Game's future

Status
Thread Closed: Not open for further replies.
Don´t get me back to this part, Luniticisi...

I have a Rift. That´s why there is something very transparent for me.

In SC you barley can turn around without serious framerate drops without VR.

So here we go again...

rULwcLx.gif


Man...milk is running out of my nose..
 
Last edited:
So when someone says "this X is good/bad" I know that's subjective. When someone presents a factual truth I know it isn't.

Ever heard of 'facts' that are invented or things taken out of context and massaged to represent someone's POV?

Stop arguing that people are here to argue factual information. Most are here to push their agenda and feelings.

Which is fine. Just need to admit that.
 
One problem is that the moment someone says anything, one way or another about ED this happens.

...Quick, someone said something bad about Elite Dangerous ....

landscape-1472821492-computer-angry.gif

...Quick, someone said something good about Elite Dangerous ....

landscape-1472821492-computer-angry.gif

It's a never ending round-about.

My feeling is that ED is far from dying, But that is just my opinion.

The OP has their circle of friends that is falling away from ED, so his perspective is skewed in that direction.

The problem with being in 'Circles' (and we are all guilty of this) is that it can often make people believe that because their 'Circle' believes one thing, everyone must obviously believe the same thing too, which is obviously not true.

Remember this, Not everyone thinks the same as you and your friends.
 
Whatever happened after Horizons, it hit the game development pace very hard. Or they had all already done and were releasing it in parts.
2 years ago on the elite meet in cologne we have seen accretions disks and all this stuff - Nothing has made it into the game yet.

I have some hopes, but I think that we are not Talking About a bright future of this game we all love(d).
 
By the way, how is it worse to create a thread highlighting a specific flaw on steamchart graphs than creating a thread using false data to claim that the game is dying?

It is worse because instead of talking about the state of the game, you only focus on the validity of steam charts, even though that's not the point.
 
I have absolutly no opinions, agenda and feelings. So I don´t have to mention it.

I can say, we established a Player Faction two years ago, now we are more than 240 Pilots and become more every week.

There are not many things in the world, I had get so much fun for so few money.

And I still want more...

Thanks for that!
 
Last edited:
...and you can´t flush the toilet, you are right.

But instead you can play the game. Even in VR.

And in the future Elite:Unicorn version (upcoming with SC Beta 1) I bet you can.
 
Last edited:
Thing is though, as I've said with a few of my comments now, David explicitly states in these diaries the enormous work a lot of the features are going to entail (starting back then 4 years ago), and he says they're going to take a long time. It just amazes me that people think he was lying when in reality 4 years for a game of this scope isn't all that long (look at Cyberpunk 2077 six years in development and it's in Alpha with years away from release as said by the devs this year. Also Star Citizen. Infinity Battlescape, and many more).

And Cyberpunk 2077 (or any other AAA game developed behind closed doors) doesn't have to worry about:

a) releasing a playable relatively bug free game at any point in 6 years of development before it goes gold.

b) releasing content in an order that not only makes best development sense but also keeps those playing it happy.
 
It is worse because instead of talking about the state of the game, you only focus on the validity of steam charts, even though that's not the point.

Problem is that for lot of players it kinda is. They know that alone their opinions are just like that - opinions. And they feel they need to 'pad' their argument with idea, that there are more people disappointed with game and that's why devs should listen to them.

Thing is - devs would listen even without that padding. But they wouldn't necessarily obey players. And that's something pass by for many people posting these threads. Devs know complains and feedback. They will address them in matter of time and their own way.
 
The offline debate has been had and was done and over years ago.

Prove to me that they said content add-ons like space legs and planetary landings would be free.

Interstellar travel being boring is your subjective opinion and with it having more depth, well isn't that what part of Beyond Q4 will address?

Hiding in the hold of a ship is space legs and refers to what I said in my comment about these kinds of things taking a long time.

Horizons was clearly hampered by the fact that they were moving offices, hence the extra year (along with other unforeseen hiccups). But they've said they want to move away from the season model and have explained why. What's your issue with that?

And about space legs and the dev comment, they're not telling us what they're working on full stop at the moment. And they're certainly not going to suddenly announce it by replying to a comment on here last year.

What do you mean on foot till 2021?

I don't see lies, I see development problems and changes which are expected to happen and happen with every game. Once again it's people not understanding this and not grasping the scope of this game and in fact the scope of any game. It takes time and during that time there are issues and bumps along the way.

Like I said before, I will start getting worried and perhaps believe you about the lies if Frontier doesn't reveal anything about substantial new content by the end of this year. But in the meantime, Beyond is still ongoing.

Offline mode it's lie from Braben. Period. You like it or not.

This is the first time I'll discuss with you so I'll give the benefit of doubt.

Moving to new office has nothing to do with development, because at that time they were working on Dinosaur an an expansion of planet coaster if I remember right.

Ed has been completly abandoned to itself: compare the number of expansions we have had in 2015 (from 1.0 to 1.8) to 2.0 and what happened in the next 3 years.

Don't state the number of the add-on released (i.e.3.1 or 3.2 and so on): compare what they promised and how they cut (multicrew it wasn't that tu*d that it is now : they cut a lot of feature because they hadn't time which was spent on different project).

Compare even 3.1 and 3.2: what we get? 2 new ships (nice) and a revisitation of a what should be done right times ago (and they didn't).

Hell: in 2015 we passed from 16 ships to almost 31! And in the meanwhile they were working on planet, srv and so on. When they were working on Elite they shows us what they were doing.

And note: they did incredible things

But they stopped to work on Elite.

Don't answer me: compare by yourself and then go on: if you think Elite is well developed than stick with it.

Space legs and 2021.

They have announced that they'll work on Elite till 2021. If you see what they did till now you'll clearly can draw a conclsuion: no space legs will come out before 2021 or atmo planet.

True: that doesn't mean that they'll never work after such time on Ed. but unfortunatly it doesn't means neither that they'll work on it.

Considering that the only expansion which regular appears are the one in the shop (hence: elite as a cash cow) and again you can spot a pattern here and drawn your conclusion.
 
They wouldn't announce an exploration overhaul if they thought that. And white knight or not, every one on this forum agrees that it needs some love. So it's kind of a boring point to discuss.

Its not boting, the game released bare bones and they took 4 years to develop 2 basic core activities, the otrhers are still bare bones.
Yes, they thought exploration was ok otherwise they would improve it the first year instead of creating CQC or Powerplay.

Its not a "boring point", it is important. I've said this many times, the game needed an overhaul, the activities in Elite are very shallow and boring.
I've started in early 2016 a thread about the lack of interactions in the gameplay, lack of mechanics and simplicity and the thread was locked after several pages because "it was a boring thread". The fault the game is in this crappy state is all because of the complacent community.
In this 4 years we didn't have any overhaul in the placeholder activities, we only got tiny tiny features. They had 4 years to make basic gameplay interactive and fun buyt ALL the gameplay is about shoot things, point and wait, or hold a button.
If they don't do a really good job with mining and exploration then I'm done with Elite.
 
Well its possible they find it interesting.

I actually find the vast majority of it interesting - all in small doses I hasten to add. Exploration is more the what have I discovered, although the good to rubbish system ratio is low, especially towards the centre. The other asects I fnd interesting as I tend to use them to drive the BGS, so there is an extra layer of cause and effect - Ii is my "why", to go with the what and how. You need the why!

The BGs is very simple but the interaction of multiple groups and other players is all but simple. It does make the rest of it fun in my opinion, but you have to have friends to play with it. I had some once, but I kept trying to put words into their mouths and judge them on those words.............

Simon

I'm not even talking about BGS, I'm talking about the interactions with the ship, enviroment or npcs. I'm talking of what you need to do with a tool of the ship to make something. How complex is honk a horn pressing a button? or flying straight to dock at full speed to evade 20 police ships and a HUGE door with air traffic controllers who give you complete access to dock at full speed and don't care anything. "Hey i'm not suspect Im just docking at full speed".
Or an infinite number of ships without objectives in a fishtank.
What kind of gameplay is this? The game has no sense, no soul, no complexity in its mechanics.
 
You know I hear a lot about the arc of doom concerning ED, usually in parallel with the arc of renegade intentions of FD since before the KS era.

I often think of it like this:

Bloke waiting for a bus, he has come to understand that a bus is a mode of transport available to him that once a ticket is purchased, takes him to where he wants to go. He has studied the bus timetables and routes, and decided he wants to visit town centre and has subsequently walked to the relevant bus stop, at which point he has been told his bus will arrive and pick him up.

Now for the most part, he is able to witness several if not more buses both pass and stop at his bus stop, which he decides not to get on, as they do not go where he wishes to go. A destination that he has been reliably informed is possible to reach and the reason why he is at the bus stop in the first place.

He keeps waiting.

And waiting.

He is there for months, happily waiting for this bus come rain or shine, as the bus company is repeating his bus will be available at some point through the tannoy at the bus stop. If only every now and again.

Years later, the bus company announce they have stopped the service for which the man went to the bus stop, and would the man like to catch another bus? After he calmed down, the man decides that being as he is invested, and that his family have now left him due to him living like a tramp at the bus stop, he might as well.

Once at the outskirts of town, the man speaks to the bus driver and says "well this isn't anywhere near town". To which the bus driver replies, you just spent four years using our bus stop, then got the bus...what do you want from me? Of course, the rest of the passengers, don't want to admit to a similar level of embarassing commitment to the original premise laid out by the bus company, so they all laugh at the bus drivers comments. Most of them of course, have no idea where they are or how they got there.

Turns out, neither does the bus driver.

Personally, I'd give a bus company offering that level of service, not long at all.

It's not "Doom".

It's just survival of the fittest.
 
Last edited:
im not fdev employee, its not my responsibility to find solutions to where they screwed up, im here to voice my dissatisfcation and i hope people will keep complaining and making theads to keep pushing fdev to do something

Its called constructive criticism.

Google it.
 
Disappointment with elite dangerous is generally increasing.
Comment sections on trailers are getting more and more negative and toxic. (check new trailer comment section)...

This happens in all game forums no matter what the game, for a simple arithmetical reason. Every game has a turnover of players: people typically buy a game, play it for weeks, months or years, then move on to another game. Most of the people who move on don't ever contribute to the forum again but there's a minority who continue posting. Their posts are of course generally negative; the game is no longer one they enjoy. Simple arithmetic then means that new, keen players gradually get outnumbered by discontented people. Every game forum becomes more and more toxic over time because of this.

The rising discontent therefore indicates nothing about how good or bad the game actually is.
 
Status
Thread Closed: Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom