Okay FDEV time to make elite fair..FOR EVERYONE!

So many of you are telling the OP to "go buy it, it's only a few bucks / pounds / euro's"

Yet none of you are volunteering despite continually making the point that the price is so low as to be almost meaningless pocket change.

So if you're not willing to give him the money - or group together to help him buy it - it's not quite such a meaningless amount after all is it?


If you're the kind of person that would pick up a dollar / pound / euro - from the pavement instead of walking past - then you saying to him "it's just a few....." are hypocrites.

There's a point being made by the OP and most of you aren't getting it.

Stop ruining “The Dark Wheel” novella for me please.
 
This whole argument only exists because FD deviated from their original Engineers idea: interesting sidegrades to customize the ships. This was perceived as too grindy for not enough oomph, so they vastly reduced the grind and massively increased the effects gained. So then we complained that it isn't fair to get the things the same community asked for, and FD should give their work away for free.

Engineers is a perfect example for why listening to your customers isn't always the best idea...
Totally agree engineers should of been a side grades with greater negative effects to keep some sort of balance since we play along side the base game owners but i'm almost 100% sure they were intended to be over-powered to drive sales.
 
As was I, but not having any (thank $deity), I have no idea how kids are raised now.

Judging from the results not very well.

You think? Neither my partner nor I can afford to smoke, and we drink a LOT less than we used to, due to the cost.


Maybe thats a good thing health wise


And that's rather sexist! I've never asked nor expected money spent on me, not even when I lost my job and home about 12 years ago. If you've only ever met women who did expect it, then that's more on you for hanging with the wrong company. I mean sure it's nice if people spend on one, but very few people actually expect it.



Remind me how much an Anaconda is in Elite credits. I live in London - Millionaires and rough sleeper in the same place.
 
Last edited:
Totally agree engineers should of been a side grades with greater negative effects to keep some sort of balance since we play along side the base game owners but i'm almost 100% sure they were intended to be over-powered to drive sales.

I hated it in wow when people bought the expansion and became stronger and had new places to play in. I worked hard in vanilla to be the strongest and best and strongly complained when new content made me underpowered.

/SARCASM
 
So many of you are telling the OP to "go buy it, it's only a few bucks / pounds / euro's"


Yet none of you are volunteering despite continually making the point that the price is so low as to be almost meaningless pocket change.


If you're the kind of person that would pick up a dollar / pound / euro - from the pavement instead of walking past - then you saying to him "it's just a few....." are hypocrites.



Like I said I don't get a commiosn

Maybe Frontier can set a charity to help gamers in need . Who are unable


Thanks I will email Obsidition EA with that argument see what they say.


There's a point being made by the OP and most of you aren't getting it.


** I always asume its a set up and its glued to the floor.

***Where r you in the world? I live in Capitalist London paid £150 before release.

**Yet you fell able to tell everyone else what to do. Are you going to volunteer?

So if you're not willing to give him the money - or group together to help him buy it - it's not quite such a meaningless amount after all is it?

** Didn't say in was mingles. Highlighted that it was at a 76% discount

**I think that was just me.

** I always asume its a set up and its glued to the floor.


**Maybe Frontier can set a charity to help gamers in need . Who are unable to afford to game.

Tried the doing the lottery? Euro near 101m oh wait its cost £2.50 to enter.


Why not raise these directly with the Chairman of the company.


I would like a shiny anaconda ? Can I just fly to Hutton Orbital and pick up the free One?
 
Last edited:
If standard elite owners are going to face engineered ships, then the base game should provide access to level 3 engineering, purchasing horizons unlocks it to grade 5.
 
I hated it in wow when people bought the expansion and became stronger and had new places to play in. I worked hard in vanilla to be the strongest and best and strongly complained when new content made me underpowered.

/SARCASM

You mean like when corporations instead of taking the time and investment to develop a product just buy a competitor and assest strip or kill the competion >or when football teams buy player rather than develop home grown players then complain when national team cant win games?


Also one word Starcitizen.
 
Last edited:
I guess this won't be popular with anybody who was hoping to get Horizons for free but another alternative would be to just spawn NPC-builds based on the detection of Horizons.

High-rank player + Horizons = Engineered NPCs.
High-rank player - Horizons = Unengineered NPCs.

If numerous players are in an instance together then the game could spawn a mixure of engineered and non-engineered NPCs based on the proportion of Horizons/non-Horizons players.


It's definitely silly to always spawn engineered NPC when there are non-Horizons players who don't have access to engineering though.
It's right up there with creating CGs which require planetary landing to participate equitably.

Keep saying the same thing; this is the fundamental problem with creating exclusive expansions.
It fragments the player-base and forces the dev's to create content which ignores any of the features an expansion might provide.

And this is only ever going to get worse when/if we get space-legs and atmo' landings - assuming they're paid expansions too.

I'd love to see, for example, a CG which involved defending surface installations from attacking ships (and, ideally, waves of invading SRVs too) but it's never going to happen as long as there are players who don't have access to planetary landing.
 
There isn't a guaranteed shelf life on any iteration of a game. Not only can the developer change whatever they want at any time, a vast majority of the player base expects them to, and not doing so would mean the death of their game. If you don't want to grow with the game by buying new expansions, then too bad. I don't think they should waste an ounce of energy worrying about those who choose to play an old version. They should consider it no longer supported.
 
Engineering exists and invariably influences the game for non-Horizon players, even if they aren't facing Engineered vessels in combat, in any mode.

This is unavoidable and omitting Engineered NPCs for non-Horizons players wouldn't be any more 'fair' and wouldn't address the advantages Horizons players have.

The current system is essentially pay to win and I do find this undesirable. My preferred solution would be to stop selling Horizons separately and make each successive paid expansion a free part of the base game after a certain point, say 12-18 months.

I guess this won't be popular with anybody who was hoping to get Horizons for free but another alternative would be to just spawn NPC-builds based on the detection of Horizons.

High-rank player + Horizons = Engineered NPCs.
High-rank player - Horizons = Unengineered NPCs.

I often fly an unengineered Viper against Engineered NPCs and by and large, can still mop the floor with them. I'm sure there are non-Horizons players that appreciate the challenge Engineered foes provide.

Regardless, I've never found difficulty scaling to be good gameplay in any game. The full spectrum of NPC quality should exist irrespective of the CMDR, and should be placed where they make sense to be, doing what it makes sense for them to do. If someone doesn't have the tools to face them, they should avoid those areas and refrain from attracting the hostile attention of those capable of fielding such opposition.
 
Last edited:
Engineering exists and invariably influences the game for non-Horizon players, even if they aren't facing Engineered vessels in combat, in any mode.

This is unavoidable and omitting Engineered NPCs for non-Horizons players wouldn't be any more 'fair' and wouldn't address the advantages Horizons players have.

The current system is essentially pay to win and I do find this undesirable. My preferred solution would be to stop selling Horizons separately and make each successive paid expansion a free part of the base game after a certain point, say 12-18 months.

I imagine only 2.8% of daily active players don't own Horizons.

There's a point at which you can probably draw a line and say well, upgrade please, it's cheap enough, you get a whole bunch of stuff and we do have to support servers.

I bet every single person posting in this thread owns Horizons.
 
Last edited:
I imagine only 2.8% of active players don't own Horizons.

There's a point at which you can probably draw a line and say well, upgrade please, it's cheap enough and you get a whole bunch of stuff and we do have to support servers.

I bet every single person posting in this thread owns Horizons.

I think it was silly to have tangible advantages that were exclusive to Horizons in the first place and I wouldn't draw such a line. If Horizons was simply new locations or gameplay types, that would be one thing, but it's a lot more than that.

I'm strongly of the opinion that there is nothing I have that a user of the base game should not be able to attain, unless it's something that has zero utility for non-Horizons content (e.g. the SRV), and my opinion wouldn't change if there was only one non-Horizons player in existence.
 
Listen, you are not getting what he's saying - it's quite simple if you took a breath for just a moment from that rant and thought about it.

He's playing the version of Elite where the only thing available is bows and arrows and basic leather armour from 2000 years ago - figuratively - yet all the NPC's he's being FORCED (yes FORCED, as there's no other option available) to interact with all have Modern Kevlar armour with armour piercing ammunition.

Tell you what - lets have a fight - you get a knife and I'll bring a Magnum .45 - sounds fair right? (I'm being rhetorical mods, pretty obvious but just to be sure)

Regardless of whether you think the OP is right or wrong about not buying the Horizons expansion - there should be NO OVERLAP OF ASSETS. PERIOD.

It IS possible if you pay attention to the code - anyone who's played older multiplayer games with different code versions would know this.

Also having a go at the OP because you don't have ANY CLUE about his financial restrictions or ability is in pretty poor taste and you owe him an apology.

And don't even get me started on FDev's policy regarding the "value as sold" of thier products or you and I are going to have a real problem, because ED as it stands today is still missing HUGE chunks of content sold in the KS with no ETA being given as to WHEN - or even IF - it will arrive.

@Bortas and the rest who are saying "just buy it" - each of you put in a dollar and he can have it - otherwise ask a question: "WHY hasn't he got Horizons" and consider there may just be a very valid reason that you in your 2 car garage house and "3.9 Earths lifestyle" are forgetting.

such arrogance.

This is the attitude that stops the game from being engaging.
 
Last edited:
OP, you're gonna get into trouble with some of the lepers, they want even more $$$ dlcs...

(Not that fdev should listen to extremist lepers :) )

Plus: if horizons is rolled into the base game, how will I recover when I get my srv jammed on a brain tree? :D

Ermmm, why is it impossible not to make OP DLCs?
 
Last edited:
Alternatively, maybe they did think for longer than 10 seconds and realized that that would be problematic to say the least if you want non-Horizons to play with Horizons cmdrs in the same instance. Besides, it is completely absurd to pretend you need engineering to play the game versus NPCs. Never mind that people had three years or so to save up the whopping $6 they charge for Horizons.
https://store.steampowered.com/app/441340/Elite_Dangerous_Horizons_Season_Pass/

Rather than be grateful you get so much for six bucks, people complain they should get it for free? Get out of here man...

That's assuming they began playing when the game launched.
 
This whole argument only exists because FD deviated from their original Engineers idea: interesting sidegrades to customize the ships. This was perceived as too grindy for not enough oomph, so they vastly reduced the grind and massively increased the effects gained. So then we complained that it isn't fair to get the things the same community asked for, and FD should give their work away for free.

Engineers is a perfect example for why listening to your customers isn't always the best idea...

Customize you ship? Engineers? Are you kidding me? That's paintjobs, bobbleheads, ship kits and engine color, that's ​customization.
 
Back
Top Bottom