These are all good points. And your point about revaluating what one actual wants from exploration is the crux of the matter for people who have become bored of it or find it uninspiring. At one point I did set my own goals of retracing some of the more famous expeditionary routes, and I enjoyed that for what it was, but I can't help feeling I still missed out as those events were community events, and doing them alone was interesting but not that inspiring tbh. My own fault for coming to this party late. I even went along on some of the edsm expeditions last year, and enjoyed them for what they were (despite only ever bumping into half a dozen different people along the way).Last year I got my name in the Codex for 5 different biologicals as the first discoverer of them in their respective regions.
I also found a landable ice planet that had a temperature of over 30°C during the day.
I've found mountains to hike up and canyons to fly.
It's true that you're not going to find a long lost alien civilisation out there. To be honest, this is a complaint that can't ever be fixed. If frontier adds hidden things to find like this, they get found and then people complain there's nothing left. If the procedurally generated lots of "special" things to find, people would complain that there's nothing actually interesting to find.
If you want to be an explorer now, you've gotta have an appreciation for stellar forge quirks and unique system configurations or planet formations.
If that doesn't work for you, I don't think there's much frontier could ever do to fix that problem.
That said, you could always be the first one to discover something like a new HGG or even a GGG.
I guess I just never really understand these complaints. Yes, looking on the galaxy map for nebulas is not going to give you any free first discovered tags. Because, like you, everyone else before you had that idea. I don't really know what you're expecting.
Frontier just 2 years ago added so many new landable planets and revitalised all the old ones. There are whole new landscapes out there to discover now, new mountains, skies and horizons. They could add earthlike worlds tomorrow and people would still say "I've been to one, they're all procedural so none of them mean anything there's nothing actually unique to find"
My approach would be to reevaluate what you actually want from exploration. Personally, I want to travel alone through the black, looking for unique systems (billions of those still exist untouched), unique planets (trillions or more), and unique vistas (even more of those). The joy of flying through a real, persistent galaxy is what keeps exploration alive for me. And that's something the game gives in spades.
And on the aspect of community comin together for things like the DSSA, famous explorers didn't just get famous from a discovery. They get famous from community. Beagle Point is not just famous because a guy called Erimus went there first. It's famous because he catalogued the journey, shared it with the community and then helped organise and uplift the exploration community during its early days.
If you want to leave your mark on the galaxy, you need to be willing to work with and for the community itself.
Basically, the real exploration was the friends we made along the way.
I still hold out hope the multi-thousand mega community events will return to Elite someday, but as I mentioned in my earlier post, as the years go by and elite galaxy as a whole remains unchanged, I can understand why they're probably a thing of the past.