No, I was talking about planets that have the most Earth-like surface conditions, at least as far as the current stats can tell us. A bit subjective, I know. But, as I think more about it, there's totally room for more (and certainly less subjective) records in this vein, such as 'Earth-like world with highest/lowest surface pressure, highest/lowest surface gravity, highest/lowest temperature', etc. It would also probably be a good idea to separate those categories between natural and terraformed Earth-likes, as well, as I think some terraformed worlds might be too small to have formed 'in the wild', for example. We could also have similar categories for Water Worlds.
Anyways, Here's my entry for WATER WORLD WITH THE LOWEST SURFACE PRESSURE, if the idea is approved:
Also, I've got a record-breaker for SMALLEST WATER GIANT and LIGHTEST WATER GIANT,