LostWinds Gamespot review: 5.5/10

The reviewer cites sloppy controls and camera glitches, which doesn't make any sense. The only problem I had with the controls was trying to get a rock on a switch, but that was only because I didn't realize I could use the slipstream on it. As for the camera, the only thing I can think of is he somehow didn't know you can zoom out. He then goes on to bash the setting of the caves, calling them ugly and dreary. Would he criticize Zelda's dungeons for being dark and not flowing with sunshine and happiness? Doubtful. Taken from his review: "For instance, horizontal commands are sometimes reversed. Even if you clearly move the Wii Remote from the left side of the screen to the right, the wind will sometimes blow in the opposite direction.". Ok, that's just plain not true. I've heard that that reviewer has a fairly established anti-Nintendo past on the NeoGAF forums. Gamespot is a major game site. I'd think they'd be a bit more professional with the way they operate. Then again, after that whole Kane and Lynch fiasco, this shouldn't come as too much of a surprise.

I made this topic because that review is just plain ridiculous. And I absolutely love this game and felt the need to defend it a little. <_<; This game has quickly became one of my favorite games in some years and I've already played through it several times, something I almost never do with games. Congratulations Frontier, you've created a wonderful experience.
 
Indeed totally out of sync with pretty much every other industry review of between 8 and 9. Reviewer is clearly not to be trusted.

In the Gamespot forums both the reviewer and Gamespot themselves have been utterly slated and discredited. Simply moronic.
 
Last edited:

Michael Brookes

Game Director
As you can imagine it's not our favourite review either :) At the end of the day reviews are people's opinions, it's interesting to note that the other WiiWare game they reviewed didn't review well either.

Michael
 
The gamespot reviewer must have been one of the undead

I couldn't believe this review after playing the game :confused:. Totally wrong.
It must be very annoying for the developers/designers to see this kind of mis-representation of their game. Unfortunately gamespot is one of the bigger game sites and this won't help sales.
 
True, but their reputation isn't so hot these days, so it hopefully shouldn't have too much of an impact. And when a game has otherwise wonderful reviews, that one bad review isn't likely to hold much weight.

I have been curious about the sales. I wonder if the numbers will be released. Virtual Console numbers aren't, but WiiWare might be different.
 
The most bemusing part of it I found was the when he claimed it "lacked personality" :eek: , I have to wonder what game he was playing because it certainly wasn't Lost Winds
 
Apparently the reviewer is fairly well known for slating anything that's on the Wii as is Gamespot themselves. Suffice to say I have stopped regularily checking gamespot for reviews. IGN is my new review haunt.
 
Apparently the reviewer is fairly well known for slating anything that's on the Wii as is Gamespot themselves. Suffice to say I have stopped regularily checking gamespot for reviews. IGN is my new review haunt.

I began my shunning of Gamespot after they gave Twilight Princess an 8.8
 
As did many people.

IGN is great. Aside from their better reviews, they also seem to get news and previews way before other places.
 
After Geff Gerstmann was ousted, Gamespot disappeared off my must read list.

I'm hardly surprised they didn't like Lost Winds; it's charming, interesting, different: i.e. it's not one lone cuacasian faceless marine chainsaw'ing heads off which is all Gamespot seem to care about these days.
 
I thought this review was bizarre too. It just doesn't make sense given that the game controls better than any game for a while and looks stunning. Oh well, the truth is in the playing.
 
since when do gamespot reviews count for anything? they seem to be giving away scores of ten these days to games that dont really deserve it. I dont agree with their lostwinds review at all. Eurogamer gave it a 9 and agree with that score, not just because its the same score I'd the game myself, but just because eurogamer is the review site i trust the most, they are pretty much always bang on the money with reviews.
 
Back
Top Bottom