What Eve does fatally wrong...
Thank you for your opinion on Eve.
Since I absorbed any information about that game the last 14 days (I even found a PERFECT podcast dealing with all issues a noob needs to know -
http://www.virginworlds.com/podcast.php?show=17&ep=3)
I do know that this game has some very strong disadvantages.
The Elite 4 dev.team should notice that very carefully!
For example:
1. Every pro states, that it is 100% impossible to play solo and on your own.
You won't get far. No independence - you HAVE to hang out with a corp. Which means, that you have to work as a slave for some guy having more skillpoints.
I am not a hierarchy type of player - in fact, I am not in real life. That is not an option - so this game IS nothing for solo-players in a massive online game.
2. Exploring (not in the Eve - way here where exploring is something like finding a hidden pirates-nest and exploit it) is no option. As soon as you leave the max. sec. space you will be shot sooner or later. Sooner, as far as I know since the goonswarm is applying the Jihad-tactics into this game - even in max.sec sectors. This is the most disappointing issue for me: no endless space, unlimited possibilities.
3. The universe is maybe big - but it is massively overcrowded: You won't find a single moon out there where you could harvest minerals secure - be sure, you will be tracked down in no time. That means, that you WILL NEVER EVER be able to start your own, secure and profitable business hidden in space - you will have to join a nerdy corp AND an alliance.
4. Due to the malprogramming the whole game suffers a massive deflation - now comes the point I DO KNOW something about.
Since first quarter 2008 the prices for most of the goods - no matter if it is raw materials, consumer goods or even ships are down about 80%.
Why? Because this game ISN'T a real market regulated by market powers: Any gamer want to make money - fast, into the billions. Overproduction, no demand. Profit rates are down to 10% for the professional producers. The 40.000 real gamers have now (most of them) highly skilled chars which are able to produce anything without any effort. But who should buy it?
5. This game pushes you into fights - no chance to live a free traders life the save and interesting way by exploring new systems.
6. Is a game worth playing, where it takes you at least 2 years to gain a skill to drive large ships? By the way: is that REALLY realistic?
I mean: you have 20 billion credits but you have to drive your ship on your own and need to have all patents for flying? Come on...an Arab Sheik does not need an A+ license to fly his own Airbus 380 - he has his pilot - perhaps an autopilot. So: you want a titan? play Eve for 4 years every day...or just gain a Ph.D. on physics in EXACTLY the same time - no kidding...
7. As far as I can see, the so often praised "economic system" isn't as good and complex as they say. You don't have nearly no margins between the systems because all the pro's are swarming around at every system without pause. What else can you expect when alliances control the whole universe?
Where are the unknown lands?
The big trade deals?
8. The only chance of making money in the beginning is mining. Mining - and get ripped. Perhaps a little salvaging... run missions...but really: For a player being really interested in industry development, building factories (forget about that due to deflation and the 3 years of skillpoints to work profitable. You don't have the Blueprint? You want to invent? Forget it...) there is No way to do so. You will never ever find a hidden place to fill a space in the supply chain.
Missions, mining. But again: Only in corps - remember...
9. Science and invention: forget about it: you only can "invent" known objects. If you are VERY lucky (you have a success rate). And remember the deflation problem?
Go into the blogs and read about those problems. So what is left then? Mining. Killing. Or slave yourself to a corp.
So: Where is the fun?
For players from the early days in 2003-2004 it IS fun - with 40 mio. skillpoints.
Sorry, guys...Eve WILL be offline soon. They know it, we know it.
I am SICK of hearing millions and millions of issues about corps, corps, alliances, and corps. This is all the pro's are talking about.
Hello? Find a corp I fit in?
Find a corp that I can adopt to?
This is the thing massive online games are suffering from: It is much easier to become an self-made billionaire with unlimited power in real life than in some crappy online game like Eve. And THAT is the truth as far as I can interpret the online information.
PS: I will still move into Eve sooner or later. I am prepared, I have the calculations, the scripts and the view. But will it be fun? At least I will learn how Elite 4 should not be.