Good sense or good fun?

No it doesn't.
That hole in the hull is a huge safety risk. The glowing blue "shield" breaks down and * poof * the explosive decompression. Thus, you want it as small as possible because of two reasons.
1.: closing it as fast as possible
2.: the unusable area of a round entrance is HUGE, large ships could still just go through the middle. But it is more than enough space for more air to flow out in the above case. So cost / effect ratio is really bad … because explosive decompression is really bad.

I wish I coulde explain better, but I guess you get what I mean.
 
You know what makes more sense than a rotating rectangular docking entrance? A round one.
The engineer in me disagrees. I'd design the smallest portal possible to reduce the power requirement to maintain the atmo-shield, yet still allow for safe passage of the largest vessels. In the emergency event that the station needs to be locked down, you're not going to close your round hole quickly. At least my mailslot can have a mechanical bay door I can slide down.
 
No it doesn't.
That hole in the hull is a huge safety risk. The glowing blue "shield" breaks down and * poof * the explosive decompression. Thus, you want it as small as possible because of two reasons.
1.: closing it as fast as possible
2.: the unusable area of a round entrance is HUGE, large ships could still just go through the middle. But it is more than enough space for more air to flow out in the above case. So cost / effect ratio is really bad … because explosive decompression is really bad.

I wish I coulde explain better, but I guess you get what I mean.

Well I understand what you mean however, a circular opening;

1) Has the maximum area for minimum circumference. ie for a given length of hole provides the largest opening.
2) Does not have any unusable area around the entrance if the ship cross-section is circular.
3) Is easier to fit a cork in, in the event of explosive decompression.

I guess either ships were designed to maximize the rectangular station slot geometry, or the station rectangular geometry was implemented to compliment rectangular ship cross- section. It's a chicken and egg situation. :)
 
There's only one issue I see with this. It then wouldn't be the same as the original 1984 game:

EliteOrigStarport.png
 
Arthur C. Clarke and Stanley Kubrick would also disagree.

I would, however, agree that making the mailslot non-rotating (i.e. counter-rotating to the station) would be a good compromise.

Edit: Ninja'd on Kubrick. :geek:
 
As stated above, don’t be messing with things that have been carried over from the original. Cuz I might have a problem with that. And we might have to meet outside the saloon at Lave Station at high noon. And I don’t think you want that.
 
Back
Top Bottom