I think the job of the players is to express what they want, why they want it, and maybe spitball some ideas. Expecting it to be well balanced and well designed gameplay loop is unreasonable. OP is doing what players should, and we as a community should be encouraging people who are genuinely interested in the game improving, expanding and growing.The Fdevs have limited resources to spend fine-tuning ideas after they get into the game. This is one of the more compelling reasons to state a clear and concise problem and then find a definitive solution as this leads to less extraneous and poor design decisions.