Firstly, Sorry for the huge thread derail!
(...)
I hope this has helped you get a grip on my stance on this and the thinking process behind why I said what I did in my original post. Sorry for the length of it and semi garbled format too. It's a pretty dense things to have had to go in to, but I do hope you receive it as the reasoned argument it was intended to be.
You've done a brilliant job of explaining this, and I feel this isn't a derail of the conversation at all! This is a fundamental part of why this discussion started, and it can't spontaneously initiate in another thread.
I definitely see your point that without "genuine" ownership, it is less likely to devolve into a competitive style of gameplay, however, I do fear that group-centric activities, if not tempered, make the environment the equivalent of when a tour bus or school group arrives at a museum: the entire attitude changes, and suddenly what was a place of collective, profound appreciation becomes a fight to endure the boorish hoards that use 'organization' to run roughshod over the environment.
I understand that, with or without in-game curation groups still exist, and succeed through coordination, but I also feel like there are theoretical tools in place to identify a player's factions, just no good way of collaborating beyond a small wing of 4.
It's a very, very big galaxy. With about 20-30,000 players online at any one time, spread across many tens of thousands of stations spending only a few minutes in each one, the ability to even FIND another individual is very difficult, let alone finding someone with which one can "identify".
I would like to know the people that call my little slice of the galaxy home. Maybe someone else uses my little Anarchy as a home base, but unless I sit and watch for hours on end, I may never know. I may never find someone that could actually become a wingman or even a friend, because the "social mechanics" don't support it. I'm not really upset by that, to be honest, as I fully understand my loneliness is only a function of my own motivation.
Thank you so much for your meaningful and delightful discussion. I wish I could discuss it with you at length in a back-and-forth manner, but I realize this bulletin board doesn't really make that easy to do...somewhat appropriately.
My best regards to you, and I can't give you any more Reputation because I have apparently given you enough right now...