This is just personal opinion, but I think there's no such thing as having too much scoop. IMHO, it's always money well-spent, to fit the largest scoop that the ship can take. If the scoop is fast enough, you can point the ship in a straight path at full throttle, and look at the map while you're scooping. The faster the scoop is, the higher you can set your course relative to the star's surface. By not diving as deep, you can start your jump sequence sooner with less heat. So for me, it's just a "travel efficiency" thing. I'd rather not have to stop and scoop when I could just fly straight through, and start a jump right away if there's nothing I want to scan.
But not everyone travels that way.![]()
I would argue that you are not actually realizing the benefit that you think you are because of the minimum amount of time from system entry to system exit. If you have 2 scoops that can fill your tank in that amount of time, then the larger, more expensive one isn't actually speeding up your journey. It might certainly feel like it does, but it isn't actually saving you any time. Additionally, the distance and heat differences are, in my opinion, negligible. That benefit you certainly do get, and I don't argue that, but consider that the 8D scoop runs at almost exactly 1T/s, costs about the same as a 4A, and uses less power than the 7B/7A/8B/8A. That power difference, for some builds, can have a large impact. It also reduces the rebuy, should disaster strike. That scoop will refill a single T-10 maximum jump's worth of fuel within that minimum time (almost 2 jump's worth, actually), and since you can't leave any earlier than that (regardless of what scoop you are using), I have trouble justifying the extra cost for no real, actual gain.
Again, if one has the credits to burn, and wants to spend almost 3 times the cost of the ship itself on a scoop, who am I to try to stop them? My goal here is not so much to change anyone's mind who is a tenured Explorer, but rather to show newer Commanders that they do not (and in my opinion, should not), in fact, just blindly go for the largest A scoop they can afford. They should use something like Coriolis, and build their ship to suit their intended purpose within their budget, and they can do that without feeling like they are somehow less because they didn't spend 90M credits on a 7A, or 290M on an 8A for ships that can carry them.
Riôt