Cheap option for foot pedals.

I often feel like even with a HOTAS the throttle is a bit limiting. It's a lot harder to do anything that requires any sort of reaching, however small, in particular, yet some binds for me just aren't comfortable putting on the HOTAS no matter which way around I try them. It struck me while I was riding around in my SRV that foot pedals would be a great solution. I have feet, why not use them? I believe this game wouldn't even care if they are a separate controller as its control systems are pretty good, but it has to be something analog (too bad -- there are tons of super cheap pedals that are just a toggle switch that I could have just wired into the HOTAS, but obviously analog control is necessary.) Not just for the whole sweet spot thing, but some things (like landing) just don't work too well with an all or nothing while some things kind of need it (like actually flying through a system to a point 500,000 LS away where you really don't want that throttle less than 100% until you're actually close... Though it would lose the set and forget needed for Hutton Orbital, I only needed to go there once just to say that I did, lol.) I would also be able to dedicate my throttle to something else such as, perhaps, vertical thrust which might benefit from an analog control.

I've been looking around at a few options. My best bet is probably to buy something used and old (and probably getting worn out) on eBay, but it's really difficult to find anything particularly promising -- especially when you don't really have the right search terms. I keep either finding ultra-expensive ones intended for high-end flight sim rudder controls or some so poorly made I'm pretty sure they won't last. Not to mention just a host of digital toggles with no analog. Money is a huge issue for me right now and I know I'm treading on expensive ground here, but are there any sort of semi-decent options out there for really cheap pedals that would work for this? I'm thinking maybe of gutting some racing controller or something like that, but I'm just not even really sure and even most of those (sadly) do not come with foot pedals so start to become expensive when they do.
 
Well, I'm able to google too, but I don't really know about doing DIY ones. I'm decent with tools and all, but building that sort of thing is a bit much and I especially don't want to have to even be the one to deal with having to try to make physical components physically move a pot without breaking it. They have machines and calculations for doing that right but I do not. I was hoping there was something cheap but premade that might work. DIY just means too much investment of time, effort, and yes, money too because you have to buy all those parts and experiment around until you get it right (which inevitably results in parts getting broken/trashed/etc.) It doesn't have to be great -- after all, most throttles really aren't very special internally anyway -- just enough that I'll be able to have sufficient control (allowing a bit of time to get used to it of course.)
 
I played the original Elite with two pieces of wood hinged together, a piece of string, a nail as a pulley, a sliding potentiometer and an elastic band. It was incredibly badly put together but it got me to Elite.

These days you need something to interface that to the computer. The Arduino Leonardo makes it easy, but only if you can program moderately well.

That's going to be your problem: you need it to present itself as a USB game controller. If you go too far away from "foot pedals made for PC gaming" then it won't be a PC game controller and you will have to get into electronics and programming to get it to work.
 
I made these with a second hand joystick, a TV swivel mounting, angle brackets and shelf supports. I connected the pivot to the joystick stub with a pipeclip. Total cost about £20 or you could look for second hand pedals. Well made pro level pedals cost quite a bit.
1577714452451.png
1577714510158.png
1577714537135.png
1577714602147.png
 
I made these with a second hand joystick, a TV swivel mounting, angle brackets and shelf supports. I connected the pivot to the joystick stub with a pipeclip. Total cost about £20 or you could look for second hand pedals. Well made pro level pedals cost quite a bit.
View attachment 157189 View attachment 157190 View attachment 157191 View attachment 157192
The diamond plate is astonishing. Using bungee cords for tension was a stoke of genius! My hat's off to you. Salute from the USA at your ingenuity.Throw a couple McPherson struts in the water, shrink 'em down to scale, then you can put a couple of micro switches on to simulate toe brakes, LOL. In my twenty plus years in the US navy, I could have used your jury rigging talent several times.

Fly High, Fast & Dangerously
The Ancient Mariner
 
I use an ELECOM M-HT1URBK 10-button trackball that turns into 18-buttons with [L-Ctrl] held down. And bind the controls to toggle the Ball's (Pitch + [Roll or Yaw]) to the button under my (right) ring-finger. The best of the low-budget ($60) controllers for the K&M crowd. Not a proper pedal solution but I thought you all should know about this option.
 
Last edited:
The diamond plate is astonishing. Using bungee cords for tension was a stoke of genius! My hat's off to you. Salute from the USA at your ingenuity.Throw a couple McPherson struts in the water, shrink 'em down to scale, then you can put a couple of micro switches on to simulate toe brakes, LOL. In my twenty plus years in the US navy, I could have used your jury rigging talent several times.

Fly High, Fast & Dangerously
The Ancient Mariner
Thanks, they worked well for a couple of years. On the Il-2 Ubizoo there was a stick modder thread that showed some amazing ideas. I later bought Saitek pedals but have had MFG crosswinds for the past 2 years. Dear but very nice :)
 
I played the original Elite with two pieces of wood hinged together, a piece of string, a nail as a pulley, a sliding potentiometer and an elastic band. It was incredibly badly put together but it got me to Elite.

These days you need something to interface that to the computer. The Arduino Leonardo makes it easy, but only if you can program moderately well.

That's going to be your problem: you need it to present itself as a USB game controller. If you go too far away from "foot pedals made for PC gaming" then it won't be a PC game controller and you will have to get into electronics and programming to get it to work.
Find a gash keyboard - smash it open and wire switches between the wires on the pcb - this will do for button controllers.

For Joysticks, buy a broken one off ebay - wire into the potentiometers - same game.. no software required..
 
I wonder if it would be profitable or worthwhile to offer programmed Arduinos for sale. Or maybe just the download files. Apart from the programming, they're just plug and play. Four 5V analogue signals and however many 5V switches. The authentic ones even come with a base-plate that makes fixing them down easy and safe. It would be a whole lot less faff than breaking apart a keyboard or joystick.

20200107_154253.jpg
 
Back
Top Bottom