I have X52 pro, but x52 non pro is not differ much. I think it will be better to get x52 than you proposed because it is out-the-box set up designed to be hotas. It will be more ergonomic. Product you proposed are entry level, x52 is placed higher so it could be more accurate, precise and durable. Before X52 i used Fly 5 and hotas x. Playing on x52 is much better. Of course i dont have T-16000M and G13, maybe someone else should can say more.