What type of controller will you be using for Elite Dangerous

Looks like the Bees Knees! :smilie:

How does it feel / operate...some good functions?
Does it install well under Windows etc.?

Pass it over here for me to try...."I want's it my precious"...gulp! :D

Jack :smilie:
 
Last edited:
I tried it on X3TC (I don't have the ED alpha) and it's a good joystick.
It has 11 buttons, POV and a scroll wheel. The throttle is dual control (for example with aircraft) but can lock so it operates as one control.
The stick part is adjustable, but it felt ok for me straight out of the box.
Windows 7 installed it no problem and there is a configuration program I can download from the website if I need it

All in all a good stick for the £40 I paid for it. I don't feel so bad about not having the X52.
 
I tried it on X3TC (I don't have the ED alpha) and it's a good joystick.
It has 11 buttons, POV and a scroll wheel. The throttle is dual control (for example with aircraft) but can lock so it operates as one control.
The stick part is adjustable, but it felt ok for me straight out of the box.
Windows 7 installed it no problem and there is a configuration program I can download from the website if I need it

All in all a good stick for the £40 I paid for it. I don't feel so bad about not having the X52.

Does have twist? That is something the Warthog, and I, is missing.
 
Does have twist? That is something the Warthog, and I, is missing.

It has twist, which I'd assume any flight stick would have (obviously not).
My next question is to someone in Alpha ... is it listed in the controllers presets?
If not, I know I can set up the stick manually.

In fact ... could someone in Alpha be good enough to list the controllers in that list please?
Otherwise I might have to dig through Kerrash's videos as I know he listed them at some point.
 
Last edited:
control Pad
Control Pad with Yaw
Keyboard and Mouse
Black Widow
Saitek X52
Saitek X52 Pro
Saitek AV8R-03
Saitek F.L.Y. 5
Thrustmaster Tflight
Classic Keyboard Only
Custom.

Thats the options at the moment!!!
 
control Pad
Control Pad with Yaw
Keyboard and Mouse
Black Widow
Saitek X52
Saitek X52 Pro
Saitek AV8R-03
Saitek F.L.Y. 5 (<---- MY JOYSTICK)
Thrustmaster Tflight
Classic Keyboard Only
Custom.

Thats the options at the moment!!!
YAY !!!!! Thank you Psykokow.
 
I've just received my x52 pro and it's a lot bigger than I was expecting. In fact, a tad intimidating.
I won't be able to use it until Beta 1 but it's giving me tingles every time I look at it. :D
@Alien. I was going to get the Cyborg Fly 5 as it seemed to be the best stick for a sensible price, so I think you made a good choice. However, once I started splashing out on a new rig I went with the X52.
Maybe not a sensible buy, really, but it is the season for a wee bit of jolly-folly. :)
 
It has twist, which I'd assume any flight stick would have (obviously not).

In fact a real 'flight' stick doesn't come with a twist, 'cause real pilots use pedals for yaw control.

Trying to kill time 'til i can command my own ship in beta, i just watch some episodes of Firefly, again. I seriously thought about getting a yoke control, just like they used in the series (http://www.saitek.com/uk/prod/yoke.html). But then i saw it in the store and it felt pretty cheap to the touch and not very solid. So if any alpha testers have experience with it, please let me know.

So today i ordered myself a Thrustmaster Warthog. Seems to me like the perfect controller for ED, since i felt that a starships controls should feel heavy in your hand, i mean, it's a starship, not a dwarf car (like f.e. a Messerschmidt Kabinenroller or that thing Jeremy Clarkson drove through the BBC offices in Top Gear).
That's why it seems quite wrong to me to use a PS or xbox controller or any of these tiny things that so many around here prefer (might work well for them, but not for me,... immersion, you know...).

Of course there are more reasons for me to choose the Warthog, it's said to be extremly precise and with all the many buttons it should be possible to fly the ship with oculus rift goggles on, since the keyboard is not needed anymore.

Since i stil had a voucher of a local electronics warehouse left and had to spent it anyway, even the price was not so much of an issue. This is probably the last joysick i'll ever buy in my life, so it's not so much an expense, but more like an investment.
Delivery takes 4-7 days, so with a little luck i can make myself a nice christmas present. Next item i plan to get is a set of pedals, had Saitek's 'Pro Flight Combat Rudder Pedals' in mind (http://www.saitek.com/uk/prod/compedals.html?scid=SA_CP).

Equipped like that i feel confident to be able even to toast some trigger happy teenagers before they can get me.
 
Last edited:
not a dwarf car (like f.e. a Messerschmidt Kabinenroller or that thing Jeremy Clarkson drove through the BBC offices in Top Gear).
That was a Peel P50. I think the Messerschmidt is a different car, still small though.

I understand about the pedals, and it makes sense from a flight sim (as in 747) point of view, but in 3300 I'd imagine controller sticks would have twist and not pedals. I suppose some pilots could have pedals fitted to the controls of their ships for that "old timer" feel, but times have moved on. :D

And I too only play games on a PC, and while a keyboard & mouse is fine, for this I want a joystick.
 
I tried it on X3TC (I don't have the ED alpha) and it's a good joystick.
It has 11 buttons, POV and a scroll wheel. The throttle is dual control (for example with aircraft) but can lock so it operates as one control.
The stick part is adjustable, but it felt ok for me straight out of the box.
Windows 7 installed it no problem and there is a configuration program I can download from the website if I need it

All in all a good stick for the £40 I paid for it. I don't feel so bad about not having the X52.
11 buttons? No wait!!! it has a 12th button, it's got an orange symbol on it.
This has puzzled me, so I got the instruction manual. Two pages about adjusting the stick, then repeats in different languages. Nothing about the buttons.

So I looked it up (gotta love Google). The orange button is a shift button.

11 buttons? HA more like 22 !!! Yeah that's right, all you X52 people "I can has 30+ buttons" but it cost at least £100 :p
And you Warthog HOTAS owners ... all those switches, shiny, but do you really need them? and you ain't got twist!!! (realism I hear you explain).

So ner ner ner ner ner .... I can has 22 buttons, which is plenty (I'm struggling to assign the four at the bottom of the stick to something, and I haven't even thought about the shift key) as I will still use a mouse & keyboard to play the game (joystick + mouse + keyboard ftw) :D

all teasing aside .... I'll probably still get blown up more times than I could count whatever fancy / basic, expensive / cheap, joystick I use.
 
Just got my Saitek x52 pro joystick and throttle hope i can use my mouse and keyboard as backup , we will see if more than 1 input get sorted, And i be in heaven come January and Premium Beta commences. :D

I bet i will need a week or 2 to memorise all the Controls. :cool:
 
... (I'm struggling to assign the four at the bottom of the stick to something, and I haven't even thought about the shift key) ...

a) divert power to Engines
b) divert power to Shields
c) divert power to Weapons
d) equalise power distribution

That's (close to) what i plan to asign my joystick-base toggle buttons to.
 
a) divert power to Engines
b) divert power to Shields
c) divert power to Weapons
d) equalise power distribution

That's (close to) what i plan to asign my joystick-base toggle buttons to.
How about:
a) divert power to Engines
b) divert power to Shields
c) divert power to Weapons
d) scream for help

:smilie:
 
That was a Peel P50. I think the Messerschmidt is a different car, still small though.

I understand about the pedals, and it makes sense from a flight sim (as in 747) point of view, but in 3300 I'd imagine controller sticks would have twist and not pedals. I suppose some pilots could have pedals fitted to the controls of their ships for that "old timer" feel, but times have moved on. :D

Thanks for the info, i admit, that i was just to lazy to look up the name of that funny little car. And the Messerschmitt definitly is a different car. Just recently i've seen one on the road, they are very rare nowadays, even around here.

I'm just guessing here, but i think you never piloted a real airplane, did you?
It's easier to precisely (!) control a planes movement around the 3 axes if the control functions are seperated to different controllers. That might be the reason why the sidesticks in an Airbus don't have a twist (btw even the latest models of the 747 stil use a yoke instead of a sidestick).

Of course i have no idea what kind of controllers people will use 3300 A.D. Also i didn't forget, that we are talking about a spaceship, not an aeroplane, but i'm very much used to the old school airplane controller configuration and adapting these to ED just seems logical to me.

Furthermore i try to immerse as much into the game as possible. I even got myself a flightsuit allready (pretty crazy, i know :D) and of course the oculus rift is high on my wish list. Using a controller that doesn't feel 'real' to me might be very contraproductive to do so.

Maybe you are right and i am really an 'old timer' (nothing wrong being 'old school', as long as one stays open minded), but i think i'm in pretty good company here at the forums.:smilie:
 
Last edited:
Pedals on RL aircraft don't just operate rudder and nose wheel steering (when activated), they also operate parking breaks too.

Brian :)
 
Nope never piloted a real airplane, but that's probably an easy guess (still right though).
I do understand that it is easier to control with pedals, heck, just trying to use two sticks to control a toy helicopter to fly it through a rectangle gap in a big sheet of paper held up by Mr Darren Grey was near impossible (but very funny), so yes, it would be dangerous to control yaw with a twist stick in a real aircraft.

I can't explain why joystick makers made sticks to twist, maybe it was pedals seemed unattractive to customers? but I have tried controlling the 3 axis with the stick, and I'll admit, it does take some concentration.

As for the "old timer" comment in my previous post, I was teasing. It was not directed at anyone specifically or to be taken seriously.
 
Back
Top Bottom