I'm too new to vote in the poll, but I got my DK2. Elite is amazing, and there's definitely presence, even with the relatively low-res DK2 screens.
I hate the galaxy and system map with a passion, and hate having to take the headset off to look stuff up on google... but the beauty and immersion makes up for that.
It's very weird when the pilot model moves its arms - feels like my own arms are moving - and while I don't get motion sick, I have made myself dizzy more than once in high-speed landings (which have fortunately led to no rapid unscheduled disassembly events yet!)
Learn to love using the galaxy map. Here's how: https://forums.frontier.co.uk/showthread.php?t=132901