News Peek of the week: Cluster Compound

Herik

Herik
R21352 said:
Hi, Bret C,

Can I ask if this screenshot is same as SC arena? The reason i ask is because it looks rather similar, am I allowed to compare ED with SC?:rolleyes:

Although ED is a lot better IMO.:mad:

R
Click to expand...

If your suggesting 'who copied who', and (I haven't seen the station in SC your referring to); It' more likely SC is copying E:D, given E:D's development began before SC's.
 

Drucifer

D
Having read back over the thread, basically everyones sentiment has been: "This should be in the main game, I am otherwise indifferent to this announcement."

ED is in this weird kind of uncanny valley at present; so close to being simply brilliant, but a hundred little niggles plunge it into being ultimately un-engaging.

Some small tweaks and additions would make it the perfect space sim.
 

Ben Ryder

Ben Ryder
Looking good. Hope CQC can be integrated in to the main game. Perhaps as Arena's in Capital systems and permit locked locations?
 

Arindor

Arindor
So, when you say "map", are you inferring that this area is closed off from the main galaxy map? If so, what is the reason behind this kind of segregation? Also, will multiple commander slots be implemented so that one's current save isn't tarnished if one partook CQC and completely sucked at it? ;) :)

It's amazing that the asteroid field in this map looks more amazing (IMO) than the actual asteroid/ring systems currently implemented. Either that or I happen to come across all the worse looking ones. ;)
 
Last edited:

Brett C

Frontier
R21352 said:
Hi, Bret C,

Can I ask if this screenshot is same as SC arena? The reason i ask is because it looks rather similar, am I allowed to compare ED with SC?:rolleyes:

Although ED is a lot better IMO.:mad:

R
Click to expand...

What comes from Elite: Dangerous, is Elite: Dangerous; and whatever comes from Star Citizen, is Star Citizen. :)
 

kilvenny

kilvenny
Drucifer said:
Having read back over the thread, basically everyones sentiment has been: "This should be in the main game, I am otherwise indifferent to this announcement."

ED is in this weird kind of uncanny valley at present; so close to being simply brilliant, but a hundred little niggles plunge it into being ultimately un-engaging.

Some small tweaks and additions would make it the perfect space sim.
Click to expand...

I think its fine where it is - all sorts of logistical challenges exist if you are exploring. In deep space there are no stations or outposts so I don't see what mechanic you could add to make a believable transition to the CQC.
 

etien

etien
like a lot of peeps i do think that those assets ( space elevator, hidden asteroid base, etc ) should be incorporated in the main game. perso i dont care about cqc. etienne
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom