I think the majority of people will find it boring, the majority of people are not very bright though, so there is no real surprise.
People mouthing off in chat is largely irrelevant innit.
This.
As I have thought about this more, really the comment shows someone that has not done any reflection at all and is just spouting.
Consider that every single game is boring after a short while. Chess; plays the same every time, checkers, even worse. FPS games - all identical basically, run, gun, die on 10 maps with 10 weapon choices and then turn to modding to keep up your interest. Story driven games, fun for a while but being driven down a rail for 20 hours wears thin and when the game is over is it replayable? Other forms of entertainment: movies- good for 2 hours and at most 3 viewings for the absolute best ones; books- put you to sleep but maybe 6 hours enjoyment for a long one. Riding a bike - more than an hour only for the dedicated. ETC.
So really, this type of comment is quite odd.
Some games with mechanics like Chess or RTS games have more replay value or staying power over time. Elite has such long-term promise to hold my interest and offer new experiences in the game world for at least several years, which I really like. Needn't play it every day. Pick it up after a couple of months and visit a new station, see what has happened in the Persistent Universe, nice.