This is one REALLY REALLY HOT icy planet! 3000 degrees F !!!!!

It's like the ice....is like.....on fire almost. Like an icy version of the Hindenburg. It's a wonder the planet hasn't already exploded already! I mean we're talking like 3000 degrees Fahrenheit (1923 K) levels of icy heat here! You can't even roast marsh mellows on them ice cubes without instantly vaporizing them! :D

t48k4yG.png
 
Errm... yeah. That is some weird and exceedingly inhospitable planet there. 78,000 atmospheres, however a temperature of 1923k (I'll ignore the defunct even in the 21st Century reference to Fahrenheit) is pretty damn warm for ice and while odd things happen at high pressure to water, I have no idea if that pressure is high enough to compress the water gas to a solid. Could be right though.
 
Errm... yeah. That is some weird and exceedingly inhospitable planet there. 78,000 atmospheres, however a temperature of 1923k (I'll ignore the defunct even in the 21st Century reference to Fahrenheit) is pretty damn warm for ice and while odd things happen at high pressure to water, I have no idea if that pressure is high enough to compress the water gas to a solid. Could be right though.

Yea, I didn't even notice the 78k atmospheres!

That's pretty insane. I wonder if it's a record of some sort for "icy" type planets.
 
Some interesting science-y stuff!!

http://arstechnica.com/science/2007/03/turing-water-into-very-hot-ice-very-very-quickly/

By passing the 20 million amperes of current through a small aluminum chamber, a magnetic field is created that isentropically compresses aluminum plates that sandwich a thin (25 micron) layer of water to pressures ranging from 50,000 to 120,000 atmospheres. For reference, what you experience at sea level is one atmosphere of pressure. What the researchers found was at these incredibly high pressures, water was squeezed into ice—ice VII to be exact, which was subsequently hotter than the boiling point of water at atmospheric pressure. As described by Sandia researcher Daniel Dolan, "Apparently it's virtually impossible to keep water from freezing at pressures beyond 70,000 atmospheres." Maybe that's a bit of an understatement, but it is very important to know for future operation of the Z machine and similar devices. The physical properties of ice—any ice phase—are vastly different from their liquid counter part.
 
See my thread on "Hot Ice Planets" here:
https://forums.frontier.co.uk/showthread.php?t=117390

Basically under enough pressure, you can maintain Ice in special phases even at high temperature. I don't think 78,000 atmospheres is quite enough to maintain Ice VII at 1923K though (it'd melt at around 550K)!

-- Pete.

See my source above. Evidently it's impossible for hydrogen dioxide (water) to have any other form BUT ice above 70k atmosphere's of pressure.
 
I wonder whether there's any plausible reason to have 78k atmospheres of pressure on a world of 0.1 earth masses.
 
Must be a bug, actually.

Infocard says:
- Atmosphere - 100% water
- Surface pressure - 78 154 atmospheres
- Surface temperature - 1 923K

Problem 1: The "atmosphere" is made of water under immense pressure. At that pressure the water is solid as quoted already (edit: actually not; might be a liquid, though). So it isn't an atmosphere anymore.
Problem 2: It may not even be possible to have such pressure on a small planet.
 
Last edited:
See my source above. Evidently it's impossible for hydrogen dioxide (water) to have any other form BUT ice above 70k atmosphere's of pressure.
Yes - that post contains a very impossible to read phase diagram of water to explain it.

In my post I have a much clearer phase diagram of water:
512px-Phase_diagram_of_water.svg.png

So, you could read an article that even says, "maybe that's a bit of an understatement" immediately after the statement you quoted, or you could do the maths and look up the results on a phase diagram yourself. I did the latter.

(bar is a unit of an "atmosphere" if you want to use the right hand units, or Pascal is the SI unit if you want to use the left hand units. 78,000 atmospheres are almost 8 GPa)

To maintain Ice at very high temperatures you need hundreds of thousands of atmospheres at the very least. The diagram tops out at around 150,000 atmospheres to maintain Ice VII at 650K.

-- Pete.
 
Last edited:
The hell is a "Fahrenheit"?
A slightly more modern version of the Reaumur scale

Problem 1: The "atmosphere" is made of water under immense pressure. At that pressure the water is solid as quoted already (edit: actually not; might be a liquid, though). So it isn't an atmosphere anymore.
Pressure is only at the surface. The further up towards space you go the less pressure, so there is the possibility of a water atmosphere. Effectively this is saying you have a planet with a tiny solid (ice) core and a LOT of atmosphere. However given the radius and especially the mass of the planet that doesn't grok, either.
At that kind of distance from the sun (0.33AU) the atmosphere would likely not have stayed on with such low gravity in any case.

But seriously: It looks like they did a 'sanity check' for some of their values (ice at those pressures is perfectly possible at those temperatures), but not for everything. Which, from a game designer point of view, I can understand. You can spend unlimited amount of time fiddling with these details, but they add very little to the game experience - so you focus on other stuff first.
 
Last edited:
Thanks to the water pressure expertise here... I guess the most serious thing wrong with this planet is the description's reference to "low temperature". Although even that is subjective as it is in fact "low temperature" compared to the coronasphere of a star.
 
My major issues with the planet is the proximity to the star (about .33AU) with the lack of volcanism. Effectively this planet should have no magnetic field roughly indicated by the lack of volcanism which in itself is usually an indicator of an inactive core (that which usually generates a magnetic field). At that distance the star should be stripping away the atmosphere with its solar winds and effectively reducing the planet to a barren rock much like mercury. Add to this the fact that the planet is very small (which shouldn't be able to hang on to an atmosphere) and that it is tidally locked and well it appears to be a PG glitch.
 
Should still be able to float on an air balloon comfortably in a high altitude region in the twilight zone of the planet and experience a comfortable temperature and pressure. With your own supply of oxygen ofcource.

However knowing our universe it wouldn't surprise me if this planet had sulphuric acid in its upper atmosphere.
 
Back
Top Bottom