So I checked out Elite after ditching it for Star Citizen

You can also do this in Space Engineers - steal a ship by jet packing from one to another while in flight, and I honestly don't like it. Jet packs are OP, allowing a player in a jetpack to catch up to a ship in flight, and grinders (think cutting torch) are OP as well, allowing a player to slice into a ship they don't own like Luke slicing into an AT-AT walker with a lightsaber. It makes everyone feel like Iron Man rather than humble pilots of powerful ships. I personally use a mod to nerf this insane jet pack, but most public servers do not.

I have no idea how this works in Star Citizen. I can see using a ship with grapplers to grab onto another ship like pirate ships of old, and then sending a boarding party over. This plays out both in real life and many sci-fi movies very realistically. Heck, it's the opening scene of the most famous sci-fi movie of them all, the original Star Wars. It's more practically with larger, slower ships than two fighters, though I can almost picture Tom Cruise popping the hatch on his F16 in Top Gun and jumping onto the MiG below him and tossing out it's pilot, but that's because I've watched too many Mission Impossible movies, LOL.
What a guy ..
 
Do that while you're in the air and the other plane is in the air. That's what we were talking about. Stealing ships from another ship, in flight, as per Star Citizen.
Oh. We're gonna need Zero-G and Vacc suit skills now. A plasma torch/laser welder might be handy for those pesky iris valves...
 
Do that while you're in the air and the other plane is in the air. That's what we were talking about.
No, it is not. Theft is what we're talking about. Thieves strike at the most opportune moments. A thief doesn't steal your car while you're driving 80 miles per hour down the interstate by somehow jumping on to your hood from the side of the road in a Batman like leap, breaking in through the windshield with his steel reinforced gloves and throwing you out of the car, then crawling in and taking the wheel.

They wait till you park it, walk away and then steal it. Or they wait for you to stop, hold you at gunpoint and take it.

The same applies to aircraft. It happens every single day. Lots of times.

The same applies to ships in this game should it come to that. Thieves wouldn't strike while you're in warp between stars. They'd wait 'till you parked in a station and went to the concourse, then steal it; or buy a ticket on one of your tours, hold you at gunpoint and take it.

Your entire analogy is completely worthless. It makes absolutely zero sense of any kind at all as it has absolutely nothing to do with reality. The fact is: planes are stolen every single day. THAT is what we're talking about.
 
Last edited:
Not a Red Dwarf fan? Where is the Shame! Shame! Shame! gif when I need it?
I'm American, so RD was only occasionally on PBS when I was a kid, and the humor went over my head. In my defense, I did become a Doctor Who (specifically Tom Baker) fan as a kid, so there's that.

ps - the little bit of Red Dwarf that I watched took place in space on a giant ship. That's about all I remember of it, that and a weird android with a A glued to his head..
 
Last edited:
To be fair, there aren't any other space sims out there that allow a player to take off from a planet's surface, enter space, disembark from their ship, float through space to another ship, board it, fight the crew, then take a seat and start flying it around.
No, it is not. Theft is what we're talking about.
Wrong. Here's the original post I was replying to:

To be fair, there aren't any other space sims out there that allow a player to take off from a planet's surface, enter space, disembark from their ship, float through space to another ship, board it, fight the crew, then take a seat and start flying it around.

And a ship of the 34th century is still going to shred you before you even move beyond the airlock.
 
And a ship of the 34th century is still going to shred you before you even move beyond the airlock.
I've built those ships (it's not trivial), and I've seen nothing in Elite ships that look like they would "shred" anything entering an airlock. Though I suppose we could look at the age-old debate of how some things are allowed to penetrate a shield (outgoing weapon fire, SRVs, people) and other things like incoming weapon fire is blocked. The shield to me would be the most realistic "shredder" of unauthorized personnel, but even that must have some sort of "key" to allow the owner and his friends in, and where there's a lock, there's a crook who can crack it.
 
I've built those ships (it's not trivial), and I've seen nothing in Elite ships that look like they would "shred" anything entering an airlock. Though I suppose we could look at the age-old debate of how some things are allowed to penetrate a shield (outgoing weapon fire, SRVs, people) and other things like incoming weapon fire is blocked. The shield to me would be the most realistic "shredder" of unauthorized personnel, but even that must have some sort of "key" to allow the owner and his friends in, and where there's a lock, there's a crook who can crack it.
Not while flying about at several relative (and rapidly changing) Gs there isn't. Star Citizen sounds as if it's a bit cartoony.

What do you mean you've "built those ships"?
 
Not while flying about at several relative (and rapidly changing) Gs there isn't. Star Citizen sounds as if it's a bit cartoony.
Most people aren't flying that way normally. "A line is the straightest distance between two points." If someone sneaks up on you from behind while you're flying from point A to point B while minding your own business, they can easily board you from behind with no Gs at all. Been there, done that (on the receiving end).

What do you mean you've "built those ships"?

You have to start with that post and continue to the next page in the thread to get the entire story. It was actually quite fun, in a terrifying sort of way.
 
I'm American, so RD was only occasionally on PBS when I was a kid, and the humor went over my head. In my defense, I did become a Doctor Who (specifically Tom Baker) fan as a kid, so there's that.

ps - the little bit of Red Dwarf that I watched took place in space on a giant ship. That's about all I remember of it, that and a weird android with a A glued to his head..
Back in the 90's, KETC-9 (PBS) would run a Brit Sci-fi marathon on late Sunday nights. Trying to get all that on tape was fun.
 
Wrong. Here's the original post I was replying to:



And a ship of the 34th century is still going to shred you before you even move beyond the airlock.
I had laser pistols on the floors of my airlocks, and converted maser communicators in the ceiling. Then, there are the firefighting systems...
 
As many people probably know, the current drama in Star Citizen enticed me to check out elite again(2800 hours in Elite, about 1000 in Star citizen), i found mysefl playing it 3 hours a day daily even though I dont think it will last me very long.
Surprised you didn't mention engineering, promises that will never be delivered, and taking a steaming dump on console customers.
 
I'd happily throw more money at ED if it would help. Not sure they have a funding model that will make that viable though, so what will be will be.
I became leery of ED's longevity when FDev decided not to charge something monthly for MMO, whilst at the same time ditching plans to enable offline-only.
 
Back
Top Bottom