Unlike many explorers (apparently) I have decided to play the role of an actual pathfinder-explorer. Find a cluster of stars and start moving through them. Surface scan all planets that may be useful for the colonisation of space by the Human race. This is meant to be a kind of RPG after all. Of course, there would be a certain number of commanders who simply head off into the Night to see what's out there. But there would also be many who would be employed to survey star systems in the hope that they can be colonized or exploited in some way.
My goal isn't just to find an Earth-like (although I have found 2 so far), it is to discover new places that Human space can expand into. I have found scores of terrestrial water worlds and a fair few hundred terraformable planets. I started with 3 trips that only went out 500-1000Ly from Sol (not the edge of human space). I discovered hundreds of un-scanned systems and earned more than enough to completely outfit an Asp. I am now 5500Ly out and moving slowly through Thrakaae (sp?) Sector towards the Lagoon Nebula. I have no doubt that the Nebula itself (which is about 1000Ly from my current position) has been completely scanned, but for the last 5 days since leaving the Cat's Paw Nebula every single system I have visited has been virgin territory.
If your aim is to zip around the Galaxy looking only for Black Holes or Neutron Stars, then that is your choice. Just don't be surprised when you find some other yahoo has been there first.
If you truly want to explore and discover new systems (and have the patience to do so) just find a sector of space, turn off the route planner on your Galaxy Map, and pick a star to jump to. NOT just the bright and shiny ones....
Just outside the Cat's Paw Nebula I found one system where the star had a 'discovered by' tag. There were 10 planets in the system. There was one which, on ADS, looked like it may have been Earth-like. It had a 'discovered by' tag on it (same guy as on the star). None of the other planets had been tagged.
I went through them. Found 2 Terraformables, 3 Terrestrial Water Worlds (2 of these were Ammonia Worlds). The tagged planet was a simple Water World.
That is what cherry-picking does for you.
So, do what you enjoy most, but don't complain. Because it is a big Galaxy. Just head in a different direction and try again.
Cmdr Sebastien Ortec
Aboard the Asp Explorer - Sundiver