Which Joystick do you currently own/plan on getting?

  • Black Widow

    Votes: 47 1.5%
  • Saitek AV8R-03

    Votes: 8 0.2%
  • Saitek F.L.Y. 5

    Votes: 93 2.9%
  • Saitek X52

    Votes: 381 11.9%
  • Saitek X52 Pro

    Votes: 653 20.4%
  • Saitek X55

    Votes: 455 14.2%
  • Saitek X65

    Votes: 45 1.4%
  • Thrustmaster T.Flight Hotas X

    Votes: 654 20.4%
  • Thrustmaster Warthog

    Votes: 364 11.4%
  • Logitech G940

    Votes: 52 1.6%
  • Other ... (Leave details on the comments)

    Votes: 690 21.5%

  • Total voters
    3,205
  • Poll closed .
Most Excellent. Let us know your thoughts; I thought long and hard about obtaining that unit, or its larger sibling.

Ok on the Cobra M5...

So I'm no joystick expert but it's Russian style stick apparently, so a bit different from the normal stick you'll get in the UK. Perfect if you like to fly for the Empire!

895RM-Z5WTN-UH2Y0B-50TV.jpg


All I have it to compare to is an old Saitek Cyborg Gold, obviously they're world's apart.

So in light of me knowing nothing about these things!..

It feels incredibly light and precise, and I love that. With a caveat that the light feel of it means that when centered you can get a slight movement in it, not that it drifts at all but I play ED on the couch so any movement on my part transfers to the stick when I'm not "grasping" it. You can easily sort this by adjusting the deadzone but I don't find it an issue and adding a deadzone could impede how precise it is on small movements, so I've not bothered.

Modes - There's a switch with 3 positions so buttons are switched, I currently have a main mode, landing and cruise. This mode change does not switch all buttons just most. Button 1 +2 (main trigger) stays consistent as does the RH POV hat. However limits in ED limit this feature somewhat, in that ED only allows two keybinds for any action, so for example if you wanted to assign one of the mode switching buttons to an action you want to be consistent over the three modes, well it's not possible due to ED only allowing two keybinds per action. Not a huge issue you can easily work around it but worth knowing.

The main trigger - A few things with this. First off it's a 2 stage trigger, so you pull the trigger in partially and button1 triggers, then pull in more and button2, but given you've past button1 too it's essentially button1+button2. This sounds a great feature but in practice the use-cases for it are actually pretty slim, exacerbated somewhat by the fact that ED only allows for two fire buttons so if you're using a kill scanner too you can end up having to compromise or keep switching between fire groups. In all honesty I've not yet found a great use for it in ED.

Also on the trigger there's quite a bit of movement before it engages, my previous Saitek Cyborg was almost a hair trigger which when I switched was a bit of a "hmm I'm not sure if I like this" moment. You can of course discipline yourself to partially depress the trigger in combat so it's sitting just before the engagement point if you want. Or alternatively you could flip the main trigger forward (it clicks out of the way into a non-combat position) and use the more hair-trigger smaller secondary trigger button underneath (which is essentially button2) if you wanted..

ENABLE 3 OR 4 FIRE BUTTONS PLEASE FRONTIER!!

Little finger trigger - It has a small trigger sitting under your little finger, so imagine a press performed with a slight squeeze. It's not massively precise but has it's uses, I have it currently as the kill scanner in combat, so hold down, or all stop in landing, so squeeze to stop.

4E352-EL741-J9MB50-29GV.jpg


Two hats - Great, not got two hats on your T16000 have you! A main POV hat and a secondary one. I was intending to use the secondary for lateral thrust but in all honesty I'm finding left hand on a keyboard works great for that so in combat it's currently used for ship/subcomponent targetting and fire group switching.

Throttle - Basic, it's precise enough but the bit sticking out, the lever bit is small, and on full or no throttle it touches against the case meaning it can be a touch difficult to get your finger under to move it, so you end up using the grooves instead. Not a big issue but in the heat of combat it's not ideal. This is currently a non-issue for me as I prefer throttling via keyboard on the left hand.

0P1BK-LDS1I-58BXQX-57AP.jpg


Other bits....

Two thumb buttons - Fine they're buttons!

The software is essentially just calibration, there's no macro support in there or anything. There might be third party tools for joystick macros I haven't looked.

While mostly plastic it has a heavy metal baseplate.

It's right hand only.

It cost me £42 all in.

In summary, might sound like I'm being a bit critical but I absolutely love it, feels great, really precise, it has a bunch of buttons with mode switching and the price is right. =D
 
Last edited:
system map joystick comtrols

How can you pan to see the system pap with a joystick. i cant see any control options in the control menu
 

oomwat

Banned
Yeah, it would be great to be able to step from star to planet, to moon, using the hat on the top of my stick.

Don't think it's possible though.
 
Joystick Setup

Hi I have a Microsoft sidewinder forceback joystick......I have set the joystick up assigned commands and axis but the ship spin uncontrollably any advice appreciated ( I have tried with and without forcefeed back)
 
Control issues with Saitek AV8R-03 joystick, can't use vertical and lateral thrusters

Hello,

I started with mouse and keyboard but realized I have an old Saitek I'd try to use. I went to the combat trainer and things worked fine. I also when to the Launch tutorial and confirmed my setup worked as intended... most importantly the vertical and lateral thrust on my POV worked as expected. (It did take me some time to figure out how to navigate the UI panels, but I'm getting used to it now.)

I then went to the Landing tutorial. Everything appeared to work fine as I requested docking, then flew into the station. Landing gear down... check. I was able to spot my landing pad and fly towards it using the main thrusters. Then I tried to refine my position using lateral thrusters.... and there was no response. I tried vertical thrusters... no response.

I went to my config section and the presets for my joystick were still there. I noticed that there is a special section for Landing Overrides but the tool tip says if there is nothing there my main flight configuration is used. My main flight config showed the lateral and vertical thrusters are still tied to my POV control.

I resumed the game and still had no response from those thrusters. I then tried to change my Landing overrides to use the POV control even though the tool tip said it was unnecessary. Still no luck.

Am I not allowed to use vertical and lateral thrusters while landing? I watched the video tutorial and those thrusters are used there.

I'm assuming this is an issue with my joystick controls... does anyone have any thoughts or tips while my controls aren't working?
 
Not enough buttons are you kidding Oo it has more buttons than any other HOTAS out there.

CH Throttle definitely doesn't have "enough buttons" when compare to Warthog or x55's throttle. CH Throttle is a decent and though throttle in terms of quality, just that it is not a "detailed" throttle in terms of functionality (it doesn't even have twin throttle which is quite important if you play other flight sims).
 
I had this issue - download the controller software and calibrate it. May take 2 or 3 goes - but mine works perfectly now. You kind of want to do this for the thumbstick anyway....

Z...

Cheers Zeeman.
The instructions and the cd packet and a guide on the net all said in capital letters to Not install the CH Control Manager in Windows 7, but when I tried to calibrate by Windows calibration wizard, CH said I had to install their control manager, which I therefore did, and all seems ok.

Not that I have tried it in game yet, everytime I have time to play this game I find I have to update it first which uses all my playing time.
 
What flight stick to use?

As a newcomer to this forum, just curious, what controller / flight stick does everyone use? I have my eye on this:
 

Sir.Tj

The Moderator who shall not be Blamed....
Volunteer Moderator
Copied and added the poll from the old thread at the top for you folks to tell us which stick you are using..
 
Waiting for my Hotas X to arrive... Should have been here yesterday... Damn that planet Earth and their silly Xmas traditions!
 
Last edited:
Joystick "shift" posibility

Hello comanders,

I'm a new player of Elite nver played it before although i pirated it on my homecomputer back in the day. Now i'm older and wiser i support all the software i like.

But that's not my question, i'm playing with a "logitech extreme 3d pro" joystick.
But Elite needs way more buttons and hadswitches that i have on my joystick. So i was thinking is there an "shift" option for joystick buttons. So that i can put 2 functions on 1 button.

Example, If i'm using trigger 1 for primary fire, but when i'm pressing button 10+1 then it's next target. That way i can map more functions on my joystick.

is that posible i can't find it ennywhere in the options (but i'm kinda lost in the many many diferent functions)
 
Hello comanders,

I'm a new player of Elite nver played it before although i pirated it on my homecomputer back in the day. Now i'm older and wiser i support all the software i like.

But that's not my question, i'm playing with a "logitech extreme 3d pro" joystick.
But Elite needs way more buttons and hadswitches that i have on my joystick. So i was thinking is there an "shift" option for joystick buttons. So that i can put 2 functions on 1 button.

Example, If i'm using trigger 1 for primary fire, but when i'm pressing button 10+1 then it's next target. That way i can map more functions on my joystick.

is that posible i can't find it ennywhere in the options (but i'm kinda lost in the many many diferent functions)
-
Yes in your settings hold one button down and press the other to assign it, as long as the shift button is not already assigned.
 
Also try VoiceAttack software.. you can assign a voice command (of your choosing) to a key press ;) such as J = "Warp" and also "disengage".. and on full power "Engage" and so on :)
 
that t-flight hotas thing looks nice for the price.

i cant justify the investment or space needed for a warthog or similar priced stick, for just this game.
 
Back
Top Bottom