I'd still say "for some sulphur for my first engineering", I'd suggest using the srv to prospect for it normally because it's the fastest and most immediately convenient way to get what's needed without advanced locational knowledge and a good thing for a new player to know anyway. Only one of the first page replies mentioned it at all. About the most helpful direct advice was "don't mine for it".Well, to be absolutely accurate, the OP was advised to go visit some random planetary sites (barnacles and geo/bio sites included), but then he asked about G5 Raws and i felt obliged to mention the Crystalline Shards and the guide from the newb section... so not quite a derail, but a true development![]()
Organically, the thread probably helped the op tons either way (your contributions fit squarely in that bracket) but I do question the "jump to z, ignore a to y" priority for advice given the content of the op and his first reply, which made it really clear they weren't after the advanced stuff. I can see you identified that, just felt the overall discussion around barnacles, thargoid systems, g4 trading etc fell outside of the demands of the original question.
I've just noticed this habit here a lot with similar threads. Like "I need 10 arsenic for my first fsd upgrade, what's the fastest method?" threads getting the "go to shard sites" replies on page one. It's the correct answer to a certain question from a certain player, just not for that player asking that question.
Last edited: