The way i see it is that Open play was the mode the game is designed for, and if that is how it is designed then imo it should be played that way and embraced whilst doing so.
I have never played the modern Elite games but I have watched plenty of my friends play it and from my perspective the game seems much more fun when you have that extra layer of potential pvp added to it.
I no doubt will get 'griefed' by some in my time on Elite, but that isn't something to complain about. It is part and parcel of the game and its universe and something I may very well rage at yet in that moment but I will embrace it too because if i get caught out and destroyed I will learn from it and learn why i ended up in that position.
From what i can tell, have seen and have been told by friends the pvp griefing is over exaggerated on the scale of how often it actually happens with the majority of players actually quite friendly when you meet them and that the AI will be a far greater threat for more of the time I will spend in the game in OPEN.
For me I am super stoked for this game and looking forward to all the new experiences of the Elite universe no matter what happens, bring it on.
I'd be interested to know what you would be able learn from having your mid-level ship virtually insta-killed by a wing of 4 high-tier engineered, combat optimised fighters.
My conclusion is to not play the Open environment whilst playing in the very area that has the greatest player population and activity, which actually totally defeats the entire object of playing the Open environment, but your mileage may differ...
Cheerz
Mark H