My thoughts of the ratings/rankings of Asian Animals (as a NA resident):
Indian Subcontinent:
I feel like this region use its own separate post. I'm glad there is some consensus that India needs an animal pack soon. There are many deeply underrated animals from India. The
honey badger and
sloth bear have decent support, which is good to see. Both would make good additions to the game. India desperately needs a monkey, and while the votes are split mostly between two good favorites (I actually think we should aim for both), the
lion tailed macaque and
grey langur still seem deeply underrated. India could also use an antelope or two, and while I think the
nilgai and
blackbuck as favorites seems appropriate, they are still lacking in general for votes. The
fishing cat is the community's 4th favorite cat right now, which feels appropriate. While there are other more pressing deer needs right now, India could probably use one, too. The
chital and
sambar deer are brought up sometimes as good options. One would be nice to see.
Guar are kind of cool, but given their niche seems sort of met by the water buffalo, their lower popularity makes sense. India also has some cool and underrated options for habitat birds, including the
bar-headed goose, painted stork, and demoiselle crane.
Most Underrated: Indian Monkeys and Antelope (we really need these, too, but they seem to have a bit more support)
Himalayas: I'm glad the iconic
markhor and
Pallas's cat are decently appreciated. The
monal also has some votes, and the
yellow throated marten (also in East Asia) is catching up, which seems good. I think the
tahr is a bit underappreciated, but the favorite species seem more important to me as well.
Most Underrated Tahr
Southeast Asia: While the region seems nicely filled out right now, it is still lacking in monkeys. The
red shanked douc is my favorite for all of its beautiful colors, and of course I think it's underrated. It does have a longer history in captivity, but now it's only kept in its native range. The
East Javan langur is another cute and underrated choice with an adorable golden morph. The
lowland anoa is a decently appreciated option that could pair nicely with babirusas. The
giant Asian pond turtle and
cloud rat are underrated, too. If they aren't adding domestics, the
red junglefowl is deeply underrated and would give us a chicken. Though their niche is covered by binturongs,
palm civets are an underrated variety pick for a small carnivore. I also like
tarsiers, but I don't think they're as important for a zoo game.
Most Underrated: Red Shanked Douc and Giant Asian Pond Turtle
East Asia: I'm glad the
takin is appropriately appreciated. While I understand the desire for more internationally-kept monkeys, I also think the
golden snub nosed monkey is also underrated and very important for representing East Asian zoos. I like the
Chinese alligator's cute face, and I think this endangered buddy is also somewhat underrated. East Asia is home to some popular choices for ornamental birds, including the
golden pheasant and
Mandarin duck. There are some other pheasants that would be nice, including the
silver and Lady Amherst's. All of the birds are underrated. I might call the
Pere David's deer overrated due to niche overlap with the red deer, but its interesting conservation story makes it seem fine where it is. However, I think the small fanged deer of Asia are much more unique and very deeply underrated. The
Reeves's muntjac is my top missing ungulate, which can be paired with red pandas. It is endangered and a common zoo animal. Other options include the
tufted deer, water deer, and Siberian musk deer. This seems to be the biggest ungulate gap for me.
Most underrated: Reeves's Muntjac (wins most underrated overall for me)
Central Asia: There isn't really anything I need from this region. The
saiga is the only animal I sort of want, but I would not call it underrated.
North Asia: The
wolverine and
musk ox have appropriate support. I don't think I need anything else from here.
Middle East: The wide support for the
Hamadryas baboon makes sense. The
honey badger and
spurred tortoise are also appropriately popular. After that, I would say an ungulate is all that's needed to finish the region off. The
Arabian oryx, Nubian ibex, and onager, would all do this well. Personally, I would probably go with the iconic oryx, but they all have their merits. The Nubian Ibex is the main ibex kept in my country, and horses seem to do well with the broader playerbase.
Most Underrated: Ungulate Variety Pick(s) (at least one would be nice, but none are
necessary)
Small Exhibit Animals: While Asia mostly has a decent amount of habitat animals, it is very lacking in exhibit animals. The coolest and probably most underrated is the
Philippine Sailfin Dragon. The
cobra is appropriately appreciated for its iconicism, though I have some doubts about how good it will actually look in an exhibit. One will need to have its hood up at least sometimes. For some colorful snakes, the
white lipped island pit viper comes in an unusual blue, and the
red bamboo rat snake is bright red. The
Chinese crocodile lizard also underrated. The blue
tokay gecko and beautiful
orchid mantis have some appreciation, which is good to see. I would also say the
Emerald Swallowtail is deeply underrated. This butterfly would complement the colors of our existing ones by adding some black and green.
Most Underrated: Sailfin Dragon Lizard and Emerald Swallowtail Butterfly
Flying Birds: The
Bali mynah, Steller's sea eagle, and hornbills are brought up most frequently, which seems appropriate. Beyond them, Asia would also benefit from the
golden eagle, raven, peregrine falcon, and Eurasian eagle owl. I think the
rose ringed parakeet is the most underappreciated flying bird. It can be found in India as well as Africa and has a lovely blue morph.
Most Underrated: Rose Ringed Parakeet