What i wonder is this.
- They had a cheaper license with restrictions (must use CryEngine for game)
- They later purchased a FULL license in 2013...
- Would not the NEW license at least nullify the demand to use CryEngine exclusively?
No. Not unless they paid for extra capability and fewer restrictions just like Amazon did.
What they appear to have bought "later" was access to the source code so they could continue to develop the engine if CryTek folded.
Judging by the complaint, that is ALL they bought with this so-called Full License. Access to the source code.
Very likely they just added it onto their existing agreement rather than negotiate a whole new deal.
- Unless of course if they STILL got a lower priced full license...
- But at the same time they claim they stopped wanting updates or stopped receiving them in 2015 from CryTek?
- And if CryTek could not deliver updates to their own engine...
Then they would have been entitled to activate whatever penalty clauses were in the agreement, or to sue.
They could not, however, unilaterally declare the GLA null and void or do whatever they wanted. Regardless is what was happening at CryTek, CIG were still bound by their agreements.
...perhaps because they could not pay their own employees who then started working for CIG...
Which is still going to look like CIG poaching CryTek employees so that it coukd illegally modify and steal CryTeks IP.
And which is essentially what they actually did even of that wasn't their motivation. They put ex-CryTek devs to work modifying and changing a licensed engine and ended up cdlling it a different name and denying they were usinv CryEngine to the point they removed CryTeks logos and notices.
Even if CIG are innocents in this regard....it looks very bad.
"Mess" is understating the trouble they could be in if CryTek are out for blood. CryTek can make a very good case on all their charges and put a good case for maliciousness as well. And if the judge/jury accepts their copyright issues as well.....
We could be talking serious money here.