You are entitled to your opinion of course, and we'll see what Egosoft do with this particular title. I don't have any faith in them after Rebirth. All that remains to be seen is whether they learned anything from that disaster. But I do credit them with being the company that cured me of pre-ordering.
I post on there as well and have been very critical of them there as well. I've seen people affiliated with ES try and stomp on stuff on other forums like Steam where that won't wash and they don't have a free hand like they do on their own forums. They can't silence criticism so readily.
All that being said I am looking forward to X4. But you'd have to be crazy to preorder this one. I don't really believe a word they say and will only believe what I see with my own eyes
or from someone who gets early access that I trust. For me there couldn't be anyone other than Mack. His Worth A Buy of Rebirth was spot on.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LxUx96-6-dw
And as I mentioned on the Egosoft forums it will be interesting to see whether they offer review code to journos to get videos out, either before the release date or on the day if they have an embargo.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gavcvi19q1g
And if they don't offer review code? Read into that what you will.