Absense of melee weapons in game

The only use I see for melee weapons in Elite would be commando-style quiet stealth takedowns with a combat knife/dagger.

These guys disagree. If you can't fight lasers with swords & clubs then you aren't a "real" warrior. Arrrggggh!

Flash Gordon.jpg
 
Why does it seem like there's a group constantly working to suggest more and more ridiculous things to ruin Elite?
There are so many suggestions made, not to ruin the game but to improve it in the mind of the suggester, or to make it simpler for new players to have G5 everything 2 hours into the game...

The playerbase is fortunate that the majority of these suggestions fail to inspire FD to implement them - but, at least being able to make a suggestion is permitted.

At least, while FD is rebuilding internally, anything more than a minor tweak is unlikely to happen to the game (PP 2.0 excluded, that has probably been a project for quite some time) and it would be curious to have FD implement something that would only please a small minority (PP 2.0 excluded)!
 
Why does it seem like there's a group constantly working to suggest more and more ridiculous things to ruin Elite?
Who looks at Elite, a game with spaceships and laser guns and thinks "what this game needs is swords"?

I used to tell people that they didn't understand what Elite "is" ... I'm not sure I do anymore to be honest, but it sure as heck doesn't need swords.

You know what Elite really needs? a 500cc petrol-powered dirt bike, yeah ... THAT's what Elite needs. That's about as valid as saying a sci-fi game set in the near-distant future needs swords.
I blame the trend for genre mish mash in general. Stuff like... Fortnite? Is it Fortnite? Sorry, I'm not so fluent in what the kids play these days - just steal from every genre and put it in a "funny" fantasy environment - genre continuity not required. "Cyberpunk" today practically exclusively means japanese anime with ninjas and tech weapons. Starfield couldn't resist to push magic into a space themed game. These days, anything goes. WWII weapons in a Fantasy game? Why not. Medieval knights in SciFi? Hell yeah. Just mash it all together.

There you go. Here's today's old man yelling at clouds for you.
 
At least, while FD is rebuilding internally, anything more than a minor tweak is unlikely to happen to the game (PP 2.0 excluded, that has probably been a project for quite some time) and it would be curious to have FD implement something that would only please a small minority (PP 2.0 excluded)!
I'd speculate that the thargoid war related graffiti was actually developed for the upcoming PP2 visual changes. If so, PP2 has been under development for quite awhile.
 
What Elite needs is interesting on foot combat. Being Jango Fett was cool for about an hour, but the NPCs behave like someone beat them over the head with a shovel for about an hour before coming to the CZs, even the High ones. They are incredibly clueless and will just stand their while you gib their friends with a rocket launcher. Some of them seem to understand the premise of the affair, and will shoot at you, but a certain portion of them seem to be there doing a kind of treasure hunt or geo caching adventure.

I suspect I'll finish getting Merc Elite for Inara's rankings and then simply forget about it for quite awhile. It's not as bad as exobiology, though.
 
but the NPCs behave like someone beat them over the head with a shovel for about an hour before coming to the CZs, even the High ones

Try posing, smiling and saying Cheese to an Enforcer in a High CZ - then let me know if your next reaction is "I can see my house from heeeereeee"
 
Try posing, smiling and saying Cheese to an Enforcer in a High CZ -
I only do Highs, the others are a complete waste of time. I read a guide that said the goal was roughly 16M bonds per CZ and they were using G5 gear on a little tech settlement where getting to enemies is much easier. I am using G3 L6 and G3 whatever that SMG is because it's what I have, and my last CZ was 15M on a large tourist one where travel times are longer. I have had lower payouts before I got better at the Jango Fett Gank methods, but the NPCs are just goobers.
 
I guess those Imperial nobs like to prance around with an ornamental blade at their side, and occasionally brandishing them for effect in the senate chamber, but do not imagine them inclined to personally set foot on an actual battlefield. :p
 
I don't see anything wrong with a sharpened piece of metal as a sidearm or last resort weapon. Anything that provides more mechanical advantage and concentrates force into a smaller, harder, area than an unarmed limb has advantages over being completely unarmed. The lack of moving parts, no need for ammunition, and the multifunctionality intrinsic to such tools are also utility that will justify carrying a blade large enough to be called a weapon as long as people have appendages capable of wielding them.

That said, I think there are far more pressing concerns with ED's combat and general gameplay mechanisms than the weapon selection.
 
I don't see anything wrong with a sharpened piece of metal as a sidearm or last resort weapon. Anything that provides more mechanical advantage and concentrates force into a smaller, harder, area than an unarmed limb has advantages over being completely unarmed. The lack of moving parts, no need for ammunition, and the multifunctionality intrinsic to such tools are also utility that will justify carrying a blade large enough to be called a weapon as long as people have appendages capable of wielding them.
Yep. If I was a rl warrior (which I'm not), when the bullets ran out, I'd prefer a sword (assuming I have enough training to not hurt myself) over a knife and a knife over a fist. But ED is a game where my suit somehow stores 12 explosive rockets along with dozens of reloads for various weapons and ammo is literally just lying around in boxes all over the place. It's probably a OSHA issue. Explains why I never see any kids around I guess.
 
one thing you gotta admit: bladed weapons would look totally badass together with the current aesthetic of the Odyssey suits.
Until you try to use them. IMO bladed weapons harm the immersion when the character body model doesn't allow to be cut and stabbed. It's bad enough with explosive weaponry but I can play with that.
 
It's bad enough with explosive weaponry but I can play with that.
Curiously, one of the trailers for EDO, before release, had a NPC in a power building being shot on the stairs, and a spurt of blood was briefly visible - never made it into the expansion proper.
 
Back
Top Bottom