Hardware & Technical I require assistance. X52 or X55?

I am just about ready to purchase a new hotas and have narrowed it down to these two contenders. Any one that has either of these Hotas, I would appreciate any feedback from you. Pro's / Con's of either Hotas.

Saitek X52 pro / Saitek X55

Thanks.. :rolleyes:
 
Well, I just read reviews, watched videos and then it was fairly apparent. Besides it's common among any similar products. How long does said company take to up the QA process. How long will a lesser model last before the better model is, better. What kind of deal is available to you, now. How likely are you to recoup some of assets used when a switch is in order.

I got a 52-pro for a snazzy price. I barely use the throttle. Considering the nicest thing about the 55 is...the throttle you see my reasoning. I also take care of stuff and am decent with electronics/mechanical stuff. I'll find a buyer for my x52-pro when something better comes along at an appropriate price.

I would have bought a Warthog if it had twist.

The 52 pro is a tad loose stick wise. But it is accurate and very smooth. Noticed a positive difference immediately. 2 hats which are fairly usable, I have smaller hands but the stick isn't too big. I haven't fiddled with the modes or even programmed the thing. I plugged it in, drivers downloaded, calibrated it, open elite, map keys, done. I've heard of ppl with software problems but :shrug: got 99 and that ain't one. Maybe I'm missing out on something but it works for me. It's construction is not what I would consider rugged, but it doesn't feel delicate however I am a slender fellow with a light touch (5'8"ish 155lbs).

The throttle. IMO they dropped the ball. There simply aren't buttons where you would think there should be. Smooth though but with a weird "lock", thing going on at the top and bottom of the range respectively. IMO the turny thingies they have are useless and not very intuitive. Basically like 2 or 3 ok buttons. Good thing I am not huge into the throttle and it tucks in my desk snugly while still being accessible. It's actually a retractable throttle. I fly space ships u kno ;)

I use a T1600 for left when piloting little stuff, throttle for boats. If you are unsure about hotas setups the T1600 would probably be my nomination for best bang/buck. 60 ish with hall sensors and sturdy construction. No brainer. I mean voice attack pretty much obviates throttles unless dogfight, which I do hence a joystick for my thrusts. The pelvic kind....!!!

I dunno, I don't regret my Pro but I often buy stuff just to see if I like it. Frankly until some issues are worked out and I get better at scripting I'll lightly use my X52-Pro until I get a dual T1600 setup off the ground. But I am weird everyone says so.
 
I am just about ready to purchase a new hotas and have narrowed it down to these two contenders. Any one that has either of these Hotas, I would appreciate any feedback from you. Pro's / Con's of either Hotas.

Saitek X52 pro / Saitek X55

Thanks.. :rolleyes:

Yes, I would very much appreciate some feed back on these two products too please. Thanks:)
 
I have never used the X-52 so I can't compare. It seems a lot of the Devs use it and FD sells it. I've used the X-55 for months and love it. Most of the controls seem to be in the right place per the default X-55 profile supplied with ED plus lots of switches to tweak to your liking. No local custom profile is needed. Just load the basic drivers and select the X-55 profile in the game. The only time I use the keyboard is to type in a system name or hit the ESC key to exit the game to the main menus. It also works perfectly with X-Plane 10xx if you're into flight sims. Note that some motherboards do not supply enough current for the X-55 and this causes multiple issues especially when docking. I added a powered USB hub (they're cheap) and it has worked perfectly ever since.
 
Last edited:
i have the X52 (non pro) and have had no trouble with it, it's easy to set up and very accurate and has made my games so much better.

having had several joystics over the years i was genuinely surprised just how much of an improvement it has been

hope this info helps.
 
I have both. I can recommend the X55 over the 52, but both are well made pieces of kit. I have everything that is assignable assigned to all the buttons/switches on the 55 and still have room for more commands.
 
I am just about ready to purchase a new hotas and have narrowed it down to these two contenders. Any one that has either of these Hotas, I would appreciate any feedback from you. Pro's / Con's of either Hotas.

Saitek X52 pro / Saitek X55

Thanks.. :rolleyes:

X65f ;-) One left on amazon.co.uk. Bleedin' great HOTAS
 
i had an x-52 and now a X-55, without doubt i would recommend the x-55, i couldn´t live without all the hats and extra buttons it has, the throttle hats are really useful for managing your ship´s thrusters, you don´t have anything compared to that in the x-52.

about building quality both are the same, but i feel better response in the X-55 and the software is much more complete when you want to do fine tunning in your axis.

Throttle shape is also more ergonomic and fits better to your hand / wrist.
 
Back
Top Bottom