I have a new theory!
Sorry if someone already had the same idea, but I haven't found anything.
I think we have to group up the obelisks. I think this is why no one could find a pattern and we said every instance has it's own combinations. I think that's wrong. Instead I think it's not important what Obelisk exactly you use. Compare my image (
here) with the one from CMDR Straha (
here). We got nearly exactly the same data, always with the same items in cargo but from different obelisks. But if you look closely you will see that my source obelisks are always directly next to the one of Straha. That leads me to the conclusion that we have to group the obelisks together.
Here's an example:
I have Historical Data 8 from obelisk 2 with the items casket + tablet. Straha has Historical Data 8 with the same items but from obelisk 1.
I have Historical Data 12 from obelisk 3 with the items casket + orb. Straha has Historical Data 12 with the same items but from obelisk 4.
When did we get the data? After we scanned the second obelisk of each group. While I had the casket and the tablet I first scanned obelisk 1 and then 2. After that I got the data and of course entered it in the obelisk 2 column. I believe Straha had the same objects but first scanned obelisk 2 and then obelisk 1. Then he got the data and entered it in the column of obelisk 1.
You see? The data doesn't come from one of the two obelisks, but from the second one if scanned right after another. We now have find the obelisk groups and scanning pattern. Which makes everything much more difficult.
Could that be possible or am I stupid?
Side note: The first scanned obelisk in each group got me the flashing message that immediately disappeared. Maybe that's a hint that we scanned an obelisk with the correct items, but need to find the next one in sequence to get the data.