Discovery scan orbital data make little sense

There is one thing that bugged me massively during my recent exploration trip, and that is that the data available after a discovery scan make little sense.

You enter a system, toot your horn, and after that, the computer obviously has enough data to plot complete orbits of the discovered objects. To do this, the computer needs to have all orbital elements.

These are:


  • the semi-major axis (basically the longer of the two "radii" of the elliptical orbit)
  • the eccentricity (describes how elliptic the orbit is)
  • the inclination (tilt of the orbit relative to the system's reference plane)
  • the argument of the periapsis (a second angle describing the orientation of the ellipse)
  • the longitude of the ascending node (a third angle describing the orientation of the ellipse)

Ignoring for a moment that the latter isn't mentioned at all in the game, it doesn't make the slightest bit of sense that a discovered, but not yet surface scanned object's data on the system map only includes the semi-major axis.

341FBJe.jpg

Only after completing the surface scan, we get the rest of the orbital parameters:
S4UUI8z.jpg
I get that things like the rotational period or atmospheric composition are only available after a surface scan, but the orbital parameters are clearly already obtained after the discovery scan.
 
Last edited:
Aargh... Something else for me to lay awake at night worrying about!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rdk-rHAndNc

As for the OP, I get invested in this game too, but perhaps a good way to approach this kind of stuff is to just explain it away in your mind and play. In this instance I just tell myself the discovery scanner does actually get the data required, but doesn't display it for some reason. And all is right with the galaxy again.

I do however like your attention to detail :)
 
As for the OP, I get invested in this game too, but perhaps a good way to approach this kind of stuff is to just explain it away in your mind and play. In this instance I just tell myself the discovery scanner does actually get the data required, but doesn't display it for some reason. And all is right with the galaxy again.
Bah! Humbug! I don't buy your apologetics! ZorgonSoft sold a crappy version of their scanner software, and there's no excuse for that! This has to be patched immediately!

:p
 
Maybe the spaceship lady (aka Tank Lady from RvB) doesn't think you are interested until you spend time scanning the body.
I'm quite happy that she makes this decision for me, I would have to google a lot of the long words anyway, and probably still be none the wiser.

"the argument of the periapsis" sounds like some hardcore theoretical maths problem that nobody have managed to solve yet, even in 3302.

Edited to try to hide incompetence
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom