A BIG Rant

FFE had a scripted story. it was not continual, it just popped up from time to time, but it was there...... and actually it was pretty good!. It was a long time ago since i played (ie I am talking about the 12 months period that I bought it) and without cheating and using google I cant be 100% certain, but I think it involved making peace with the thargoids!. I know it ended up with you being given one of their ships, which after the initial wow had worn off, actually ruined the game for me. I never made elite because of this.

I totally forgot this, thanks for the memory :)
 
On release, every player should have had to Pledge to a power, after that it was up to them if they got involved.
What about doing my own thing? Doing courier runs and warzones to get mcguffins (rather than credits) isn't my thing, that's for sure. There will also be people who want to roleplay a character with no sympathy for any of the galactic powers.
 
I never lack for something to do in ED, and I don't have any difficulty finding other players when I want to find other players. So, I agree with the general points the OP is making in these regards.

Get real, space is B I G, really really big. If FD were to introduce any semblance of realism, once you leave your starter world you would probably never see another real player again - the odds are just against it!

This argument is fundamentally flawed.

Space is really big, but people don't just dash for untouched corners of the galaxy to live out their lives as hermits. Civilization is something most people are unwilling, or unable, to do without, and civilization depends on concentrations of people. It makes perfect sense that this concentration surrounds the world that spawned humans.

I encounter real players all the time out side of the starter and these players weren't placed there for my enjoyment. We simply depend on the same civilization, so happen to be within inhabited space fairly frequently.

Nothing implausible about this.

You should not have got an option whether to participate or not. On release, every player should have had to Pledge to a power, after that it was up to them if they got involved. But by pledging, they are part of the universe and get the benefits and the danger involved. You basically have the majority of populated space involved in a war of attrition yet (guessing here, but an educated guess nevertheless) the majority of players just don't care! If PD wanted PowerPlay to work, to become part of the Universe, then it should be an option and should be restricted to Open (i.e the rewards only come to those who complete the tasks in Open).

This is absurd and contradictory. How do you make pledging mandatory, then make it an option restricted to Open?

I don't feel any allegiance should be mandatory, nor would a mandatory allegiance for people to participate in power play any more than they are forced to participate now.

The PP factions do not control all inhabited space. Even if they did, they would not have absolute control over who was able to attain a spacecraft and Pilot's Federation membership.

Participation, beyond the inevitable, incidental, indirect kind that unpledged CMDRs see now, needs to remain optional.
 
What a strange post. I especially like the part where OP doesn't care or know enough about Powerplay to even know how it works or what it is and why people dislike it, and yet still wants everyone to be forced to play it.
 
You forgot to mention the complaints about 'grinding'. This is a concept that is alien to me, as I relax and enjoy my slow movement through the game in my Cobra, quietly scoffing at all those players from 'a certain age demographic' who are obsessively boring themselves to tears with the work of "Must have uber Conda rignt now so I can prove myself in PvP to mitigate my shortcomings in RL!"
;)
 
You forgot to mention the complaints about 'grinding'. This is a concept that is alien to me, as I relax and enjoy my slow movement through the game in my Cobra, quietly scoffing at all those players from 'a certain age demographic' who are obsessively boring themselves to tears with the work of "Must have uber Conda rignt now so I can prove myself in PvP to mitigate my shortcomings in RL!"
;)

Is that the Condor from the Mysteries Cities of Gold?
 
To OP, while I agree that at times there can be two much senseless ranting on these threads, they usually do point out some glaring issues, though sometimes it is completely "me me me" focused and those are meaningless, many times the rants also have good suggestions that would improve the game, which is fairly empty right now, its got an amazing foundation, but nothing else, and I look forward to that amazing house that will one day sit on top, but in the meantime I don't think it is bad to have people give their complaints and suggestions, I agree that they shouldn't always be so selfish, but they do serve a purpose.
 
You forgot to mention the complaints about 'grinding'. This is a concept that is alien to me, as I relax and enjoy my slow movement through the game in my Cobra, quietly scoffing at all those players from 'a certain age demographic' who are obsessively boring themselves to tears with the work of "Must have uber Conda rignt now so I can prove myself in PvP to mitigate my shortcomings in RL!"
;)

You forgot that there are two separate points in your statement. No-lifeing happens in every game because demographics, but it is not the same as complaints about the game's lackings. Nice conflation though.
 
It is time I vent my spleen, yes this is going to be a rant, there are some things that just makes me shake my head in disbelief:

THE ROADMAP
It seems that every second thread someone will complain that FD are keeping the vaulted and mythical 'Roadmap' secret and it just isn't fair. Well what do you expect! I haven't seen too many games that the developers release a complete list of their intent with dates of intended implementation. Can you imagine just what would happen if FD did release such a document:

  • One third of the players would scream that the feature THEY wanted isn't included and they will personally hold everyone at FD responsible until all other projects are cancelled and their feature gets maximum effort to be developed immediately. They cry, they rant, they bleat that if their brilliant ideas aren't listened to, the game will be dead before Christmas
  • One third will kind of agree with what is on the Roadmap, but will demand 'minor amendments or adjustments' to every item on the Roadmap just because they 'think' they know more than the Devs and could do the programming in a few minutes (wonders why they aren't working in the industry then huh). They cry, they rant, they bleat that if their brilliant improvements aren't implemented, the game will be dead before Christmas
  • The remaining third will like what is listed in the Roadmap but totally disregard reality and demand that all features are finished and the patch released by Friday at the latest. They cry, they rant, they bleat that if the patch isn't released by Friday, the game will be dead before Christmas.

Come on guys, the staff of FD do know what they are doing, and are trying to please a very diverse group of players over a varied set of operating systems. We don't know what their plans are, maybe that is all they are are plans. Let them do their job without the continuous demands for things we may think are urgent but in the overall scheme of things could still be years away.

THE UNIVERSE
Another continuous whine I hear in these forums is: I never see another Commander, this is suppose to be a MMO, where is the PVP, there is no one to 'interact' (read shoot and annoy) with.

So lets look at the facts: The games boasts 400 BILLION (that is 400,000,000,000) Systems. Now lets assume that each system, on average has 4 planets/moons/things to fly into - that is 16,000,000,000,000 objects in the Universe. And you want all players to be jammed into a corner so you can see them? Get real, space is B I G, really really big. If FD were to introduce any semblance of realism, once you leave your starter world you would probably never see another real player again - the odds are just against it!

FD has tried to help, for those that crave human contact there are Community Quests, PowerPlay, even the creation of RES points but don't expect every player to want to participate in any of those, it isn't compulsory is it. Now FD are bringing in CQC just so those that have whined the most can engage in some pretty meaningless pew pew for bragging rights. Meanwhile the rest of us will be out exploring the galaxy.

POWER PLAY
Admission up front, I have not pledged to a power, never thought of pledging to a power, don't even read the posts about Power Play. Why, it is simple, I don't have to. And that is where I think FD made a strategic error. They let PowerPlay exist on both Solo and Open (not sure about groups but would assume there too) and then surprised when a lot of players do the dangerous stuff in Solo where they are safe.

In my own opinion, I believe PP should be all encompassing. You should not have got an option whether to participate or not. On release, every player should have had to Pledge to a power, after that it was up to them if they got involved. But by pledging, they are part of the universe and get the benefits and the danger involved. You basically have the majority of populated space involved in a war of attrition yet (guessing here, but an educated guess nevertheless) the majority of players just don't care! If PD wanted PowerPlay to work, to become part of the Universe, then it should be an option and should be restricted to Open (i.e the rewards only come to those who complete the tasks in Open).

THIS SUCKS THERE IS NOTHING TO DO
God if I hear this whine one more time I am going to, hell I don't know, shake my head in disbelief. It seems there are a lot of players who are bored with the game, and I would guess that the majority of those come from a certain demographic age wise. They are use to having structured games, with everything laid out for them in a nice linear line. They need instant gratification, if they don't they don't know if they are progressing or not. They need goals, they need an End Boss to beat. What piffle, Elite was never about that, it was always about doing your own thing. If you can't think up something to do, then maybe the fault isn't with the game but with your lack of imagination. I suspect a lot won't do some of the less action things like exploration and mining because it doesn't rake in the credits and there is no bravado or bragging attributed. Be brave, be daring, try doing something that might sound boring, you might just find it is a lot more enjoyable than you thought.

Yes, FD could do some simple things that would offer more gameplay, we have all been told that such things are coming but again, people want them NOW, right NOW or they will tell mummy.

RANT OVER
I know I am going to get roasted over these comments, how dare I suggest people should have patience, to trust FD to deliver what they promised. Remember this game has been in gestation for nearly 30 years, it has been the vision of one guy since the original Elite, I think he knows what he is doing.

You really do talk a lot of rubbish.
 
:))
So the OP basically says that we should be fine with paying for the surprise..............right.

I have a flashback now.... yeah my grandma used to warn me about this.... she said : "Honey, don't marry the first......." ohh, not that one.
this one: "Be smart, never buy rabbit in the bag."
...
You know she was somewhat right... :)
 
You forgot to mention the complaints about 'grinding'. This is a concept that is alien to me, as I relax and enjoy my slow movement through the game in my Cobra, quietly scoffing at all those players from 'a certain age demographic' who are obsessively boring themselves to tears with the work of "Must have uber Conda rignt now so I can prove myself in PvP to mitigate my shortcomings in RL!"
;)

What certain age demographic would that be?

Please provide this data. I'll add it to my thesis, "A Study of Overly Judgmental Role-players (or Immerse This, Pal)".
 
It is time I vent my spleen, yes this is going to be a rant, there are some things that just makes me shake my head in disbelief:

THE ROADMAP
It seems that every second thread someone will complain that FD are keeping the vaulted and mythical 'Roadmap' secret and it just isn't fair. Well what do you expect! I haven't seen too many games that the developers release a complete list of their intent with dates of intended implementation. Can you imagine just what would happen if FD did release such a document:

The userbase would get excited and little else. No Man's Sky is in the bag, so they are not going to 'borrow' ideas, and Star Citizen is Vaporware and years away from any kind of release.

Large community based passtimes, like this one (Elite) are known to publish roadmaps, CCP are really good at this, example DUST514's Roadmap and the EvE Online Dev Blogs. CCP do it, because they have a niche market (like Elite), a dedicated mature community (like Elite) and they know that keeping the comms channels open engages and enthuses their community.

Another continuous whine I hear in these forums is: I never see another Commander, this is suppose to be a MMO, where is the PVP, there is no one to 'interact' (read shoot and annoy) with.

CQC addresses this need - so the Dev team are clearly listening - and after a lot of thought, I think CQC will be a cracking idea - because it means those who want to 'pew-pew' with other players can do so easier.

So lets look at the facts: The games boasts 400 BILLION (that is 400,000,000,000) Systems. Now lets assume that each system, on average has 4 planets/moons/things to fly into - that is 16,000,000,000,000 objects in the Universe. And you want all players to be jammed into a corner so you can see them? Get real, space is B I G, really really big. If FD were to introduce any semblance of realism, once you leave your starter world you would probably never see another real player again - the odds are just against it!

The game is Sci-Fi, not 21st century Science fact, if it were, we would not leave the solar system for 10 actual years. It is a game, and it is a fictional universe based in science fact. Therefore there is no reason at all why player interactions could not be more frequent. I hate to keep using EvE Online as a reference, but the simple fact is, CCP had this nailed very early in their games dev cycle. Player interactions can be more frequent in more populated areas, by ensuring that there is more reward for being in that space. At the moment Elite has a long way to go before it can match EvE for interactions.

God if I hear this whine one more time I am going to, hell I don't know, shake my head in disbelief. It seems there are a lot of players who are bored with the game, and I would guess that the majority of those come from a certain demographic age wise.
I know I am going to get roasted over these comments, how dare I suggest people should have patience, to trust FD to deliver what they promised. Remember this game has been in gestation for nearly 30 years, it has been the vision of one guy since the original Elite, I think he knows what he is doing.


Your ageism aside, there is some merit in what you say here, that said the galaxy is largely an empty vessel waiting to be filled - only a very small fraction of the galaxy has stations in them. I remember well David Braben's YouTube video ( Development Plan) back when we were backers enthusing all the possibilities that would come "sometime" after release. He hinted at some amazing gameplay opportunities - some of which are being realised in no man's sky already, and that's been in development for far less time, with far less resources than Elite Dangerous.


All I'm saying is, before you rant about whingers and young players trying to get more for nowt. Try and remember that there are some Beta Backers (of which I am proud to be one); who also think that Frontier need to engage and enthuse the community better than they are doing today. Not doing so, will (I think) make people look at alternatives that already do promise those gameplay opportunities that we all want to see.

I am sure Frontier and David will bring about the best possible space-sim over the long haul, NMS and Star Citizen will play for a different audience. They still have my confidence and I think we are in for some really amazing things over the next decade. My continued faith in the project will not waiver. But I do want to see better and more engaged communications coming out of the development team. And for the NDA and Soon(tm) to be consigned to the rubbish heap where they belong.
 
Last edited:
It is time I vent my spleen, yes this is going to be a rant, there are some things that just makes me shake my head in disbelief:

THE ROADMAP
It seems that every second thread someone will complain that FD are keeping the vaulted and mythical 'Roadmap' secret and it just isn't fair. Well what do you expect! I haven't seen too many games that the developers release a complete list of their intent with dates of intended implementation. Can you imagine just what would happen if FD did release such a document:

  • One third of the players would scream that the feature THEY wanted isn't included and they will personally hold everyone at FD responsible until all other projects are cancelled and their feature gets maximum effort to be developed immediately. They cry, they rant, they bleat that if their brilliant ideas aren't listened to, the game will be dead before Christmas
  • One third will kind of agree with what is on the Roadmap, but will demand 'minor amendments or adjustments' to every item on the Roadmap just because they 'think' they know more than the Devs and could do the programming in a few minutes (wonders why they aren't working in the industry then huh). They cry, they rant, they bleat that if their brilliant improvements aren't implemented, the game will be dead before Christmas
  • The remaining third will like what is listed in the Roadmap but totally disregard reality and demand that all features are finished and the patch released by Friday at the latest. They cry, they rant, they bleat that if the patch isn't released by Friday, the game will be dead before Christmas.

Come on guys, the staff of FD do know what they are doing, and are trying to please a very diverse group of players over a varied set of operating systems. We don't know what their plans are, maybe that is all they are are plans. Let them do their job without the continuous demands for things we may think are urgent but in the overall scheme of things could still be years away.

THE UNIVERSE
Another continuous whine I hear in these forums is: I never see another Commander, this is suppose to be a MMO, where is the PVP, there is no one to 'interact' (read shoot and annoy) with.

So lets look at the facts: The games boasts 400 BILLION (that is 400,000,000,000) Systems. Now lets assume that each system, on average has 4 planets/moons/things to fly into - that is 16,000,000,000,000 objects in the Universe. And you want all players to be jammed into a corner so you can see them? Get real, space is B I G, really really big. If FD were to introduce any semblance of realism, once you leave your starter world you would probably never see another real player again - the odds are just against it!

FD has tried to help, for those that crave human contact there are Community Quests, PowerPlay, even the creation of RES points but don't expect every player to want to participate in any of those, it isn't compulsory is it. Now FD are bringing in CQC just so those that have whined the most can engage in some pretty meaningless pew pew for bragging rights. Meanwhile the rest of us will be out exploring the galaxy.

POWER PLAY
Admission up front, I have not pledged to a power, never thought of pledging to a power, don't even read the posts about Power Play. Why, it is simple, I don't have to. And that is where I think FD made a strategic error. They let PowerPlay exist on both Solo and Open (not sure about groups but would assume there too) and then surprised when a lot of players do the dangerous stuff in Solo where they are safe.

In my own opinion, I believe PP should be all encompassing. You should not have got an option whether to participate or not. On release, every player should have had to Pledge to a power, after that it was up to them if they got involved. But by pledging, they are part of the universe and get the benefits and the danger involved. You basically have the majority of populated space involved in a war of attrition yet (guessing here, but an educated guess nevertheless) the majority of players just don't care! If PD wanted PowerPlay to work, to become part of the Universe, then it should be an option and should be restricted to Open (i.e the rewards only come to those who complete the tasks in Open).

THIS SUCKS THERE IS NOTHING TO DO
God if I hear this whine one more time I am going to, hell I don't know, shake my head in disbelief. It seems there are a lot of players who are bored with the game, and I would guess that the majority of those come from a certain demographic age wise. They are use to having structured games, with everything laid out for them in a nice linear line. They need instant gratification, if they don't they don't know if they are progressing or not. They need goals, they need an End Boss to beat. What piffle, Elite was never about that, it was always about doing your own thing. If you can't think up something to do, then maybe the fault isn't with the game but with your lack of imagination. I suspect a lot won't do some of the less action things like exploration and mining because it doesn't rake in the credits and there is no bravado or bragging attributed. Be brave, be daring, try doing something that might sound boring, you might just find it is a lot more enjoyable than you thought.

Yes, FD could do some simple things that would offer more gameplay, we have all been told that such things are coming but again, people want them NOW, right NOW or they will tell mummy.

RANT OVER
I know I am going to get roasted over these comments, how dare I suggest people should have patience, to trust FD to deliver what they promised. Remember this game has been in gestation for nearly 30 years, it has been the vision of one guy since the original Elite, I think he knows what he is doing.

I'm pretty much over with you on this. +1 Rep!

Maybe the PowerPlay option should not be enforced on everyone, though.
 
Last edited:
What certain age demographic would that be?

Please provide this data. I'll add it to my thesis, "A Study of Overly Judgmental Role-players (or Immerse This, Pal)".
I was quoting the OP. Though I'm inclined to think that the age demographic in question is actually closer to the grave than the cradle :)
Might wanna leave that out of your thesis ;)
 
You forgot to mention the complaints about 'grinding'. This is a concept that is alien to me, as I relax and enjoy my slow movement through the game in my Cobra, quietly scoffing at all those players from 'a certain age demographic' who are obsessively boring themselves to tears with the work of "Must have uber Conda rignt now so I can prove myself in PvP to mitigate my shortcomings in RL!"
;)

Thinly veiled 'those damn kids' post, well done gramps. I quietly scoff at players who make derogatory posts about a 'certain age demographic' without understanding enough about the game or the arguments being presented on its flaws to make a cogent point.
 
You forgot that there are two separate points in your statement. No-lifeing happens in every game because demographics, but it is not the same as complaints about the game's lackings. Nice conflation though.
That's a fair cop, well called. And as a Premium Beta backer I will acknowledge the game's lackings. Not going to get into them here though.
 
All the whingers are young COD players who need constant rewards.

Why can't they like boring games like I used to have to play?

Tarnation!
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom