://imgur.com/ZsDDcce

PRAEA AERB VS-T d3-0

A 5

QOHEN LETH

F5 VB, G6 VAB

F5 VB

No

http://imgur.com/2OyYHUZ

BLU EUQ CW-E d11-37

9

QOHEN LETH

F5 VB

Yes

http://imgur.com/68rJgbC

PUEKEE OZ-S c19-4

A 3

QOHEN LETH

K3 VA, M7 IVB

K3 VA

No

http://imgur.com/ymMkZs8

STRANAEI FQ-P d5-193

6

QOHEN LETH

A8 VB

Yes

http://imgur.com/vx1CcGb

SHROGEA LQ-R c19-337

A 2

QOHEN LETH

M1 VA, L2 V, L9 V

M1 VA

No

http://imgur.com/XcnvWEX

AUNAIRM ZO-Q d5-174

5

QOHEN LETH

A9 VB

Yes

http://imgur.com/Rip5syb

HYPUAE SCRUA XU-N d7-139

4

QOHEN LETH

F8 VAB

F8 VA

F8 VAB

Yes

http://imgur.com/WaxESBi

NYUENA GL-Y d769

A 5

QOHEN LETH

K7 VA, M3 VA, L1 V, YO V

K7 VA

No

http://imgur.com/oAr4hmG

PHROEA FLYA NT-F d12-3869

4

QOHEN LETH

F9 VAB

Yes

http://imgur.com/rQFa0VO

Binary with below

PHROEA FLYA NT-F d12-3870

5

QOHEN LETH

F9 VAB

Yes

http://imgur.com/IvHvOYY

Binary with above

CHOOMAAE WK-W c2-1499

7

QOHEN LETH

G4 VAB

Yes

http://imgur.com/IPrI1bG

THEEMUA UP-F d11-892

5

QOHEN LETH

F9 VAB

Yes

http://imgur.com/PV0TV07

THEEMAA VZ-C c27-39

A 5

QOHEN LETH

G8 VAB, M0 VA

G8 VAB

No

http://imgur.com/bEOmLZ4

THEEMAA CG-O e6-415

1 A

QOHEN LETH

Neutron Star

Yes

http://imgur.com/lZUO57v

Moon-ELW + Neutron Star

PYROOMEE NS-Z c1-13

6

QOHEN LETH

K7 VA

Yes

http://imgur.com/bjB3GLD

HYPO AUF CH-J d10-18

7

QOHEN LETH

A8 VI

Yes

http://imgur.com/P7E89Rx

PHROI PRI OB-W c18-8307

8

QOHEN LETH

K9 VA

Yes

http://imgur.com/4D4Wq1K

SYSTIMBU BA-Y d1-908

3

QOHEN LETH

A8 VI

Yes

http://imgur.com/36rTmTA

EOK GREE BB-R c20-1086

A 8

QOHEN LETH

K6 VA, M7 VA, M6 VA

K6 VA

No

http://imgur.com/UGNK2lM

Paired with a WW

BRAIREE XZ-K c10-3367

A 1

QOHEN LETH

G7 VAB, M0 VA

G7 VAB

No

http://imgur.com/tN2bbW9

AISHAISH IB-O d6-3561

2

QOHEN LETH

F8 VB

Yes

http://imgur.com/6EiEzhf

GLAICHOO PN-E c26-1

1

QOHEN LETH

K2 VAB

Yes

http://imgur.com/CDUg4Nw

SMOOTAU HX-L d7-141

3

QOHEN LETH

F2 VB

Yes

http://imgur.com/QeoQ6hc

PYRAEA THAE TE-G c24-0

A 7

QOHEN LETH

K1 VAB, M4 VA

K1 VAB

No

http://imgur.com/3HX0ObH

SYNEAEYOOE RD-K d8-1

B 4

QOHEN LETH

A9 VB, K0 VAB

A9 VB

No

http://imgur.com/5TKEMv9

SIFI NZ-F d11-7

ABC 2

QOHEN LETH

F3 VAB, K6 VA, F7 VI, G4 VAB

F3 VA

F3 VAB, K6 VA, F7 VI

No

http://imgur.com/ekQrlwS

FROALT TA-C d14-270

B 5

QOHEN LETH

S3 IIIB, K4 VA

S3 III

K4 VA

No

http://imgur.com/VZdMHMi

IOWHAIL PJ-O d7-841

A 6

QOHEN LETH

MS4 IIIB, K2 VAB

MS4 IIIB

No

http://imgur.com/e0Hy3nz

Orbiting Carbon star

BYOO AIRG EL-V d3-137

3

QOHEN LETH

F5 VI

Yes

http://imgur.com/sqSMRBZ

BLAU AESCS NV-B d14-131

A 4

QOHEN LETH

F3 VI, M1 VA

F3 VI

No

http://imgur.com/jHJlvBK

PRO AEWSY HF-Q c21-4

A 1

QOHEN LETH

K4 VA, M3 VA

K4 VA

No

http://imgur.com/h2C7qk8

TOSIA CA-A d13

A 3

QOHEN LETH

A6 VI, F8 VI, K0 VA

A6 VI

No

http://imgur.com/zFEUur0

TOSIA OA-A c2

A 2

QOHEN LETH

K1 VA, K1 VAB

K1 VA

K1 VAB

No

http://imgur.com/MusQvtH

SPHUQOAE LO-Z c13-0

A 5

QOHEN LETH

K4 VAB, M5 VA

K4 VAB

No

http://imgur.com/cWsiK21

SPHUQIAE ZD-K d8-0

5

QOHEN LETH

F0 VI

Yes

http://imgur.com/scKuZ7l

ATHAIP VJ-R e4-6108

1

QOHEN LETH

Herbig Ae/Be

Yes

http://imgur.com/zrssfN7

Orbiting an Herbig

I formatted my sheet like yours, so I can send it to you and you can just copypaste it.

Sapyx · Jan 8, 2017

I have a very minor error to report.

I can't recall why I originally bookmarked the BLO AESCS KN-S E4-173 system a couple of months ago to include as a waypoint in my route; it may have been on an old list of systems we needed verification or more info on, or something. Anyhow, after arriving and scanning the Earth-like, I note that the entry for this planet in the current file lists the first discoverer of this planet as Cmdr Bigg Kepler, when it is actually Cmdr Clubfoot. In this system, Clubfoot tagged the neutron star, the third star and the ELW, Bigg Kepler tagged everything else. The picture Chiggy has given in that entry is correct in showing this.

I know it's only a minor detail but if you could correct this entry, then at least I wouldn't have taken a 1500 LY detour to visit this system for no reason.

marx · Jan 8, 2017

@ osser: Now I'm jealous. Looks like it's Herbig season these days. I've looked at around 600 of them so far, not a single ELW - although there was one water world that came very close to being Earth-like. Then the alien encounters happened, so now I'll give those Ae/Be-s a rest. Looking forward to getting the data from yours when you have it tagged!

@ Qohen Leth: Thanks! I'll look up the distances later, might take some time. I did add your double Herbig system before though, so that's already in.

@ Sapyx: Thanks for the heads-up! That's fixed now. Good luck on your way back!

Maleks · Jan 8, 2017

Submitting 3 ELW's found in two systems:

1. ELW with ring:

Code:

[TABLE="class: grid, width: 1500"]
[TR]
[TD="align: center"][B]System name[/B][/TD]
[TD="align: center"][B]Planet ID[/B][/TD]
[TD="align: center"][B]Dist. from Sol (ly)[/B][/TD]
[TD="align: center"][B]First discovered by[/B][/TD]
[TD="align: center"][B]Contributed by[/B][/TD]
[TD="align: center"][B]System star(s) type[/B][/TD]
[TD="align: center"][B]Ringed EL?[/B][/TD]
[TD="align: center"][B]Moons[/B][/TD]
[TD="align: center"][B]Screenshot URL[/B][/TD]
[/TR]
[TR]
[TD]Dryio Flyuae MZ-F d11-1975[/TD]
[TD="align: center"]2[/TD]
[TD="align: center"]21000[/TD]
[TD="align: center"]Maleks[/TD]
[TD="align: center"]Maleks[/TD]
[TD="align: center"]A9 VAB, Y0 V[/TD]
[TD="align: center"]Yes[/TD]
[TD="align: center"]0[/TD]
[TD][URL]https://s6.postimg.org/cpqjjky69/9.jpg[/URL][/TD]
[/TR]
[/TABLE]

2. Binary pair of ELW's:

Code:

[TABLE="class: grid, width: 1500"]
[TR]
[TD="align: center"][B]System name[/B][/TD]
[TD="align: center"][B]Planet ID[/B][/TD]
[TD="align: center"][B]Dist. from Sol (ly)[/B][/TD]
[TD="align: center"][B]First discovered by[/B][/TD]
[TD="align: center"][B]Contributed by[/B][/TD]
[TD="align: center"][B]System star(s) type[/B][/TD]
[TD="align: center"][B]Ringed EL?[/B][/TD]
[TD="align: center"][B]Moons[/B][/TD]
[TD="align: center"][B]Screenshot URL[/B][/TD]
[/TR]
[TR]
[TD]Eord Flyuae JJ-G d11-1074[/TD]
[TD="align: center"]11[/TD]
[TD="align: center"]19000[/TD]
[TD="align: center"]Maleks[/TD]
[TD="align: center"]Maleks[/TD]
[TD="align: center"]F1 VI[/TD]
[TD="align: center"]No[/TD]
[TD="align: center"]0[/TD]
[TD][URL]https://s6.postimg.org/iglbb1vk1/11.jpg[/URL][/TD]
[/TR]
[TR]
[TD]Eord Flyuae JJ-G d11-1074[/TD]
[TD="align: center"]12[/TD]
[TD="align: center"]19000[/TD]
[TD="align: center"]Maleks[/TD]
[TD="align: center"]Maleks[/TD]
[TD="align: center"]F1 VI[/TD]
[TD="align: center"]No[/TD]
[TD="align: center"]0[/TD]
[TD][URL]https://s6.postimg.org/4lifeubr5/10.jpg[/URL][/TD]
[/TR]
[/TABLE]

Col Frost · Jan 8, 2017

I just found an ELW orbiting 4 stars, think that might be quite rare

Will submit soon

PaleGringo · Jan 9, 2017

Submitting my first "not mine, somebody else" world. I checked the list, and as of v2.5 it didn't seem to be on there.

System name	Planet ID	Dist. from Sol (ly)	First discovered by	Contributed by	System star(s) type	Ringed EL?	Moons	Screenshot URL
HIP 17362	C 4	430.89	MCBIERLE	PaleGringo	A3 V, M2 VA, F7 VI	No	0	http://i.imgur.com/1useQcr.png

SpocksOddSocks · Jan 9, 2017

Hey been away from the game for a while, but came back to search for Thargoid encounters. Had my first one on Saturday, but whilst I was looking I found this:

System name

Planet ID

Dist. from Sol (ly)

First discovered by

Contributed by

System star(s) type

First star

ELW is orbiting star(s) type

One primary star?

Ringed EL?

Moons

Screenshot URL

Notes

Taurus Dark Region DL-Y c7

8

444

Hudgard

Spock Oddsocks

G9 VA

Yes

No

0

http://i.imgur.com/bzVH91v.jpg

I would have added it directly to the sheet, but wasn't sure which tab you'd like them added to.

Also, thanks to Allitnil for this:

Allitnil said:
WYSIWYG still works, but I need to press the button at the very top left of the toolbar (if you hover over it, it says "Switch Editor to WYSIWYG Mode"). You should then be able to paste in from Excel. If you then want to add the grid lines, click the button again to switch back to source mode and change the

line to

Prior to the changes, I hadn't needed to switch to Wysiwig in the post itself, now seems that you do.

marx · Jan 9, 2017

First off, something that everyone might find interesting: I played around with CMDR EfilOne's updated proc. gen. system sector map, which is based on Jackie Silver's work, and had some maps drawn up based on the ELW list, which you can check here. I won't be including these on the main sheet, because it involves far too many counts for that (and I originally did it with queries, which were even more taxing), but it's curious to see how the ELW-s are distributed. MattG's map was more precise, of course, this just updates automatically - when I paste in new data. I'll probably do so once in a month.
It also includes mass code counts, for those who are interested. The CDE (Chiggy Distortion Effect) is quite visible here, as code D systems are somewhat over-represented. For example, before he and Col. Frost went to survey the Zunou sector, ELW-s orbiting class G stars were evenly distributed between code C and code D.

On to individual replies:

@ Maleks: please do make a note that you gave approximate distances the next time! It's fine, but it's good for me to know right away that the distance is not precise, and I'll need to look it up later.

@ Col Frost: yep, those are very rare, only nine found so far.

To PaleGringo and SpocksOddSocks: thanks for the close ELW-s! Always good to see those. To Spocks, welcome back, and hope the encounter was good for you! Of course, the Thargoids don't ask. Feel free to add them to the "Data - To verify" tab the next time.

Sapyx · Jan 11, 2017

Arriving at my next waypoint, and it's another system I'd bookmarked long ago as having an already-discovered ELW with incomplete information. This time, it doesn't seem to be in the updated database.

System name	Planet ID	Dist. from Sol (ly)	First discovered by	Contributed by	System star(s) type	Ringed EL?	Moons	Screenshot URL
BYAA AERB EZ-S d3-11	A 4	14035.96	BLAIN CRIGHTON	SAPYX	F6 VI, K2 VA	No	0	http://i.imgur.com/VtiK2zA.png

This planet is a pretty good Earth-analogue; temperature's just a shave too warm, air slightly thin, gravity a bit too high and really rather humid. The real kicker is that 136-day-long local day, caused by a tidal-locking to a large, fairly remote terraformable HMC companion which it orbits surprisingly eccentrically around. It's also quite high above the galactic plane, giving the asymmetric sky typical of such worlds. Elsewhere in the system, there's another terraformable the next planet sunwards (planet A 3, which Cmdr Crighton chose not to tag) and a waterworld around the fairly remote (90,000 Ls) secondary star; the waterworld looks a but too far from a K-class star to be terraformable, though the next planet in over there (planet B 1) might be.

marx · Jan 11, 2017

Sapyx said:
The real kicker is that 136-day-long local day, caused by a tidal-locking to a large, fairly remote terraformable HMC companion which it orbits surprisingly eccentrically around. It's also quite high above the galactic plane, giving the asymmetric sky typical of such worlds.

That's not really a kicker, because as you've said it, the planet is tidally locked to its binary partner and not to the star itself. (After all, the orbital period here is different from the rotational period.) As such, there would still be a day-night cycle on the ELW, so it's all good.

marx · Jan 11, 2017

Another update: I've added a Google form so you can submit your finds through that too, if you wish. The link is https://goo.gl/forms/hQRFycxMWuswkmnc2, and you can also find it in the first post. Note that I don't have any preference for or against it, so feel free to use whichever method is the most convenient for you.

Col Frost · Jan 11, 2017

Cool new way of submitting

CMDR Dreamstate · Jan 12, 2017

Here are my Earth-like discoveries

The first four, below, could be rolled into just two, as they are Binary Earth-likes - wasn't sure how to group them, so did them seperatly and took screenshots of each.

Planet name: SWOILZ FS-H D11-42 5
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 1,436.03
Exact type of star(s) in the system: F3 VB
Your in-game name: CMDR Dreamstate
First discovered by: CMDR Dreamstate

Planet name: SWOILZ FS-H D11-42 6
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 1,436.03
Exact type of star(s) in the system: F3 VB

Planet name: TRAIKEE WU-G D10-51 A 2
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 5,091.84
Exact type of star(s) in the system: F6 VI, K5 VA, M2 VA

Planet name: TRAIKEE WU-G D10-51 A 3
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 5,091.84
Exact type of star(s) in the system: F6 VI, K5 VA, M2 VA

Planet name: BLU THUA TT-R D4-25 11 11
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 1,829.94
Exact type of star(s) in the system: F7 VB

Planet name: M7 SECTOR WO-G C5-16 1
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 888.48
Exact type of star(s) in the system: K0 VAB

Planet name: PHYLUCS UY-S D3-42 A 5
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 2,254.62
Exact type of star(s) in the system: F3 VI, M4 VA

Planet name: NGC 6231 SECTOR IR-W d1-33 3
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 3,886.94
Exact type of star(s) in the system: F5 VB

Planet name: PRAEA EUQ DQ-G D10-42 AB 4
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 1,248.76
Exact type of star(s) in the system: A9 VB, K3 VAB, K0 VA, K6 VA

Planet name: PRAEA EUQ RX-L D7-101 3
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 1,072.80
Exact type of star(s) in the system: F4 VAB

Planet name: PRO EURL GI-B D13-45 A 1
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 1,808.38
Exact type of star(s) in the system: F5 VI, K9 VA, M8 VA, L2 V

Planet name: PRU EUQ LC-K d9-6 1
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 1,124.54
Exact type of star(s) in the system: F9 VAB

Planet name: SMOJE EY-Z D13-30 B 1
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 4,056.11
Exact type of star(s) in the system: F2 VI, G9 VA

Planet name: SWOILZ BM-J D10-82 4
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 1,397.08
Exact type of star(s) in the system: A9 VI

Planet name: SWOILZ FS-H D11-70 3
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 1,454.60
Exact type of star(s) in the system: G0 VAB

Planet name: TR 24 SECTOR FW-M D7-52 A 6
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 3,759.50
Exact type of star(s) in the system: F0 VI, K6 VA, M2 VA

Planet name: TRAIKAAE DP-Z C13-25 A 2
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 4,556.57
Exact type of star(s) in the system: G4 VB, M3 VA

Planet name: TRAIKAAE FF-R D4-135 3
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 4,402.85
Exact type of star(s) in the system: F1 VI

Planet name: TRAIKAAE IF-R D4-62 A 5
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 4,362.44
Exact type of star(s) in the system: F5 VI, K9 VA

Planet name: TRAIKAAE MR-N D6-200 A 4
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 4,547.38
Exact type of star(s) in the system: F6 VAB, F3 VB

Planet name: TRAIKEE AB-F D11-138 A 7
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 5,200.22
Exact type of star(s) in the system: F0 VI, K5 VA

Planet name: TRAIKEE BB-O D6-84 7
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 4,765.14
Exact type of star(s) in the system: A9 VI

Planet name: TRAIKEE HR-W D1-12 BC 3
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 4,327.18
Exact type of star(s) in the system: A9 VB, F8 VB, K3 VA

Planet name: TRAIKEE JN-K D8-60
Screenshots:

Distance from Sol: 4,862.93
Exact type of star(s) in the system: G4 VA