yes that is all true, however and this we don't need to hide because that's known, to me the two best endings are the Sun ending, where V take the last big job no one can do, and it ends with a cliffhanger, or leaving with Panam, to me they are the only endings i like for my V.
Now adding the new ending the emotions are getting on a roller-coaster from a story telling point of view, and yes the conversation you have with Johnny is also sad, but!! it's what comes after that, so I'm got to describe it in the spoiler and you can the choose not to look.
You loose everything in the new ending but you survive, as a normal NPC, you're now weak and can never become what you were, all your friends are gone and you're only a shadow of what you were, no Johnny, no Panam or Judy no fame no respect, and when you watch the ending cut scene it's just so freaking sad.
Its sad if you cling to the past- its a mirror image of temperance in that its a clean break (plus its dodgy writing for some characters). And as I said, it sets up V as a Morgan Blackhand solo operator if he so wishes, or use (from CP lore) bioware which works differently to cyberware. That, and not being reliant on cyber gear that when rouge AI break through the Blackwall.
In essence the new ending is V being free to do what he wants, he has his life. Plus, he / she gives a little smirk at the end too, just before turning round.
In essence the new ending is V being free to do what he wants, he has his life. Plus, he / she gives a little smirk at the end too, just before turning round.