Engineers Information about Engineers materials is very often non-existent

I'm having serious issues with some aspects of the game, which has been recently highlighted with a search for Arsenic in the Engineers update.

There's just not enough information in-game about what things are, and where they can be found. Arsenic in this specific example is described by the engineer as "Collected from planet surfaces and from asteroids". Thanks for this quality information, as there are only a billion, billion planets in the galaxy :(

This forces us to resort to the forums, Facebook groups and the wider Internet to find the most basic information, which usually comes in the form of a direct solution to go to planet XYZ, and not the "found on high metal content worlds, or ice planets" that we might expect to encourage exploration and gameplay.

What's more, this having to leave the game to use the Internet is ruining the experience and immersion for me. This surely is what Galnet should be for? Why is this in-game resource not able to have a database of all the stuff found in the game, with information on where we can find it, what it's used for and why we might need to.

Another example, if somebody needs meta-alloys, I cannot point to a single thing in the game that would tell players that they can be found at barnacle sites, what barnacles are, or where they can be found. There's no list of "Barnacles have already been found on these planets, or this type of world". We could then, another update the game needs, be able to use our advanced discovery scanners, or a new planetary scanner, to search from orbit for the approximate location of the element or item we're looking for, so we can go and find it.

Do you want people cheating and getting the full information, or do you want them to go out and find it for themselves? The latter, which would reduce cheating massively, needs some help. Just telling people arsenic or meta-alloys (as an example) can be found on planets is far from helpful.

We badly need Galnet to become a wiki we can turn to, to get enough information to get started. This is doubly-important given that engineers want all manner of rare elements and commodities that we've never seen in the game before, and wouldn't have the first idea where to begin looking for them.

Please fix this!
 
http://inara.cz/galaxy-components

There you go.

I sense frontier realise we are in the 21st century and where there is demand, the Internet will supply.
They seem happy leaving the community to come up with solutions for trading info, ship configuration, stellar cartography, and everything else that AIDS and enhances the gameplay.

Sure, all this stuff should be in game, but it isn't and a quick Google search gives you access.
If it breaks your immersion, treat the Internet as an on board information source.
 
Sure, all this stuff should be in game.

You're very right. It should all be in Galnet. It ruins the immersion for me, having to come out of the game to find basic information. What's more it's completely ruled out a VR headset as an option unless/until they fix this.
 
Problem there is, intellectual property. The community has designed these really well crafted, suited to purpose tools. Does Frontier copy/rip them off? Reverse engineer them? Buy them out? Try to design something new avoiding any similarity to what the community has created?

I think we have gone down a road we cannot turn back from.
 
Another example, if somebody needs meta-alloys, I cannot point to a single thing in the game that would tell players that they can be found at barnacle sites, what barnacles are, or where they can be found. There's no list of "Barnacles have already been found on these planets, or this type of world". We could then, another update the game needs, be able to use our advanced discovery scanners, or a new planetary scanner, to search from orbit for the approximate location of the element or item we're looking for, so we can go and find it.


Please fix this!

You mean not counting the huge number of FD created Galnet Aritcles about the finding or the barnacles near Maia, the controversy sorrounding them, the player group destroying player explorers to "defend" the barnacles, the barnacle CG to gather meta alloys at Obsidian Orbital.. those infos provided in the game over the last months. Yes you are completely right, nothing aside from all that ever hinted where to look for them.
 
A lot of stuff (materials and commodities) can be found with a search on eddb.io but give it a bit of time as it is a great tool run by some truly gifted individuals who don't work for Frontier and the patch is new, so not all materials are on there yet, but some are......

Also as suggested above, inara.cz is my goto tool for almost everything of this type and more, it is a work of genius.
 
Last edited:
Pro tip: for the rarer materials and commodities required by blueprints, don't look within range of the Engineer asking for them. I've played a fair bit, and I've come to the conclusion that they tend to spawn at least 70Ly away; it's anecdotal, but all the stuff I found at mission boards near a given Engineer was actually useful for other Engineers.

I suspect this is a job for somebody with a lot more free time than I, but as a tactic it seems to be working.
 
http://inara.cz/galaxy-components

There you go.

I sense frontier realise we are in the 21st century and where there is demand, the Internet will supply.
They seem happy leaving the community to come up with solutions for trading info, ship configuration, stellar cartography, and everything else that AIDS and enhances the gameplay.

Sure, all this stuff should be in game, but it isn't and a quick Google search gives you access.
If it breaks your immersion, treat the Internet as an on board information source.
That is literally a copy and paste job from the in game info. Granted it's all lined up and organized, but it's not additional information.
 
Arsenic has to be prospected with an SRV as far as I can tell, I just went out to get some myself but only managed yttrium (which i was also looking for) their are some guides kicking around for what to find where, you need metal rich planets then search around craters I think, I'm no expert :p
 
Arsenic is found at certain types of moons, if you dont wanna explore yourself there is plenty survey data linked on this forum. There are even google spreadsheets.

The rest is told by the tooltip when you hover over mats.
 
http://inara.cz/galaxy-components

There you go.

I sense frontier realise we are in the 21st century and where there is demand, the Internet will supply.
They seem happy leaving the community to come up with solutions for trading info, ship configuration, stellar cartography, and everything else that AIDS and enhances the gameplay.

Sure, all this stuff should be in game, but it isn't and a quick Google search gives you access.
If it breaks your immersion, treat the Internet as an on board information source.

Rep for Space AIDS
 
EDDB will soon have complete (as much as possible) body mapping including mining location finder and planetary material finder. Only a couple of weeks...
 
Back
Top Bottom