Welcome to Elite Dangerous; where the game is all made by YOU!

Catchphrase used by marketing: Open world/sandbox game. Translated for humans: design department decided that they will give you the bare minimum and you make up everything.
It is Dungeons and Dragons time all over! Why would you draw maps on paper and use figures on hexagon maps, when you can do the same online on a pretty graphic game?
At the time this game was designed, the top computer was 4 Mhz, the memory was 32K, and you would not buy it for gaming...at that time imagination was everything.
Nowadays; people start to ask more, and they should ask more. Not more graphics....that is something that evolve with the prformances of the hardware.
People nowadays expect someone to write some good fiction, expect deep involvement (sorry, if I have to read a book to play this game, and imagine all by myself; I am good with my old Elite running in emulation...I can play it even on my tablet).
Instead, ED did the easiest thing: you are free, make it up on your own. Not to diminish the huge work done, but honestly in 2015, what this game does is bare minimum.
We are at a point where MMO offer involvement with events, new content and such; you can't just release a game and let players do what they want.
ED as is now (and I pray that it will change), is the equivalent of buying a box full of wood, metal, screws, nails and bolts; a hammer, screwdriver and a book with photos of things that you can build.
Some may find it fun, some may not; this is personal.
But let's avoid to say that this game is innovative and is the next great thing after sliced bread. Beside the awesome graphic and the incredible care dedicated to the galaxy (which is purely on the paper...nobody went outside our solar system, so the stars could be upside down or totally wrong in their representation and nobody would really care), the game is barebone at most; I have seen stuff made in Unreal engine and Unity that fundamentally, was offering something similar to what ED offer, minus the cool graphic.
I love this game, but can't really close my eyes and say "yeah, it is cool", because it is not...80% of my interest was nostalgia based; and I believe the majority of us here were also old players that hoped for something new in the Elite universe. The game will evolve; some will not have time and will to wait, the others may just drop the ball after not so exciting updates; we will see.