I combat logged a duck last night.

Menu log is legitimate as long as it's not done to avoid piracy and bounty hunting.

Menu log is different than a high wake for that high wake has counters and is an in-game mechanic where as menu log does not have counters nor is it an in-game mechanic. Not to mention players affected by menu log doesn't get notified that they are being menu logged upon.

Piracy simply cannot be done in 15 seconds, and bounty hunting cannot be done either unless the logger's in a Sidewinder or some vulnerable ship.

How do you counter a high wake?

- - - - - Additional Content Posted / Auto Merge - - - - -

Not according to FD apparently, since they specifically stated that the feature's intention is not to be used to escape piracy/bounty hunting.
That makes it an exploit, not a cheat like pulling the plug is.
 
In supercruise?
If he wakes out whilst you're both in SC, then you're out of luck as he caught on to your sneaky sneaky behaviours and rabbited. :)
That's just how it is and is not combat logging which is what the discussion is about, ergo, the assumption is one has already taken one's prey out of SC and now wants to get his mitts on that tasty phat lewtz, but the slimy cheeky git as made a runner for it by high waking (as per Ziggy's question) .. thus, you scan that wake and give chase.

- - - - - Additional Content Posted / Auto Merge - - - - -

Not really a counter is it?

And from what I have read from people using it, that is an easy 'counter' to circumvent by doing a couple of hops.

Well, it is kind of a counter. You're not stopping it from happening, but that doesn't mean when they do it you can't give chase which is, I believe, the actual intent for that mechanic. :)

If such is the case, FDev will need to change up the mechanic to allow for a true cat/mouse game that could prove really interesting to a lot of players. The thrill of the chase, and the thrill of being chased.
 
Last edited:
If he wakes out whilst you're both in SC, then you're out of luck as he caught on to your sneaky sneaky behaviours and rabbited. :)
That's just how it is and is not combat logging which is what the discussion is about, ergo, the assumption is one has already taken one's prey out of SC and now wants to get his mitts on that tasty phat lewtz, but the slimy cheeky git as made a runner for it by high waking (as per Ziggy's question) .. thus, you scan that wake and give chase.


Or the other player high wakes out after the interdiction and jumps to an other system and then jumps to the next one. In any case the player got away. So, no there is no counter to high wake.
 
No, I don't want to single out anything.
You mentioned your KoS list. I asked questions about it. This leads me to an other question.
Do you think KoS lists of pirates/player killers/rivals are OK?
Are those KoS lists promoting a witch hunt mentality?
I get the impression that KoS lists are used as a way to single out certain players and to specifically target them repeatedly. Not sure if that is something that really helps the game.

I think they are fine, it creates game play.

I'm used to MMO/guilds/faction rivalry so I'm very comfortable with the idea of having a target painted on my head for supporting/belonging to certain faction/guild/play style.


Could you provide a link to an official source where this is stated? It would help a lot in discussions about combat logging.

Support ticket that got answered.

- - - - - Additional Content Posted / Auto Merge - - - - -

Go ahead and post the response. Let those reading your misinformation decide. Because, that's exactly what you did. You cling to the interpretation that best suits your agenda, with nothing to support your claims, but innuendo.

Your entire reading of that response was shredded in another thread, not that long ago. Post it again, and see what happens.


Not at all actually, I defended my position properly, there's simply disagreements.

People that disagree with you aren't "automatically wrong," fyi.

Edit:

Actually, what is my agenda?

Having functional multiplayer game play?

That sounds about right .-.
 
Last edited:
Or the other player high wakes out after the interdiction and jumps to an other system and then jumps to the next one. In any case the player got away. So, no there is no counter to high wake.

I wasn't aware that you could lose someone so quickly.
As I stated above, if such is the case then the mechanic needs a bit of work; scanning from SC, for example, would be a good start.
 
I think they are fine, it creates game play.

I'm used to MMO/guilds/faction rivalry so I'm very comfortable with the idea of having a target painted on my head for supporting/belonging to certain faction/guild/play style.

Thanks for your answers.


To bad it's just an image, but I think it's good enough for me. I hope that FD makes a post that clarifies this on this forum. It would provide the needed information for players to play according to the rules. Players shouldn't have to interpret the TOS or EULA or vague comments of developers to know if something is allowed or not.
 
Combat loggers should be punished by restricting them to E-rated modules for a set time (duration increasing based on number of offences).. that would stop it...

Random murders and killers without any ingame reason "should be punished by restricting them to E-rated modules for a set time" ...




Sry but I can´t hear it anymore some want to join open without COD bashing in the game.

And, I never logged I always got destroyed.
 
To bad it's just an image, but I think it's good enough for me. I hope that FD makes a post that clarifies this on this forum. It would provide the needed information for players to play according to the rules. Players shouldn't have to interpret the TOS or EULA or vague comments of developers to know if something is allowed or not.

I would show the entire page but then my personal information are all over it and I already got a death threat from playing this game.

Here's the ticket number though: [h=1]#00000114601[/h]
 
Not according to FD apparently, since they specifically stated that the feature's intention is not to be used to escape piracy/bounty hunting.



Second time, and the third time will warrant a different kind of response to the left of the reply button.



Hah... it's identical to the high wake charge time, please stop throwing around false statements.

And as if you need to maneuver after 4 pip to system and 2 to engines then boost, launch HS and chaff then start the log out...



Which is funny how it happens so frequently in combat state and how other players that get affected by it doesn't get compensated for such a critical game play failure.



Oh dear, you're just throwing out all kind of false statements here aren't you...

https://forums.frontier.co.uk/showthread.php/105778-“Combat-Logging”-Update



It's almost as if you can't answer the phone and high wake at the same time...

And I don't know what you mean by griefer so I'm going to ignore that.



Except that timer makes piracy and bounty hunting improbable, which is why FD stated that it's not a feature intended for players to avoid the said interactions.



Logging out during combat is and should be a feature, just that its implementation and usage are questionable in various circumstances.




Well, I'm going to count this one with the aforementioned second warning, like I said, do it a third time and I'll respond to your blatant disregard of forum regulation differently.

- - - - - Additional Content Posted / Auto Merge - - - - -



It's more recent and relevant to the issue that I describe, so of course I'm going to take an FD employee seriously.

And either you are playing with strawman or you misread, I never said timed exit is combat logging.


1.
LOL.
I am fairly Sure its not Intended to be used for Escaping.
But see Mate. Open is not Intended for Anacondas to be Griefing Sidewinders either :)

Thing is. "Not Intended" And "Prohibited" is two different things :)
Thats why you wont be Banned for being a Griefer and Seal Clubber :)


2.
Go ahead.
See Mate. No Offense. But someone who Proudly Threatens People for Voicing their Opinion in the Forum. Should not Expect that others are Nice to them.


3.
Chass, Mines, Boosts and Changing Direction.
All of these Actions will Reduce the Damage you Take considerably. And none of them are Possible during the Delay.
But even if we assume that its the same as High Wake. That would still mean that for you the guy is gone :)


4.
Players also dont get Compensated for Griefers abusing Open to Seal Club :)
And well guess what. It happens.


5.
Thanks for the Link.
Because it does already make your Earlier Statements Wrong :)

"
For clarity’s sake, “combat logging” is when a Commander ungracefully exits the game (e.g. using ALT + F4 then shutting down the game process) to avoid defeat, destruction and damage.
"

As you can see. Using the Ingame Logout Function. IS NOT Combat Logging :)

And one more thing for you.

"
First things first: we do consider this an undesirable exploit. It’s not “part of the game”.
"

Which is exactly what I said.
It is not something they Like. But it is (At least not as of yet) a Punishable Offense :)

Which is the Reason why Posts like these are done on Reddit and not Reported to FD to have the Person doing it Punished :)


6.
Well guess what I cant lol.
To Answer the Phone I would need to leave the Room.
Which means I would need to leave the Computer.
This would mean that even if I activated the High Wake. I would Crash into the Sun afterwards and then continue Full Speed towards the Sun in normal Space while not knowing when I return.
Worse if its something I cant just leave alone after answering. I would be easy prey afterwards cause I might end up drifting there for an hour or longer :)
You got a Problem with that ? Well. Your Problem I guess *gg*


7.
Actually I think you were asked this a few Times already.
But mind Linking this "Statement of FD" Because I never saw it.
And just like the other Announcement. I get the Feeling that your just Interpreting something to your liking without FD actually ever having said anything remotely in the meaning you want to claim there :)

Also. Once more. Not Intended for this Use. And Prohibited to be Used for this. Are two Different things :)
Did you know. The Chaff Launcher was meant to be used as an One Time Short Breather. It was never meant to be used in Dual to allow Permanent Chaffing :)
But its not Prohibited to do this :p


8.
Thats your Problem. FD has Decided to Implement it in this way. This might or might not Change.
However until it is Changed. It is and stays no Violation of Rules to use Logout during Combat.


9.
And I repeat. Go ahead.
I am not going to make up Lies.

As I told you there. People like you which consider other Players "Content" and thus Hunt and Kill People which stand no Chance in the First Place for no Reason and no Gain aside from this Person feeling Grief about the Event.
And going as far as threatening to kill People on sight simply for sharing their Opinion on the Forum.
IS the Reason why hardly anyone wants to Play Open. Feel Free to Report me for saying this. But I am not going to change that Statements meaning in the slightest.





And Mate no Offense to ya.

But your own Picture.

http://i.imgur.com/PblCY9n.png?1

What he Told you in a Nutshell.

1.
Its not the Intended use to escape Piracy. BUT it is considered to be Legitimate.

2.
If you think that this System is wrong and should be Changed. Make a Suggestion for a Better System which the Devs might or might not come to use in the Future.



None of this States at any given point. That using the Ingame Logout Function. Would be Prohibited or against the Rules :)
As I said before.

You going to Kill Sideys with an Anaconda is not what Open Play was Intended for either.
However. it is not something thats Prohibited. :)



Greetz Sun
 
1.
LOL.
I am fairly Sure its not Intended to be used for Escaping.
But see Mate. Open is not Intended for Anacondas to be Griefing Sidewinders either :)

Thing is. "Not Intended" And "Prohibited" is two different things :)
Thats why you wont be Banned for being a Griefer and Seal Clubber :)


2.
Go ahead.
See Mate. No Offense. But someone who Proudly Threatens People for Voicing their Opinion in the Forum. Should not Expect that others are Nice to them.


3.
Chass, Mines, Boosts and Changing Direction.
All of these Actions will Reduce the Damage you Take considerably. And none of them are Possible during the Delay.
But even if we assume that its the same as High Wake. That would still mean that for you the guy is gone :)


4.
Players also dont get Compensated for Griefers abusing Open to Seal Club :)
And well guess what. It happens.


5.
Thanks for the Link.
Because it does already make your Earlier Statements Wrong :)

"
For clarity’s sake, “combat logging” is when a Commander ungracefully exits the game (e.g. using ALT + F4 then shutting down the game process) to avoid defeat, destruction and damage.
"

As you can see. Using the Ingame Logout Function. IS NOT Combat Logging :)

And one more thing for you.

"
First things first: we do consider this an undesirable exploit. It’s not “part of the game”.
"

Which is exactly what I said.
It is not something they Like. But it is (At least not as of yet) a Punishable Offense :)

Which is the Reason why Posts like these are done on Reddit and not Reported to FD to have the Person doing it Punished :)


6.
Well guess what I cant lol.
To Answer the Phone I would need to leave the Room.
Which means I would need to leave the Computer.
This would mean that even if I activated the High Wake. I would Crash into the Sun afterwards and then continue Full Speed towards the Sun in normal Space while not knowing when I return.
Worse if its something I cant just leave alone after answering. I would be easy prey afterwards cause I might end up drifting there for an hour or longer :)
You got a Problem with that ? Well. Your Problem I guess *gg*


7.
Actually I think you were asked this a few Times already.
But mind Linking this "Statement of FD" Because I never saw it.
And just like the other Announcement. I get the Feeling that your just Interpreting something to your liking without FD actually ever having said anything remotely in the meaning you want to claim there :)

Also. Once more. Not Intended for this Use. And Prohibited to be Used for this. Are two Different things :)
Did you know. The Chaff Launcher was meant to be used as an One Time Short Breather. It was never meant to be used in Dual to allow Permanent Chaffing :)
But its not Prohibited to do this :p


8.
Thats your Problem. FD has Decided to Implement it in this way. This might or might not Change.
However until it is Changed. It is and stays no Violation of Rules to use Logout during Combat.


9.
And I repeat. Go ahead.
I am not going to make up Lies.

As I told you there. People like you which consider other Players "Content" and thus Hunt and Kill People which stand no Chance in the First Place for no Reason and no Gain aside from this Person feeling Grief about the Event.
And going as far as threatening to kill People on sight simply for sharing their Opinion on the Forum.
IS the Reason why hardly anyone wants to Play Open. Feel Free to Report me for saying this. But I am not going to change that Statements meaning in the slightest.





And Mate no Offense to ya.

But your own Picture.

http://i.imgur.com/PblCY9n.png?1

What he Told you in a Nutshell.

1.
Its not the Intended use to escape Piracy. BUT it is considered to be Legitimate.

2.
If you think that this System is wrong and should be Changed. Make a Suggestion for a Better System which the Devs might or might not come to use in the Future.



None of this States at any given point. That using the Ingame Logout Function. Would be Prohibited or against the Rules :)
As I said before.

You going to Kill Sideys with an Anaconda is not what Open Play was Intended for either.
However. it is not something thats Prohibited. :)



Greetz Sun

Out of Rep+1 CMDR! Both sides should enjoy the game but one side forces the other to do something.

When the fight starts and one of the 2 pilots just exits the game I blame him for that but it could be another 1000 reasons why he logged out so you will never know. Maybe FD should lower the fight Rank experience when you exit a fight for any reason.
 
Back
Top Bottom