I didn't mention RP once for a very good reason.
Right, OK, I was using that as an example of prescriptive pronunciation.
You asked for people's opinions. No one agreed with you. I showed you that there are (and I quote myself, as it's important to the point) strong patterns in the correspondence between English graphemes and phonemes, and you reject it.
I think you misunderstood me. I wasn't asking for opinions so much as asking how people naturally pronounced something, and there's no right or wrong about that. We all know the "correct" way it's pronounced in game, in any case.
I understand your point about patterns, but different dialects have different patterns, so insisting on one correct pronunciation promotes one dialect over all others. As far as linguistics go most seem to regard English as a descriptive language these days. That's debatable though, so neither view is technically wrong and both have held sway at different points. In any case, nowhere have I insisted that my pronunciation is the "right" one or anything.
And that's what linguists call "a load of crap."
Not really, though it depends on the linguist.
From
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_linguistic_prescription_in_English:
"During the second half of the 20th century, the prescriptionist tradition of usage commentators started to fall under increasing criticism. Thus, works such as the Merriam Webster's Dictionary of English Usage, appearing in 1993, attempt to describe usage issues of words and syntax as they are actually used by writers of note, rather than to judge them by standards derived from logic, fine distinctions, or Latin grammar."