I think one of the major issues with what is going on in the Eravate/LHS Clusters right now is lack of meaningful, fulfilling content for those at later stages of game play.
PowerPlay is in essence one colored bubble fighting all other colored bubbles for space not currently in a colored bubble, with the added feature of a Facebook style "energy system"
It means very little to at least a few people, not because of the gameplay mechanics but because it does not seem real at all. We have had these 10 "characters" thrown at us and said "Here you go!, Join your power" Then you look at the powers and say huh, "We have a paragraph about what these people are about and who they are...This one has a nice weapon...Oh...A blue haired Waifu, I'll pick that one I guess." and then that's it.
I know a large majority of people here poo-poos on Eve, but when you join a "power" It's a living breathing thing, will real human goals and motivations. It's the whole tribe mentality thing, Us versus You. In Eve if you are at with some other group, you the the hell away from that part of space. In E : D it does not matter who I pledge to, I can roam all around Human space with only the slight annoyance of being interdicted by an NPC every now and again. I still can land at any station I'm not wanted in, trade and do whatever I wish, then pack up and leave with the slightest problem.
I would think of The raids on Eravate as a REAL event something that players can get together and have a meaningful impact on. I have seen "We'll they will just keep coming" that may be true for a while but if what they are doing is no longer an enjoyed event they will leave, and in the most real of terms, you have saved a section of human space from the invading army. Now on the other hand you lose and are driven out the best thing to do is to help new player get out of dodge as soon is as humanly possible because they are now in an true enemies hands. OR you could try to reason with them and try to come to an agreement to either move the war somewhere else or cease fire all together.
I think I can speak for most of us when I say that we all want E : D to be a good game, but right now we are looking at a beautiful game with excellent mechanics that is devoid of any real meaning.
-CMDR Jezry Venn