So...IP/Copyright infringement from X Rebirth?

Still prior art:

Stonehenge-from-the-air-008.jpg

Pfft, they haven't even finished putting it together yet :p
 
There are centuries of urban design studies focused on the circle, which design students will be familiar with.

Ebenezer Howard's plan for a garden city from 1902:

F4.jpg


Even fabled Atlantis in the writings of Plato was constructed in a series of concentric circles divided by walls and waterways.

heart-of-atlantis.jpg


Its as public domain as ideas come.

That said, this sort of large scale planning requires a command economy (communism/corporatism/hive minds) of sorts, which I hope FD's procedural planet surface developers bear in mind. A technologically advanced libertarian planet surface would be very different.
 
Last edited:
Circle cities in advanced societies arn't new.

This is a typical city on Vulcan, portrayed in the star trek animated series. 1974

As to looking like coruscant, what doesn't these days?

The entire planet is a city, a mile deep. there is no 'land'. trillions live there. http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Coruscant

vulcan-yesteryear.jpg
 
Last edited:
It is not close enough to infringe copyright.

Game development normally gets inspiration of other games. If was not allowed in the past then there would have been a lot less games in the past, although perhaps some more originality.
 
Those who feel the circles are ripped off from other circles, obviously belong in the Federation, boxed in with their more original squares. :cool:

( Any Imperials affected by this comment, is automatically not included of course.)
 
Those who feel the circles are ripped off from other circles, obviously belong in the Federation, boxed in with their more original squares. :cool:

I would not be surprised if some people here believe that David Braben invented the circle
 
Then who Contact (1997 movie) ripped off?

Isaac Asimov, with his descriptions of the planet 'Trantor', seat of the Galactic Empire of the Foundation series, as well as Earth described in the Robots series.

I'm sure there are older ideas though.

The first image I can think of showing circular planet wide cities is an illustration for one if Isaac Asimov's Foundation series by noted sci-fi artist Michael Whelan in the early 80s.

For real world circular cities, recent ones include New Dehli, Brasilia, Canberra; old ones go all the way back to the earliest settlements such as Skara Brae (the one in Scotland, not the one in Ultima/Britania)
 
Lol, okay - this thread appears to have drifted off into hyperbole-land. I get it, circle cities are most likely public domain.

Though, I was referring to X Rebirth and how it looks like they just changed the color saturation from red to blue, and toned down the resolution because, you know, they're Egosoft.
 
Back
Top Bottom