Proposition: Anti-Empire Alliance

As many of you are probably aware, the Empire has been bailed out of trouble yet again. It is becoming increasingly apparent that the best and fastest way to get anything changed about PP is to make it a problem for the Empire.

So, I propose we start making some problems. I believe it would be in the interest of all non-Imperial powers to make peace with each other and unite against the Empire. At 6v4 the Empire consists of nearly half the powers anyway, and in terms of player counts such an alliance could even be considered necessary to achieve any semblance of a fair fight:

Major faction ranking by support


  1. Empire (3,063,735)
  2. Federation (1,562,722)
  3. Independents (654,227)
  4. Alliance (392,479)

Major faction ranking by opposition


  1. Independents (2,193,470)
  2. Federation (2,026,275)
  3. Empire (1,385,400)
  4. Alliance (1,160,080)

From Cadoc's most recent PAA, if all non-Imperial factions were to band together our total support activity would be 2,609,428. This means the total ratio of Imperial non-Imperial activity would be approximately 1.17:1. So the Empire would still be at a net advantage for total player activity, but that only shows how uniting is so much more necessary.

The opposition numbers are a little more difficult to evaluate because we only know opposition received, we don't know where it came from. But right now, non Imperial factions are being opposed nearly 5 times as much as the Empire. Clearly, we are currently attacking each other more than we are attacking the Empire. Of course this is somewhat understandable: the way the Powers are positioned in space encourages this.

Of course, I realize there are legions of merit farmers who will never read this post and will continue to blindly follow whatever path of least resistance FD lays out in front of them. Since FD supports the Empire, this means a large portion of our own player base is effectively beholden to the enemy. However, we have seen how much the Empire has struggled already while facing the least opposition of anyone in the game, and despite FD supporting them to the hilt. I believe if the organized players of all the other factions work together, we can make a dramatic difference.

I also realize of course that this would create a difficult situation for Mahon, as his space was positioned as far from the Empire as physically possible. His only close neighbors are Hudson and Winters. We may, however, be able to negotiate an expansion corridor that allows Mahon supporters to access Empire space, without having to completely encircle the Federation in the process.

It will be up to the communities of each Power to negotiate their particular terms, but I recommend some general guidelines as follows:



  1. Member Powers will refrain from undermining other member Powers to the best of their ability.
  2. Member Powers will, when requested, attempt to assist other member Powers by opposing unwanted expansions.
  3. Member Powers will cooperate with each other to undermine the Empire in an organized fashion wherever possible.
  4. Member Powers will agree to tolerate unavoidable infractions by merit grinders, and not allow our fifth columns to erode our good standing with each other.

If we work together we can defeat the Empire, and by extension defeat FD at their own game. But if we're going to make this work, we're going to need the cooperation of as many organized players as possible. We'll also need a catchy name for our organization.
 
As a follower of Delaine, I'm going to tentatively speak for my power's pledges that we're not the least bit interested. The more eyes towards the empire's half of the bubble, the less eyes on us.
 
As a follower of Delaine, I'm going to tentatively speak for my power's pledges that we're not the least bit interested. The more eyes towards the empire's half of the bubble, the less eyes on us.

Well, that's kind of the point of this. What I'm hoping is that we'll put a whole lot more pressure on the Empire, and a whole lot less pressure on everyone else. Anyone who is under particularly intense attack from the Empire would get especially relieved, as the Empire would be forced to divert forces away from them in order to deal with everyone else ganging up on them.

So the goal is to get as many eyes turned toward the Empire's half of the bubble as possible. ;)
 
Well, that's kind of the point of this. What I'm hoping is that we'll put a whole lot more pressure on the Empire, and a whole lot less pressure on everyone else. Anyone who is under particularly intense attack from the Empire would get especially relieved, as the Empire would be forced to divert forces away from them in order to deal with everyone else ganging up on them.

So the goal is to get as many eyes turned toward the Empire's half of the bubble as possible. ;)
Let me rephrase:

The rest of you, do you thing and ally against the Empire. Pledgers of Delaine will continue doing what they do.
 
Aisling was saved from a massive collapse of their systems.

Lets see what happens to Patreus at the end of this cycle.
 
I'm already undermining only imps anyways.


Yeah, technically we're something like 75% of the way there already. Both Federation powers are allied, have a non-aggression treaty with the Alliance, and are in talks with Sirius Corp with some preliminary gestures of goodwill. Operation Davy Jones seems to still be going, so Delaine is fighting the Empire whether he wants to or not.

So basically it's a matter of wrapping things up with Sirius Corp, getting Antal on board, smoothing out the independent factions' relations with each other, and then publicizing the deal in order to herd as many cats as possible in the general direction of Empire space. Setting up some kind of neutral cross-faction diplomatic space would probably help with that.

If the best we can manage diplomatically is getting all the non-Empire factions to agree to non-aggression with each other, then I propose we call it the Non Aggression Treaty Organization. :p
 
Aisling was saved from a massive collapse of their systems.

Lets see what happens to Patreus at the end of this cycle.

Yes, let's encourage Fdev not to fix bugs if they benefit a power we do not like. Perfectly acceptable reasoning!

Had Syntheng dropped off the turmoil list, as was supposed to happen, Aisling would not have been in Turmoil again this week. She would have had a positive CC of 44.

Instead, the -122 CC of Syntheng being on the list again (the bug) caused 2 further systems to fall into Turmoil this cycle, resulting in an even larger negative CC of -359
 
Yes, let's encourage Fdev not to fix bugs if they benefit a power we do not like. Perfectly acceptable reasoning!

Had Syntheng dropped off the turmoil list, as was supposed to happen, Aisling would not have been in Turmoil again this week. She would have had a positive CC of 44.

Instead, the -122 CC of Syntheng being on the list again (the bug) caused 2 further systems to fall into Turmoil this cycle, resulting in an even larger negative CC of -359

The bailout was allowing her to expand during the first time she was in turmoil, and then claiming those expansions "pulled her out".

Every other faction that has gone into turmoil has had their expansions come to a screeching halt. Without those expansions, she's still in turmoil even without Syntheng.
 
Yeah, technically we're something like 75% of the way there already. Both Federation powers are allied, have a non-aggression treaty with the Alliance, and are in talks with Sirius Corp with some preliminary gestures of goodwill. Operation Davy Jones seems to still be going, so Delaine is fighting the Empire whether he wants to or not.
:p
So what you're saying is, all eyes will go towards the other side of the bubble and federation space is even more ripe for harvest! Yay.
 
This is the number of people who do power play?


Not directly, it's the number of merits earned in "supporting actions", such as Fortifying, Expanding, and Preparing. We currently have no way to measure population count directly other than asking FD. However, IIRC Hudson actually has the most players in a single Power, but the Empire as a whole has a higher total because they have four Powers, two of which are Hudson sized. Obviously it doesn't take efficiency into account either. For example, fortifying Groombridge to 2000% still counts towards "supporting" Hudson.

So it's not a very good statistic, but it's what we have access to.

One trick though is you can divide it by about 5,000, using the logic that it's how much you need to maintain rank 5 and the vast majority of people won't do more than that (in fact a lot will do less). So for example, the Alliance's activity is the equivalent of ~78-79 people maintaining rank 5. Obviously this isn't a good measure of population either, but "R5EQ" might be an easier activity value to grasp.

Here's the major factions' activity as R5EQ:

1: Empire: 612.7
2: Federation: 312.5
3: Independents: 130.8
4: Alliance: 78.5
 
This whole proposal is ridiculous. If we all come together and break princesses glass legs FD will just pull Rocks fall, everyone dies ... aka "WHY CAN'T YOU LEAVE DUVALS ALONE!!!"

For all of it's flaws and poor implementation, I'd still like to play Powerplay. And I kinda like Mahon.. wouldn't want to read GalNet news about some freak accident and subsequent destruction of Alliance.
 
Back
Top Bottom