First time I've stopped in Elite and just said. 'wow'.

Not sure why it caught my attention so much, but it's the first time I've actually stopped in Elite just to take a picture by being captured by the 'wow' factor.

Entered a system to be greeted by this.

4tpwuQCl.jpg

A close up (before I started frying).

g4c4Tqhl.jpg

Actually gave me pause for a minute, first time Elite has done that for me. Just thought I would share. Well, off to the founders world I go! :cool:
 
If you go to I bootis (The Beta starting point)
There is a binary star system that has broken the critical proximity that two stars can attain (They should have collided), but the game just models them as being ridiculously close together.
Stars are named I Bootis B/C

There is no reason at all for anybody to go there... If you try and fly between them, you get stuck in a heat well, your will fall out of super cruise, your FSD will be unable to cool down and your ship will overheat until you die.
ZtFosXT.jpg
 
Last edited:
If you go to I bootis (The Beta starting point)
There is a binary star system that has broken the critical proximity that two stars can attain (They should have collided), but the game just models them as being ridiculously close together.
Stars are named I Bootis B/C

There is no reason at all for anybody to go there... If you try and fly between them, you get stuck in a heat well, your will fall out of super cruise, your FSD will be unable to cool down and your ship will overheat until you die.
ZtFosXT.jpg

I really hope FD consider putting in animations for such stars, such as the smaller being sucked slowly into the larger one. Or two stars of equal size causing a black hole ;)
 
You see this is where some of us part company - this is a completely incongruous and impossible scene - these should be massively interacting conjoined twins, the smaller one parasitizing the larger one (the smaller one must have the heavier core, or else would've been subsumed already). There's just no interaction at all between them - you could cut'n'paste both of them onto separate backgrounds and there'd be nothing amiss; no clue they'd just been wrested from one another's fratricidal grasp.

Without elongating deformation, accretion discs, and blinding, cataclysmic, teeth-shattering explosions as gas-giant-sized globules of plasma are ripped from the belching donor's disc, smashing down into the furious marauding upstart, it's just, so.. meh.

Did you know FE2 has contact binaries too? Including some where the smaller twin lies fully within the corona of its larger sibling. You even get some that are perfectly centered on each other, like Russian dolls. However, like the ones pictured here, they're just statistical accidents, outliers of an otherwise inert and indifferent probability distribution. They look 'nice' insofar as all ED's stars do - but this is no contact binary in any meaningful sense. Just a cut'n'shut of regular stars pasted side by side - its only anomaly is the absence of any semblance of what actually makes such pairs so interesting to astronomers.

Like planetary landings, they should've been omitted until they could be properly rendered... where you're seeing something wondrous, awesome and special, anyone with an interest in astronomy is seeing conspicuous absences...
 
When I first saw screenshots like this I was like: "Looks interesting but totally unrealistic. How can two bodies of such mass exist next to each other without collapsing into one?"

Then, someone here on the forum pointed out that binary stars actually do exist. ED is teaching me about astronomy...

Edit:

You see this is where some of us part company - this is a completely incongruous and impossible scene - these should be massively interacting conjoined twins, the smaller one parasitizing the larger one (the smaller one must have the heavier core, or else would've been subsumed already). There's just no interaction at all between them - you could cut'n'paste both of them onto separate backgrounds and there'd be nothing amiss; no clue they'd just been wrested from one another's fratricidal grasp.

Without elongating deformation, accretion discs, and blinding, cataclysmic, teeth-shattering explosions as gas-giant-sized globules of plasma are ripped from the belching donor's disc, smashing down into the furious marauding upstart, it's just, so.. meh.

Did you know FE2 has contact binaries too? Including some where the smaller twin lies fully within the corona of its larger sibling. You even get some that are perfectly centered on each other, like Russian dolls. However, like the ones pictured here, they're just statistical accidents, outliers of an otherwise inert and indifferent probability distribution. They look 'nice' insofar as all ED's stars do - but this is no contact binary in any meaningful sense. Just a cut'n'shut of regular stars pasted side by side - its only anomaly is the absence of any semblance of what actually makes such pairs so interesting to astronomers.

Like planetary landings, they should've been omitted until they could be properly rendered... where you're seeing something wondrous, awesome and special, anyone with an interest in astronomy is seeing conspicuous absences...

...or maybe not :D
 
Last edited:
You see this is where some of us part company - this is a completely incongruous and impossible scene - these should be massively interacting conjoined twins, the smaller one parasitizing the larger one (the smaller one must have the heavier core, or else would've been subsumed already). There's just no interaction at all between them - you could cut'n'paste both of them onto separate backgrounds and there'd be nothing amiss; no clue they'd just been wrested from one another's fratricidal grasp.

Without elongating deformation, accretion discs, and blinding, cataclysmic, teeth-shattering explosions as gas-giant-sized globules of plasma are ripped from the belching donor's disc, smashing down into the furious marauding upstart, it's just, so.. meh.

Did you know FE2 has contact binaries too? Including some where the smaller twin lies fully within the corona of its larger sibling. You even get some that are perfectly centered on each other, like Russian dolls. However, like the ones pictured here, they're just statistical accidents, outliers of an otherwise inert and indifferent probability distribution. They look 'nice' insofar as all ED's stars do - but this is no contact binary in any meaningful sense. Just a cut'n'shut of regular stars pasted side by side - its only anomaly is the absence of any semblance of what actually makes such pairs so interesting to astronomers.

Like planetary landings, they should've been omitted until they could be properly rendered... where you're seeing something wondrous, awesome and special, anyone with an interest in astronomy is seeing conspicuous absences...

I agree that FD should look at adding accretion disks to binary stars to make them more realistic rather than placing two stars really close to each other. They could easily just say that if the stars are within so many lightseconds of each other then this accretion effect is applied but the problem is that they will need to divert resources in doing this which may take a while to get right so it may appear soon ™ once the more important stuff is done.
 
Yeah i'm sure given DB's love of astronomy this is gnawing at him too. Otherwise it'd be a crying shame given the game's edutainmnet value...
 
I agree, highly unrealistic: www astronomynow com/news/n0912/17binary/

Amazing imagery, but underlines the complexity of doing these systems justice. This was why i'd hoped stars in ED would be made from virtual plasma, so that the intricate complexities of these systems could be played out uniquely and procedurally for each occurrence.

Not lab-quality sims, obvioushly, but just rendered to look convincing enough to be results of sims.. maybe using fractals or something, i've honestly no idea how it might work.. perhaps this kind of functionality is implicit in a comprehensive definition of "stellar forge" (FD's proprietary star generator software) and thus in the pipeline..
 
Back
Top Bottom